US soldiers more pro-Nato than Trump, but Europe can deter Putin alone – EUobserver

American soldiers are more pro-Nato than US president Donald Trump, but if he quit the alliance, European forces could still deter Russia, two former Nato insiders have said.

“They [US soldiers] would obey if an order came to pull back, but it’s certainly not something they would concur with … they don’t share president Trump’s opinion,” said retired Italian admiral Gianpaolo di Paola.

“The American military, if not the secretary of war [Pete Hegseth], know that the real power of the US in the world rests on its alliance with those who share their fundamental values,” he added.

“They are on the ground in Europe, they live here [in Europe], and beside any brotherly feeling they have [toward European soldiers], they know that what makes America stronger vis-à-vis Russia and China is Nato,” said Di Paola, who chaired the Nato Military Committee of national armed-forces chiefs until 2011 and who is now at the Italian Institute for International Political Studies in Rome.

Trump’s latest anti-Nato outburst came after France, Italy, and Spain declined to let him use their airspace to attack Iran.

But the military understood why US allies were so “frustrated” that even the UK also “distanced itself” from the Iran war, said Di Paola.

“There was no consultation [on Iran], no exchange of views whatsoever with allies, and that was very different from the Bushes in Iraq 1 and Iraq 2,” he said, referring to the Gulf War in 1990 and the Iraq War in 2003 under former US president George Bush and his son, George W. Bush.

Admiral (ret.) Gianpaolo Di Paola (r) on board Australian vessel HMNZS Wellington on 11 August 2010 (Source: Nato)

For his part, Jamie Shea, a former Nato official, also said: “US military officers serving in Europe … undoubtedly appreciate the value of the alliance to the US”.

But he added: “The US military is conservative in values and political outlook and no doubt many voted for Trump”.

And “the military don’t have a culture of speaking out — contrary to dissenting diplomats — and express their views publicly only after they retire”.

“They have seen Hegseth’s Pentagon fire many senior military officers who were considered woke or not sufficiently loyal. So speaking for Nato is risky,” he said.

“The Pentagon is now pulling US officers out of the Nato command structure and replacing them with Europeans, which means even fewer future US military leaders with personal experience of Nato. Not ideal,” added Shea, who was Nato’s deputy assistant secretary general for emerging security challenges until 2018 and who now teaches war studies at Exter University in the UK.

Trump’s anti-Nato tirades have posed the question of whether he would honour its Article V obligation if Russian president Vladimir Putin attacked a European ally even while the US was still nominally in the club.

But Di Paola and Shea said Putin could not do so until the Ukraine war had ended and US troops had left frontline positions in Nato battalions in the Baltic states, Poland, and Romania.

“Putin will pour himself an extra glass of vodka and feel encouraged”, by this week’s Trump anti-Nato outburst, said Shea, “but he [Putin] is still bogged down in Ukraine”.

Jamie Shea at the ‘Friends of Europe’ think-tank event in Brussels on 20 September 2018 (Source: Friends of Europe).

Di Paola said: “Putin is in trouble in Ukraine, so starting another adventure in Europe is not thinkable in any short time frame”.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Fujian courts Hong Kong travel trade with new tourism offerings and air links

Improved high-speed rail connectivity between Hong Kong and China is making Fujian province more accessible to Hong Kong travellers, prompting tourism authorities to strengthen travel trade partnerships and promote destinations beyond Wuyishan. The Fujian Provincial Department of Culture and Tourism and Nanping City Culture and Tourism Bureau recently hosted 80 travel agents from Hong Kong’s

Weekly share repurchase program transaction details

Amsterdam, November 18, 2026 SBM Offshore reports the transaction details related to its EUR227 million (US$270 million1) share repurchase program for the period November 12, 2026 through November 18, 2026. The repurchases were made under the EUR227 million share repurchase program announced on February 26, 2026 and effective from February 27, 2026. The objective of

2 of the Most Scenic Railway Routes in the World are in the UK

Here at Time Out, we need no convincing that the UK has some picture-perfect rail routes. From Jacobite steam trains to mountain-climbing tracks, we’ve even got our own ranking of the best scenic train journeys these islands have to offer.  Now, there’s even more reason to shout about the country’s rail infrastructure. Travel company Viva

Five Below vs. Uber Technologies: Which Consumer Stock Is a Better Buy for 2027?

Five Below’s aggressive store push and Uber’s global platform scale pull in very different directions, and the valuation gap may tip the balance for 2027. By Brendan Coffey – Updated Nov 18, 2026 at 10:50AM EST Key Points Five Below is leveraging an aggressive store expansion strategy to capture more of the teen and tween

Why the Anthropic IPO could be a trap for investors

Anthropic’s IPO is Wall Street’s Black Friday doorbuster. But IPO history says whatever you grab on day one usually goes on sale later. Anthropic (ANT) is expected to price its shares Wednesday evening and start trading Thursday on the Nasdaq. Orders reportedly came in at nearly seven times the shares on offer, and the top

Shabana Mahmood made the announcement in a speech to police chiefs on Wednesday (PA)

Policing in England and Wales to be restructured into 200 local commands

Policing in England and Wales will be restructured into about 200 local commands under plans announced by the Home Secretary. Each area will be about the size of a unitary authority and led by a named commander, Shabana Mahmood said in a speech to police chiefs on Wednesday. Those commands will be headed by regional

Houthi supporters carry weapons as they gather in solidarity with the movement as fighting intensifies across several fronts, in Sanaa, Yemen October 7, 2026. (REUTERS FILE)

Saudi Arabia preparing for war against Houthis to stretch into next year: Report

Saudi Arabia is preparing for war against Yemen’s Houthis to stretch well into next year, doubling down despite setbacks on the battlefield in Yemen and attacks disrupting life at home, said two Western officials briefed by Saudis on the plans. Houthi supporters carry weapons as they gather in solidarity with the movement as fighting intensifies

Stock Market Correction: 2 AI Stocks With 130% and 160% Upside, According to Wall Street.

The Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC -0.74%) entered correction territory earlier this month amid concerns about the sustainability of the artificial intelligence boom. But history says the sell-off is a buying opportunity. In the last decade, the index returned an average of 21% during the year following its first close in correction territory. Wall Street analysts see

Canadian PM Mark Carney said Canada mainly exports commodities such as canola, pork and oil to China, not sensitive technologies like advanced chips. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press v)

Carney says Canada’s growing trade ties with China are not a top concern for Trump

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on Wednesday said that Canada ’s growing trade relations with China are not a top priority for U.S. President Donald Trump, pointing out that Canada primarily exports commodities to China rather than sensitive technologies such as advanced semiconductors. Canadian PM Mark Carney said Canada mainly exports commodities such as canola,

Only in Hong Kong: the ultimate guide to the city

Planning a Hong Kong holiday? Discover the city’s best restaurants, bars, neighbourhoods, hiking trails, islands and cultural highlights in our essential guide There are cities that require a week to get under their skin; Hong Kong requires approximately 20 minutes. That’s roughly how long it takes after emerging from the MTR into Central to find

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Russia’s Putin Says He Expects ‘Big Potential Benefit’ From Meeting With Trump and Xi

Nov 18 (Reuters) – Russian President Vladimir ⁠Putin ⁠said on Wednesday ⁠he expected a “big potential benefit” from his ​trilateral meeting this week with US President Donald ‌Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping.  Putin, ‌who is due to hold talks ⁠with Trump ⁠and Xi on Thursday, was speaking at the opening ​ceremony of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation

The changing stock market reaction to inflation surprises

I keep coming back to this post on why I think working in finance is so fascinating and never boring. Things change all the time. And even if the same thing happens again and again, stocks, bonds and other assets react differently to the same event all the time. That post looked at stock market

A man stands in front of an exhibition stand of Russia's State Atomic Energy Corporation Rosatom at the Russian Energy Week international forum in Moscow, Russia, October 15, 2026. (REUTERS)

Bangladesh’s first nuclear plant starts supplying power, builder Rosatom says

Bangladesh’s first nuclear power plant has started producing electricity, its Russian builder Rosatom said on Wednesday, as the south Asian nation joins a list of more than 30 countries with operating nuclear reactors. A man stands in front of an exhibition stand of Russia’s State Atomic Energy Corporation Rosatom at the Russian Energy Week international

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x