‘I believe in truth and transparency’ 

Elon Musk took the witness stand at San Francisco Federal Court Wednesday, offering his defense against allegations that he engaged in a fraudulent campaign against Twitter and its management team in the months before he closed a deal to buy the social media platform for $44 billion in October 2022 and rebranding it X. 

Investors, who are seeking as much as $1 billion in damages, are suing Musk, arguing he posted tweets and made statements designed to drive down the value of the company’s shares in order to get a better deal, or abandon his acquisition.

For his appearance at trial, Musk’s handlers tried, and failed, to win their boss a parking spot in the garage beneath the Phillip Burton Federal Building at 450 Golden Gate Ave., which is reserved for officials, judges, and diplomats. Like everyone else, Musk had to enter at the ground level. Unlike the public, he got to skip the security line, and was accompanied by his private detail through the courthouse hallways. 

On breaks in the testimony, everyone in the courtroom was asked to wait for Musk to leave first.

Dressed in a black suit and tie, Musk sat with his lawyers, vigorously chewing gum, as he waited for the jury. When he was called to the witness stand, Musk faced shareholders, including John Garrett, an elderly man sitting in his wheelchair beside the lawyers representing him. The shareholders, including Garrett, are part of a class of potentially millions of investors. 

By the time Musk took the stand, his gum was gone.

Musk’s lawyers have built his defense on an argument that Twitter was plagued by fake accounts, spam, and bots before he purchased it. Musk repeatedly testified that the company underestimated the number of such accounts at about five percent. Musk, his lawyers claim, was determined to unearth the true figure.

The problem with the argument is that despite whatever his misgivings, on April 25, 2022, Musk signed a “seller-friendly” agreement to buy Twitter at a premium. Musk waived due-diligence, giving up many rights to extract information from the company before buying it. 

Jurors were shown previous video testimony Musk made agreeing that the deal didn’t require Twitter to provide data about fake accounts or bots, or explain how it estimated the number of those accounts. Lawyers for the investors argue that the tweets and statements Musk made after signing the agreement systematically eroded Twitter’s share price.

Under questioning from the plaintiffs’ lawyer Aaron Arnzen, Musk testified that he knew he had millions of followers on Twitter. Asked whether he understood that his posts might be “material” to investors and that they could move share prices, Musk repeatedly hedged.

“My tweets perhaps have some effect, but seem to go in random directions. It’s not a certain thing,” Musk said. Sometimes, he testified, he’s posted that Tesla’s shares are overpriced only to watch them go higher.

“I believe in truth and transparency,” Musk testified. “I speak what’s on my mind, the market determines whether it’s material or not.”

Jurors were shown a May 13, 2022 tweet from Musk saying that the Twitter deal was “temporarily on hold,” a key piece of evidence in the case. Twitter shares closed down about nine percent that day. Arnzen asked, perhaps based on quotes in the press from Musk, if this was one of Musk’s “incredibly stupid” tweets?

“It might not have been my wisest tweet,” Musk said, adding that “incredibly stupid” might be too strong. “Although, if it led to this trial, it might qualify as such.”

“I’m not saying ‘I’m not going to do the deal,’” Musk said, explaining the May 13, 2022 tweet. “It’s like saying you’re going to be late for a meeting. But it doesn’t mean that you’re not going to have the meeting.”

Musk ultimately ended up buying Twitter in October 2022 after the company sued him in Delaware to make good on his original offer six months earlier.

Musk’s appearance followed testimony Tuesday from Jared Birchall, who handles his personal finances for his family office in Austin. On the witness stand, Birchall sounded more like a devotee of a cult at a Texas compound than a financial advisor, favorably referring to his boss as a “builder, engineer, creator, and entrepreneur.” 

Under questioning from a lawyer representing the plaintiffs, Birchall was stubborn and unyielding, saying he couldn’t remember the facts he was being asked about. 

When one of Musk’s lawyers cross-examined him, his answers flowed easily.

Including his security detail, Musk’s home office consists of between 40 and 50 people, Birchall said. “We have grown over the years,” he explained. About 15 members of the group are devoted to the billionaire’s finances. He described a team constantly in motion, juggling the demands of the founder of X, Tesla, SpaceX, Nuralink, and xAI. 

Birchall was asked what it’s like working for Musk?

“It’s very inspiring to work on projects and problems that are meant to help the future of humanity,” Birchall, under oath, said.

Birchall testified about a May 6, 2022 meeting Musk had with Twitter’s top executives to discuss the number of fake and spam accounts, and bots, on the platform. Ned Segal, Twitter’s chief financial officer at the time, said the company relied on a manual method to count the number of fake accounts, according to Birchall, who testified that the explanation was “uninspiring and nonsensical.”

Birchall was asked about Musk’s response to Segal’s explanation.

“Did you just hear what I just heard?” Musk said, according to Birchall. The billionaire added: “My spidey senses were right.”

The trial is scheduled to conclude March 19. For the investors to win, they must convince the jury of three women and five men to unanimously conclude that Musk undertook the alleged campaign of tweets and statements with the intent to commit fraud.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Prediction: These Will Be AMD’s and Nvidia’s Stock Prices by 2028

Advanced Micro Devices (NASDAQ:AMD) and Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) have experienced contrasting fortunes on the stock market in 2026, with one clearly outperforming the other. Nvidia, the artificial intelligence (AI) pioneer, has had a forgettable year. Shares of the semiconductor bellwether have dropped 20% in 2026, as of this writing. The company’s outstanding growth has been overshadowed

Prediction: Dec. 9 Will Be a Huge Day for the Stock Market

Multiple market-moving events are set to converge. By Adam Levy – Nov 22, 2026 at 11:33AM EST Key Points The FOMC is expected to raise the target federal funds rate. Broadcom will act as a barometer for other AI stocks when it reports earnings. Micron could be a huge buyer of its own stock starting

The EU is India's largest trading partner in goods among individual blocs. (DPR PMO/Representative Image)

India, EU likely to sign FTA during PM Modi’s Brussels visit in December

India and the 27-nation bloc European Union (EU) are likely to sign the free trade agreement (FTA) on December 16, an official said. The EU is India’s largest trading partner in goods among individual blocs. (DPR PMO/Representative Image)more The two sides concluded the negotiations for the pact on January 27 this year. European Union’s Ambassador

GLOBAL MARKET CALL: Stocks Are Cheaper Everywhere

The AI selloff went global last week. Investors fled to government bonds, sending yields lower almost everywhere. Global profits are still booming, yet valuations fell further. We see the selloff as a buying opportunity. South Korean stocks are pricing in an earnings bust that analysts don’t see coming. In Japan, hotter inflation is raising the

Damage from vandalism at a property in Sunningdale Avenue, Walker, Newcastle Upon Tyne.

InYourArea – Local News and Information

In your Journal briefing today: • A deal is finalised to buy Newcastle’s Old Post Office and turn it into a national writing centre • Concerns over an attack on a proposed HMO • Newcastle push the champions all the way • Sunderland extend unbeaten run New writing centre in Old Post Office A deal

From Anthropic to Nvidia, Wall Street just had a bizarre, wild week

I have seen a lot in the investing world over the past 20 years. Mostly good. A lot of bad. But I have to say: This past week will live on with me until I retire. Anthropic (ANT) just put a $1.2 trillion price tag on the AI dream. The AI lab opened its first

Black Friday Fitness Deals 2026: Health, Gear & More

Black Friday has become something of an endurance event in its own right. There are emails to negotiate, countdown clocks to ignore and an extraordinary number of products apparently capable of transforming your life before midnight on Monday. Somewhere among all that noise, however, are some genuinely interesting savings. With Black Friday falling on 27

Trump’s calls to Kim go unanswered, letter returned unopened: Report | World News

Trump’s calls to Kim go unanswered, letter returned unopened: Report | World News

US President Donald Trump tried to contact North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in 2025 but received no response, The Wall Street Journal reported, citing people familiar with the matter. Trump subsequently wrote to Kim. White House officials arranged for the letter to be handed to a North Korean diplomat outside Pyongyang’s UN mission in

What Your Lifestyle Could Be Doing to Your Dog’s Gut Microbiome 

The way people live may influence their dogs‘ health more than previously understood, according to new research suggesting that human lifestyles help shape the gut microbiome of their canine companions. The study, published in the journal mSystems, analyzed the gut microbiome of more than 250 dogs across Nepal, Thailand, the United Arab Emirates and the

School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): Top National, International News

School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): Top National, International News

Today’s headlines bring together the stories shaping India and the world. School Assembly News Headlines (November 23): From India-China border talks in Arunachal Pradesh to Prime Minister Modi’s remarks on artificial intelligence, today’s headlines bring together the stories shaping India and the world. Internationally, developments involving the US, Russia, Nepal, Indonesia and the European Union

Where Will Micron Stock Be in 3 Years?

Micron’s stock has plunged in recent months, but the next three years could still be lucrative. By Keith Speights – Nov 22, 2026 at 4:26AM EST Micron Technology (MU -13.89%) has lost nearly half its market cap in five months. That’s the bad news. The good news is that the semiconductor stock is still up

A battered stock market looks for the bottom: What to watch this week

It’d be impossible to top last week’s action. Anthropic (ANT) went public, marking the first pure-play generative AI lab to list on the public market in the US. GTA VI was released to near-unanimous adoration and record sales. President Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin held their first trilateral talks. And

As the talks entered unprecedented overtime, COP31 President Murat Kurum urged countries to find common ground and adopt the proposed text. (REUTERS)

COP31 becomes longest-ever UN climate summit, EU rejects ‘greenwashing of fossil fuels’

The COP31 in Turkey became the longest-ever United Nations climate conference, with the summit running 44 hours past its scheduled closing time as negotiations over a final agreement remain deadlocked. As the talks entered unprecedented overtime, COP31 President Murat Kurum urged countries to find common ground and adopt the proposed text. (REUTERS)more This comes even

AMD Stock Just Plunged on a Short-Seller Report. Is This a Golden Buying Opportunity?

AMD’s fundamentals are more than just a whisper of “buy the dip.” By Prosper Junior Bakiny – Nov 22, 2026 at 3:30AM EST Key Points Hunterbrook alleges AMD firmware reached a blacklisted Chinese company. However, AMD has denied the claims, and another news outlet has been unable to verify them. With the allegations unproven and

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

COP31 Climate Deal in the Balance After Fractious Talks

ANTALYA, Turkey, Nov ⁠22 (Reuters) – ⁠The COP31 climate ⁠talks in Turkey neared a ​close on Sunday with a ‌deal far from certain ‌as countries argued over ⁠the ⁠pace of the clean-energy transition, the role ​of carbon capture, and financial support for developing nations. Below are reactions ​from delegates: COP31 PRESIDENT MURAT KURUM “No party

How Will Markets Trade Next Week?

Thank you for subscribing to my posts. If you’re not yet a paying supporter, please consider becoming one. That’ll allow you to DM me with questions and comments. Your contribution will help cover the cost of the data I use in my posts, which I fund out of my own pocket. Thanks so much for

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x