As explained by Prime Minister Boris Johnson on the day he presented the plan, the agreement with Kigali had “no limits”: Rwanda would, in principle, have “the capacity to relocate tens of thousands of people over the coming years.” Johnson added that, if the pilot program worked, women and children would be included. The reality, however, has been very different. After investing more than 700 million pounds in it and building ad hoc two centers to house the migrants, only four people were transferred to Rwanda. And not because they were deported there, but because they voluntarily accepted the transfer in exchange for 3,000 pounds each.
The failure of the British experience is not the only precedent that calls into question the European initiative, announced yesterday by five European Union countries – Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece, and the Netherlands – to create the first migrant deportation center outside community borders, in this case, also in Rwanda. In Italy, the courts initially blocked Giorgia Meloni’s plan to expel migrants to Albania.
The Italian case, however, has a second part. After the initial hurdles, Meloni reformulated the agreement with Tirana in March 2025 and converted the Gjader center into a repatriation facility. According to a report by Amnesty International published in August 2026, Italy has transferred more than 570 migrants there since the start of the program. The first 74, intercepted in the Mediterranean and sent to Albania between October 2024 and January 2025 to process their asylum claims there, had to return to Italy after a few days by court order.
However, since April 2025, Rome has been sending adult men there who were already interned in the country and who have a deportation order or a final asylum denial. More than 500 people have reached the Albanian facilities through this route, still far from the initial goal of processing up to 36,000 migrants a year.
London’s main obstacle was the courts, although there was also criticism from the Anglican Church and, even, from the then Crown Prince Charles of England, who in private described the initiative as “appalling”. But moral considerations and legal barriers do not seem to have stopped the five European partners, who guarantee that the initiative is legal.
Challenges from human rights advocacy organizations and specialized lawyers led to the intervention of the European Court of Human Rights and various British judicial bodies. The first flight, initially planned with 37 people for June 2022, saw the list of deportees reduced successively to seven, four, and one, until it was finally suspended.
Shifting the responsibility
The guarantees of the asylum procedure also generated strong controversy. The plan stipulated that Rwanda would examine the migrants’ requests within a maximum period of three months: those who obtained refugee status could reside in the country, while the rest would be repatriated to their places of origin. Humanitarian organizations warned, however, that the system could facilitate indiscriminate expulsions and expose migrants to abuse in a country with a questioned track record regarding human rights.
In fact, the British government itself had expressed before the United Nations its concern regarding restrictions on civil and political liberties and freedom of the press in Rwanda. A report by a British parliamentary committee on the country went as far as to openly question the democratic nature of Paul Kagame’s regime, who has been in power since 2000.
The deterrent effectiveness of the initiative, one of Johnson’s central arguments at the time of announcing it, was also called into question. The government claimed that the deportations would dismantle the smuggling business and prevent migrants from using the asylum system to stay in the United Kingdom. But boat arrivals continued even on the day the aforementioned first flight to Kigali was scheduled to take place, when more than 300 people landed on British shores.
Furthermore, the program entailed a significant economic cost. London had agreed to an initial payment of 120 million pounds to Rwanda, in addition to the costs of reception and processing of the applications. A parliamentary committee warned that the cost would be equivalent to that of the British asylum system, which questioned the economic advantages of outsourcing its management. Rwanda has claimed more than 100 million pounds in compensation for the breach of the agreement, but the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled last June that the United Kingdom did not have to pay any compensation.
The British experience shows that outsourcing migration control does not curb irregular arrivals, but rather can increase dependence on human trafficking networks. This is what Ahlam Chemlali concludes, a migration researcher and co-director of the Centre for Coercion and Accountability at the University of Aalborg (Denmark). “These centers do not solve the migration problem, but rather shift responsibilities to third countries and make the migrants’ journeys longer, more expensive, and more dangerous,” she asserts in an article published this Tuesday on the academic website The Conversation.
















