The S&P 500’s Shiller P/E Is Above 40. History Says What Happened the Only Other Time.
The S&P 500 (SNPINDEX:^GSPC) has risen around 11% this year as I write. And by one valuation gauge with data going back to 1871, investors have rarely paid more for it.
That gauge is the cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio (CAPE ratio), popularized by Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller. Rather than a year of profits, it divides the index’s price by its average earnings over the previous 10 years, adjusted for inflation, which is meant to smooth out both recessions and boom years.
Missed Nvidia in 2009? This Rare Signal Is Flashing Again. In 2009, a “Double Down” signal flashed for a little-known chipmaker called Nvidia. For the first time in years, that same “Total Conviction” signal is flashing for a company 1/100th the size of Nvidia. Continue »
As the market closed Oct. 28, the ratio was 41.04. Its long-term average in monthly data is around 17.
Readings above 40 have been rare. The ratio has cleared that mark every month since May.
Until this year, it had done that only once — from January 1999 through September 2000, when it peaked at 44.19 in December 1999. Even in September 1929, right before that year’s crash, it was around 33.
How did the S&P 500 do after its only other run above 40? I used the index’s close on the first trading day of each of those 21 months. Next I measured the price change to the first trading day of the same month one, five, and 10 years later. (These numbers don’t count dividends.)
Image source: Getty Images.
One more good year
The short term depended a lot on when an investor started. Eleven of the 12 readings from 1999 were followed by gains over the next year, including a rise of around 18% from the Jan. 4, 1999, close. And the index climbed around 20% in 1999 alone, with the ratio above 40 the entire time.
Readings from 2000 went the other way. All nine were followed by a lower index a year later, with losses of around 3% to over 25%. The biggest came from the start of September 2000, the ratio’s last month above 40. The S&P 500 closed at 1,520.77 on Sept. 1, 2000, and a year later it was down to around 1,133.
That means anyone who sold the first time the ratio passed 40 would’ve missed a strong year.
Five and 10 years later, all 21 were lower
Over longer periods, the start date mattered far less. Five years later, every one of the 21 readings was followed by a lower S&P 500, down around 6% to 22%. Ten years later, all 21 were still lower, by about 18% to 43%.
From its close of 1,397.72 on Dec. 1, 1999 (the start of the month the ratio peaked), the index was around 6% lower a year later, about 15% lower after five years, and about 21% lower after 10.
Along the way, it sank to a low of 776.76 on Oct. 9, 2002 — around 49% below its Sept. 1, 2000, close. And from both those start dates, the index took over 12 years to get back above its starting level for good.
Reinvested dividends limited the damage, but they didn’t undo it. Even with them, the total return version of the S&P 500 was still around 14% lower 10 years after Sept. 1, 2000.
The valuation itself fell hard over that decade. The ratio dropped from 43.77 in January 2000 to around 21 in January 2010, under half its earlier level.
What can one episode show investors?
True, the 1999-2000 record looks lopsided. But it’s actually one episode, not 21 separate ones. These monthly starting dates overlap a lot, so they arguably act more like a single data point than a pattern.
Of course, the 10-year windows also include the 2008 financial crisis, which had its own causes.
The ratio can also read high for a mechanical reason. Because it uses a 10-year average of earnings, a stretch of fast profit growth can leave that average far behind what companies earn today, which raises the ratio compared with a regular price-to-earnings ratio.
Still, I think the episode is worth taking seriously for what it says about buying at this sort of price and holding for a decade. I wouldn’t rely on the ratio for timing, though. It’s now been above 40 since May, and in 1999 it stayed there for a full year as stocks kept climbing.
I wouldn’t get out of the S&P 500 over a reading of 41. But I’d expect less from the next 10 years than the past 10, when the index gained around 14% a year on price alone.
Should you buy stock in S&P 500 Index right now?
Before you buy stock in S&P 500 Index, consider this:
The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and S&P 500 Index wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.
Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004… if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $334,793!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005… if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $1,257,420!*
Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 874% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 209% for the S&P 500. Don’t miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors.
Daniel Sparks and his clients do not have positions in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Investors are always on the lookout for the next big thing in technology, and this time around, it may be quantum computing. It offers us an enormous step up from classical computing, allowing us to solve many of today’s impossible problems. While classical systems use bits to store information in the form of a zero
A roaring market is obviously good news for stock and commodity exchanges, because it prompts more revenue-generating trading activity. To this end, with the market still within sight of record highs, the exchanges are doing pretty well, although they’re not at the levels they reached earlier this year, when over $1 trillion in investments exchanged
Lumentum Holdings (NASDAQ:LITE) did just about everything right this morning, and its stock got punished anyway. Shares of the laser and optics specialist were down 14.9% as of 12:55 p.m. ET. Q1 2027 results beat Wall Street’s expectations and the company agreed to be acquired by Marvell Technology (NASDAQ:MRVL) in an all-stock deal. Marvell’s stock
Shares of AppLovin (APP +0.15%) are down 65% so far in 2026, making it the worst performer in the S&P 500 as of the end of October. It’s been an abysmal performance for the tech stock. And rather than one big sell-off, it’s been a continually slow, painful decline for the company’s shareholders. The adtech
California Resources has rewarded long term holders over the past five years, which naturally puts a spotlight on whether the current share price really lines up with what its sales can support. After a period that includes both a sizeable reported loss and new clean power ambitions, the question is how much revenue strength the
Taiwan’s AI stock boom is creating more ways for investors to profit from its chip supply chain, making early-stage startups a tougher pitch. Taiwan’s benchmark Taiex index is up more than 50% this year, making it the world’s best-performing major index after pulling ahead of South Korea’s Kospi. The gains extend well beyond Taiwan Semiconductor
MGM Q3 deep dive: margin recovery and digital growth offset soft leisure demand Hospitality and casino entertainment company MGM Resorts (NYSE:MGM) met Wall Street’s revenue expectations in Q3 2026, but sales were flat year on year at $4.21 billion. Its non-GAAP loss of $0.11 per share was significantly below analysts’ consensus estimates. Is now the
Shares of Amplitude (NASDAQ:AMPL) were among the winners last month as the data analytics software stock benefited from a broader rotation out of AI infrastructure stocks into undervalued stocks like Amplitude, and it also got a number of positive analyst notes during the month. Though there was no major company-specific news out on Amplitude, those
It’s not just the neoclouds and hyperscalers that investors are anxious about. Options data show a surge in bearish trading in anticipation of both Palantir and Apple earnings Monday afternoon. The two stocks have been on trajectories that are distinct from the broader AI trade – with Apple, in particular, trading almost inversely to the
Five days after Oracle (ORCL) promised to rein in its fundraising, it raised the full $20 billion in a single day. Oracle kicked off a $10 billion bond sale Monday and, at the same time, filed to sell $10 billion of stock. Together, that’s every dollar of new debt and stock it said at last
Wall Street mostly swept up last week’s tech wreckage Monday. Chip stocks kept tracking mud back through the house. About 7 in 10 S&P 500 stocks rose Monday, yet nearly every chip stock fell, and the group shed more than $400 billion in market value in a single session, by Yahoo Finance calculations. Intel (INTC)
Vancouver, British Columbia–(Newsfile Corp. – November 2, 2026) – Talent Infinity Resource Developments Inc. (CSE: TICO) (OTCQB: TIRDF) (FSE: ON8) (the “Company” or “TICO“) announces that it has completed the cancellation of stock options described in its news release dated October 14, 2026. Further to its news release dated October 14, 2026, issued at the
The “Magnificent Seven” stocks are a collection of the leading tech stocks in the world. But this year, they haven’t been doing well. The S&P 500 has surprisingly been outperforming nearly all of them. It’s particularly surprising given that the broad index is up only 11%. It’s doing well, but that doesn’t seem like a
Wall Street mostly swept up last week’s tech wreckage Monday. Chip stocks kept tracking mud back through the house. About 7 in 10 S&P 500 stocks rose Monday, yet nearly every chip stock fell, and the group shed more than $400 billion in market value in a single session, by Yahoo Finance calculations. Intel (INTC)
Oracle (ORCL -8.76%) shares have plunged about 15% since Wednesday’s close, when the tech giant held its investor day and was worth about $437 billion. It’s now worth about $372 billion, marking a steep loss of over $60 billion in less than a week. The latest leg down came on Monday, as shares fell another
Buckle up for another wild week in markets. Investors are still coming off a roller coaster ride that included a painful sell-off in the AI trade on Friday, but the volatility isn’t expected to die down soon, and a handful of potential catalysts is lies ahead for investors. This week’s docket includes more Big Tech
The highly anticipated Anthropic IPO could be one of the largest in history, with an expected valuation of between $1.5 billion and $2 billion. The Anthropic hype train, however, was knocked off the tracks a bit when the company filed its registration documents on Oct. 26. While Anthropic posted strong revenue growth in the first
Market Closed – 01:30:00 2026-11-02 am EST 5-day change 1st Jan Change 2,271.00 JPY -2.39% -1.30% +14.99% Published on 11/02/2026 at 01:57 am EST MT Newswires This article is reserved for our members. Log in to continue Log inCreate an account 01:57am Itochu Repurchases 46.2 Billion Yen of Treasury Stock in October MT Oct. 30
Investors will be watching Apple’s margins for whether the company can absorb higher memory-chip costs. Big Tech’s AI spending is squeezing cash flow, pushing companies toward more borrowing and stock sales. Friday’s jobs report will help determine whether slowing hiring changes expectations for another Federal Reserve rate hike in December. Apple (AAPL) earnings on Monday,
Tech stocks aren’t getting shredded for any old reason. It’s actually very fundamental: Free cash flow is drying up for Big Tech leaders, and capex is rising dramatically. Investors are questioning whether this ratio is totally out of whack, given more realistic growth projections for AI. The combined capex of Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Microsoft
