Ramona trustees consider limiting cell phone use on campuses – San Diego Union-Tribune

A proposal that would keep students in transitional kindergarten through 12th grade from using their cell phones in class except for educational purposes, but allow the older students to use them at lunch time, was discussed by Ramona Unified School District trustees on Jan. 20.

Trustees, who are preparing to adopt a policy on student use of mobile communication devices, heard two proposed policy options.

Trustees preferred option 2, which details expectations for student use of mobile devices in transitional kindergarten through eighth grade and separately details expectations for grades 9-12. One of the main differences for the upper grades would be allowing students to use their devices during the entire lunch period.

Kerri Bjork, director of the district’s multi-tiered support systems, told trustees that state Assembly Bill 3216 requires the school board to adopt a policy limiting or prohibiting student smartphone use while on school grounds or under district supervision by July 1. Ramona’s policy is expected to begin at the start of the next school year.

“The heart and intention of the legislation is to have cell phone-free schools,” said Bjork, noting that it addresses issues related to cell phone use such as anxiety, social disengagement, and filming fights on campus. “This is something I believe our staff are looking for.”

Ramona’s policy would apply to mobile communication devices including but not limited to cell phones and smartphones, smart watches, wearable communication devices, earbuds, wireless headphones and any personal device capable of sending or receiving messages, images, recordings, notifications or accessing the internet.

Ramona High School seniors' Ingrid Ferguson and Dylan Myrick show campus Security Guard Marc Boykin their student ID's on their cell phones as they leave the campus for lunch. (Stephanie Rene Ogilvie)

Stephanie Rene Ogilvie

Ramona High School seniors Ingrid Ferguson and Dylan Myrick show campus Security Guard Marc Boykin their student IDs on their cell phones as they leave the campus for lunch. (Stephanie Rene Ogilvie)

Interim Superintendent Leslie Wilson said staff will bring back option 2 with staff revisions for trustee consideration at the next meeting on Feb. 12.

Option 2 would allow devices to be used during lunch in grades 9-12. Otherwise, devices must be stored away during instructional time, including class periods, assemblies and other structured learning environments unless teachers or administrators allow their use for instructional or essential approved purposes.

In grades TK-8, devices must remain off or in silent mode at all times during the school day unless exceptions are approved, according to the draft policy. Students would be allowed to use their devices during the first six minutes and last six minutes of the lunch period.

Student school board representatives voiced their concerns about the proposed policy at the meeting.

Ingrid Ferguson, Ramona High School’s ASB president and school board representative, said students at her campus are accustomed to texting and communicating with each other electronically during their passing periods and at lunch.

“Taking that away would be something we would need to get used to,” Ferguson told the trustees, adding that she uses mobile technology in classes such as anatomy and chemistry. “I’m a good student and I put my phone away in class, but if I can’t have it during the break I would be peeved. I think that would be bad.”

Edan Hollander, Montecito High School’s student school board representative, said there’s value in being able to search online for information at school.

“Phone use does increase anxiety,” he said, acknowledging some downsides to mobile devices. “It’s because of social media and the amount of consumption. A majority of us have Instagram and TikTok because it’s fun.”

School Board President Daryn Drum said the district began implementing a practice of limiting access to cell phones beginning in 2024, but it was not a board policy.

“We were far ahead of the curve,” said Drum, who noted he is opposed to banning cell phones on campuses completely and favors a reasonable solution to including them at the schools. “If I remember correctly, there were not a lot of people beating our door down objecting to the practice we enacted as a district in 2024. That was surprising, I expected more.”

Drum said the school board would not dictate how a mobile communication device policy would be implemented in the classrooms and throughout the district.

“We just give the policy and say, ‘Make this operational,’” he said. “I’m not a teacher or a principal. I don’t presume to tell them how to do this. We stick to a high level and say, ‘You figure it out.’”

From left, Ramona High freshmen Hailey Gonzalez and Emily Phelan use their phones during breaks to check for updates on their school assignments. (Stephanie Rene Ogilvie)

Stephanie Rene Ogilvie

From left, Ramona High freshmen Hailey Gonzalez and Emily Phelan use their phones during breaks to check for updates on their school assignments. (Stephanie Rene Ogilvie)

Dan Summers said he and the other board members are working on a compromise position that would largely restrict cell phone use on campuses and during school activities but still allow students to communicate.

“I have no idea how I got through my entire course of education without a cell phone,” Summers told his fellow trustees. “What I did was communicate one-on-one with everyone I knew at school and because I communicated I developed the skills to communicate well.

“I understand the negative parts of having cell phones on campus is significant,” he said. “On the other hand, it’s 2026 and technology has come a long way.”

Trustee Rodger Dohm, a teacher in the Poway Unified School District who has been an educator for 30 years, said one of the district’s goals is to teach students to use technology, including cell phone cameras and the internet, in responsible ways.

Ramona Unified staff developed the draft policy based in part on feedback from a districtwide survey, Bjork said. The survey results, and the draft board policy, were reviewed by the District Advisory Council to get their input and recommendations, a staff report said.

Bjork said school districts in Oceanside and Palo Alto have reported positive results from similar policies. Students at other districts who struggle with anxiety are engaging with their peers and there is greater enforcement with a formal policy in place, she said.

According to option 2, students may possess mobile communication devices on school grounds. However, use is restricted according to grade level. Devices must not disrupt instruction, school activities or a safe learning environment, the draft option states. Devices shall not be used in any manner that infringes on the privacy rights of any other person, it states.

The policy is expected to incorporate exceptions for health and disability needs in addition to allowing devices to be used in an emergency situation involving an immediate threat to student safety or when a student is directed to use a device by staff or emergency responders.

Trustee Dawn Perfect said she is in favor of including language to allow a site administrator to create exceptions on a case-by-case basis. Trusted adults should be aware that a student is struggling and needs to call or text a parent or guardian, she said.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Prediction: These Will Be AMD’s and Nvidia’s Stock Prices by 2028

Advanced Micro Devices (NASDAQ:AMD) and Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) have experienced contrasting fortunes on the stock market in 2026, with one clearly outperforming the other. Nvidia, the artificial intelligence (AI) pioneer, has had a forgettable year. Shares of the semiconductor bellwether have dropped 20% in 2026, as of this writing. The company’s outstanding growth has been overshadowed

Prediction: Dec. 9 Will Be a Huge Day for the Stock Market

Multiple market-moving events are set to converge. By Adam Levy – Nov 22, 2026 at 11:33AM EST Key Points The FOMC is expected to raise the target federal funds rate. Broadcom will act as a barometer for other AI stocks when it reports earnings. Micron could be a huge buyer of its own stock starting

The EU is India's largest trading partner in goods among individual blocs. (DPR PMO/Representative Image)

India, EU likely to sign FTA during PM Modi’s Brussels visit in December

India and the 27-nation bloc European Union (EU) are likely to sign the free trade agreement (FTA) on December 16, an official said. The EU is India’s largest trading partner in goods among individual blocs. (DPR PMO/Representative Image)more The two sides concluded the negotiations for the pact on January 27 this year. European Union’s Ambassador

GLOBAL MARKET CALL: Stocks Are Cheaper Everywhere

The AI selloff went global last week. Investors fled to government bonds, sending yields lower almost everywhere. Global profits are still booming, yet valuations fell further. We see the selloff as a buying opportunity. South Korean stocks are pricing in an earnings bust that analysts don’t see coming. In Japan, hotter inflation is raising the

Damage from vandalism at a property in Sunningdale Avenue, Walker, Newcastle Upon Tyne.

InYourArea – Local News and Information

In your Journal briefing today: • A deal is finalised to buy Newcastle’s Old Post Office and turn it into a national writing centre • Concerns over an attack on a proposed HMO • Newcastle push the champions all the way • Sunderland extend unbeaten run New writing centre in Old Post Office A deal

From Anthropic to Nvidia, Wall Street just had a bizarre, wild week

I have seen a lot in the investing world over the past 20 years. Mostly good. A lot of bad. But I have to say: This past week will live on with me until I retire. Anthropic (ANT) just put a $1.2 trillion price tag on the AI dream. The AI lab opened its first

Black Friday Fitness Deals 2026: Health, Gear & More

Black Friday has become something of an endurance event in its own right. There are emails to negotiate, countdown clocks to ignore and an extraordinary number of products apparently capable of transforming your life before midnight on Monday. Somewhere among all that noise, however, are some genuinely interesting savings. With Black Friday falling on 27

Trump’s calls to Kim go unanswered, letter returned unopened: Report | World News

Trump’s calls to Kim go unanswered, letter returned unopened: Report | World News

US President Donald Trump tried to contact North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in 2025 but received no response, The Wall Street Journal reported, citing people familiar with the matter. Trump subsequently wrote to Kim. White House officials arranged for the letter to be handed to a North Korean diplomat outside Pyongyang’s UN mission in

What Your Lifestyle Could Be Doing to Your Dog’s Gut Microbiome 

The way people live may influence their dogs‘ health more than previously understood, according to new research suggesting that human lifestyles help shape the gut microbiome of their canine companions. The study, published in the journal mSystems, analyzed the gut microbiome of more than 250 dogs across Nepal, Thailand, the United Arab Emirates and the

School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): Top National, International News

School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): Top National, International News

Today’s headlines bring together the stories shaping India and the world. School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): From India-China border talks in Arunachal Pradesh to Prime Minister Modi’s remarks on artificial intelligence, today’s headlines bring together the stories shaping India and the world. Internationally, developments involving the US, Russia, Nepal, Indonesia and the European Union

Where Will Micron Stock Be in 3 Years?

Micron’s stock has plunged in recent months, but the next three years could still be lucrative. By Keith Speights – Nov 22, 2026 at 4:26AM EST Micron Technology (MU -13.89%) has lost nearly half its market cap in five months. That’s the bad news. The good news is that the semiconductor stock is still up

A battered stock market looks for the bottom: What to watch this week

It’d be impossible to top last week’s action. Anthropic (ANT) went public, marking the first pure-play generative AI lab to list on the public market in the US. GTA VI was released to near-unanimous adoration and record sales. President Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin held their first trilateral talks. And

As the talks entered unprecedented overtime, COP31 President Murat Kurum urged countries to find common ground and adopt the proposed text. (REUTERS)

COP31 becomes longest-ever UN climate summit, EU rejects ‘greenwashing of fossil fuels’

The COP31 in Turkey became the longest-ever United Nations climate conference, with the summit running 44 hours past its scheduled closing time as negotiations over a final agreement remain deadlocked. As the talks entered unprecedented overtime, COP31 President Murat Kurum urged countries to find common ground and adopt the proposed text. (REUTERS)more This comes even

AMD Stock Just Plunged on a Short-Seller Report. Is This a Golden Buying Opportunity?

AMD’s fundamentals are more than just a whisper of “buy the dip.” By Prosper Junior Bakiny – Nov 22, 2026 at 3:30AM EST Key Points Hunterbrook alleges AMD firmware reached a blacklisted Chinese company. However, AMD has denied the claims, and another news outlet has been unable to verify them. With the allegations unproven and

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

COP31 Climate Deal in the Balance After Fractious Talks

ANTALYA, Turkey, Nov ⁠22 (Reuters) – ⁠The COP31 climate ⁠talks in Turkey neared a ​close on Sunday with a ‌deal far from certain ‌as countries argued over ⁠the ⁠pace of the clean-energy transition, the role ​of carbon capture, and financial support for developing nations. Below are reactions ​from delegates: COP31 PRESIDENT MURAT KURUM “No party

How Will Markets Trade Next Week?

Thank you for subscribing to my posts. If you’re not yet a paying supporter, please consider becoming one. That’ll allow you to DM me with questions and comments. Your contribution will help cover the cost of the data I use in my posts, which I fund out of my own pocket. Thanks so much for

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x