Quarantine in China: why so long and does science back it up?

For example, people entering Beijing must spend 14 days in a hotel, then seven days at home or a hotel, then another seven of “health monitoring”.

In Shenzhen, Hongkongers need to spend 14 days in quarantine then seven more being monitored for symptoms. Arrivals can ask to spend the second half of their quarantine period at home.

Some provinces have longer periods. Travellers to Shenyang, for instance, have to go through 28 days of quarantine in a hotel and then stay at home for another 28 days of health monitoring.

01:51

China steps up zero-tolerance approach to Covid-19 as Delta fears grow ahead of Beijing Olympics

China steps up zero-tolerance approach to Covid-19 as Delta fears grow ahead of Beijing Olympics

What does science say about how long quarantine should be?

The length of quarantine is based on the coronavirus’s incubation period, the time between a person contracting the virus and starting to develop symptoms.

The original Covid-19 strain has an incubation period of around six days, while the Alpha variant has a median period of about three days. The more contagious Delta variant has a four-day median incubation period, according to a study of the outbreak in Guangdong from May to June published in the EClinicalMedicine journal.

According to the Hong Kong Department of Health, most people with Covid-19 develop symptoms within 14 days of contracting the virus, with five days being the most common. 

Critics of the 21-day isolation such as epidemiologist Ben Cowling and virologist Jin Dong-Yan of the University of Hong Kong say there is no evidence to support this arrangement. Cowling has repeatedly said an exit test after 10 days of quarantine is sufficient and 14 days of quarantine is “more than enough”.

Jin said the length of quarantine could be shorter for fully vaccinated individuals.

“Vaccination can shorten the window of virus shedding,” he said, referring to the phenomenon when the virus leaves the infected person through secretions in the nose and mouth. “The vaccinated people, because they have antibodies, they are actually fighting the virus.”

Experts also say the 21-day quarantine at a hotel could raise hygiene concerns, or increase the risk of a person catching the virus at the hotel. Earlier this month, Hong Kong health authorities stepped up measures to curb the transmission of the virus in quarantine hotels after health experts said a man likely caught the more transmissible Delta Plus variant from his neighbour, when both of them opened doors to their room to collect food.
Though rarer, some studies have suggested a small proportion of cases could have incubation periods longer than 14 days. In October, a woman tested positive for Covid-19 on the 26th day after arriving in Hong Kong from the United States, with authorities classifying it as an imported case.

How long is quarantine in other places?

In countries that have chosen to live with Covid-19, there is either no quarantine or the period is short.

In Britain, for example, people who are not fully vaccinated are only required to isolate for 10 days, while those who have had the shots can skip quarantine entirely.

Quarantine measures vary by state and cities in the US. Travellers to New York state and California, for example, have no restrictions, but local authorities encourage travellers to self-quarantine for seven days if they are not fully vaccinated.

Singapore allows fully vaccinated travellers to enter the country without quarantine if they are from certain countries such as Australia, South Korea and the US. Travellers from mainland China, Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan can also enter unvaccinated and only need to self-isolate while waiting for their Covid-19 test result on arrival.

Other countries have stricter measures. Travel to New Zealand without quarantine is only available to those from some Pacific island nations. Other travellers entering the country with a “critical purpose” must be isolated for seven days at a hotel and then at home until they receive their day 9 test results.

Travellers to Taiwan need to spend 14 days in quarantine in a hotel or a group quarantine facility.

02:07

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

How likely is China to shorten its quarantine period soon?

Local governments in China have not announced plans to shorten their quarantine periods. Some, such as Guangzhou, have made isolation measures stricter because of an outbreak that started in October.

The Chinese government has also not said when it will relax border restrictions. But respiratory diseases specialist Zhong Nanshan has said China could reopen if the Covid-19 case fatality rate – the proportion of those infected who die from the disease – is controlled at 0.1 per cent and an infected person infects only an average of 1 to 1.5 people.

The global case fatality rate fell to around 2 per cent in November, according to data from Johns Hopkins University, while countries with high vaccination rates have a much lower case fatality rate.

The case fatality rate of Delta variants for vaccinated people in Britain, for example, is between 0.14 to 0.18 per cent, according to Jin.
Some travellers from Hong Kong, however, are expected to be able to enter mainland China quarantine-free from December, although there will be a limited quota of a few hundred people per day to start with.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

In the race for AI supremacy, the US and China stake different paths

As President Donald Trump meets with Chinese leader Xi Jinping this week in Beijing, the United States and China are locked in an intense competition to become the dominant player in the future of AI innovation. Analysts suggest that artificial intelligence is the most transformative general technology since electricity brought light and power to average

Mourinho Plots Arsenal Raid for Real Madrid; $175 Million Olise Offer

Sports Illustrated rounds up the latest transfer rumors and gossip from around the world. Premier League Liverpool have to think about what comes next. | Simon Stacpoole/Offside/Getty Images Paris Saint-Germain have been linked with an approach for leading Manchester United and Liverpool target Yan Diomande. The RB Leipzig forward is expected to cost upwards of $117.7 million

Jon Bernthal Shines in MCU Disney+ Special

Marvel’s latest Special Presentation, The Punisher: One Last Kill, knows exactly what fans want from Frank Castle, and for better and worse, it delivers almost precisely that. Directed by Reinaldo Marcus Green and co-written by Green alongside Jon Bernthal, this Disney+ special acts as both a brutal standalone story and a bridge toward the character’s

Why CVS Stock Topped the Market on Tuesday

Ubiquitous American pharmacy operator CVS Health (CVS +3.18%) also had a strong presence on the stock market on Tuesday. That’s because its shares traded in positive territory, rising more than 3% in contrast to the slumping S&P 500 index. New and positive notes from analysts tracking the company helped put some wind in its sails.

According to Lucas (left), the team’s chief technology officer, OctoScope is a modular autonomous underwater vehicle with interchangeable sensors and an octopus-inspired gripper.

Hong Kong teens dive deep to safeguard global shipping lanes

[The content of this article has been produced by our advertising partner.] A group of Grade 8 students from Canadian International School of Hong Kong (CDNIS) has made waves on the global innovation stage, returning from the Conrad Challenge Global Innovation Summit in Houston with multiple top honours. The team captured the coveted Innovation Summit

Betis secure top-five finish to end 20-year Champions League drought

May 12, 2026, 07:22 PM ET Real Betis is back in the Champions League after a 20-year absence. The Sevilla club beat Elche 2-1 at home on Tuesday to seal fifth LaLiga place and the final Champions League spot. Betis last played in the Champions League in the 2005-06 season, when it finished third in

World Cup Transportation Costs Significantly Reduced for Final, NY Matches amid Criticism

The fees for everything related to this summer’s World Cup in the United States, Canada and Mexico have been generally astronomical, from ticket prices to hotel fares and everything in between. Fans heading to MetLife Stadium will at least be receiving some respite, however. According to The Athletic’s Adam Crafton, “The New York/New Jersey host

Inside China’s battle for electric vehicle dominance

Inside China’s battle for electric vehicle dominance

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Journey to Great Wall of China 03:00 Inside look at quarantine facility for cruise ship passengers 01:45 NBA star dies in Los Angeles 01:19 Trump heads to high-stakes summit in China 03:37 Now Playing Inside China’s battle for electric vehicle

Dancers rehearse before an audition for the Radio City Rockettes at Radio City Music Hall in New York, on Wednesday, April 22, 2026. (AP Photo/Yuki Iwamura)

As Trump Heads to China, Past US Flubs on US Policy Toward Taiwan Can Be a Warning

The way the U.S. views Taiwan under the “One China” policy recognizes the Chinese position that Taiwan is part of China, while still allowing for informal U.S. relations with the self-governing island. It is intended to be vague — built on what’s become known as strategic ambiguity. That is, the U.S. has agreed to ensure

Iran war looms over Trump’s summit with China’s Xi Jinping

May 12, 2026, 8:06 p.m. ET WASHINGTON – Donald Trump is unlikely to get the “big, fat, hug” he’s envisioning from China’s notoriously straitlaced leader, President Xi Jinping, when he arrives in Beijing for a pomp-filled visit and talks on Iran. A firm handshake and a ceremonial red carpet is more like it. And lots

Micron flashes investors rare technical signal

Earlier on May 12, I wrote about SanDisk (SNDK) hitting 80 relative strength index, or RSI, one of the most extreme overbought readings in the stock market. The AI memory trade, I noted, was running at a pace that rarely ends quietly. Then Micron (MU) showed up with its own flashing signal too. RSI on

Dancers rehearse before an audition for the Radio City Rockettes at Radio City Music Hall in New York, on Wednesday, April 22, 2026. (AP Photo/Yuki Iwamura)

Kyrgyzstan Charges Ousted Ex-Security Boss With Coup Plot, Lawyer Says

BISHKEK, May 12 (Reuters) – Kyrgyzstan ⁠authorities ⁠have charged eight people, ⁠including powerful ex-security chief Kamchybek Tashiev, with plotting to ​seize power from President Sadyr Japarov, who has consolidated power in the ‌historically volatile central Asian country.  Tashiev ‌had ruled the former Soviet republic of 7 million in ⁠a ⁠de facto tandem with Japarov since

USD/CHF Mid-Day Outlook - ActionForex

USD/CHF Mid-Day Outlook – ActionForex

Daily Pivots: (S1) 0.7759; (P) 0.7776; (R1) 0.7791; More…. USD/CHF’s rec continues today but stays below 0.7847 resistance. Intraday bias remains neutral and further decline is expected. On the downside, decisive break of 0.7760 will resume the whole decline form 0.8041, and target 100% projection of 0.8041 to 0.7774 from 0.7923 at 0.7656. However, firm

Southampton to lock horns with Hull in Championship playoff final

Shea Charles was Southampton’s hero as they reached the Championship play-off final with a come-from-behind 2-1 win at home to Middlesbrough on Tuesday. The teams were all square deep into the second half of extra-time when Charles’ 116th-minute curling cross from the right crept through a crowd of defenders and deflected in off the inside

Arcadia mayor to plead guilty to charges of acting as Chinese agent

Arcadia Mayor Eileen Wang to plead guilty in China agent case

ARCADIA, Calif. – Former Arcadia Mayor Eileen Wang has agreed to plead guilty to federal charges alleging she secretly acted as an agent of the Chinese government. Resignation What we know: Wang, 58, resigned from office Monday, the same day the federal indictment was made public. In her resignation letter to city leaders, she described

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x