Analysis: What the Epstein files show vs. what the Trump team claimed

A newly discovered document in the Jeffrey Epstein files undermines one of President Donald Trump’s central claims about the matter — specifically, his supposed lack of knowledge of Epstein’s misconduct.

And it’s hardly alone.

The release of millions of pages of documents a week and a half ago has repeatedly tested and sometimes contradicted the Trump administration’s claims about what’s contained in the files, which it initially promised to release but then suddenly pulled back on before Congress forced its hand.

Administration officials including Trump and Attorney General Pam Bondi have previously made multiple claims about the files that have later been undercut. But with the release of millions of documents last month, it appears the number is now growing.

Let’s recap.

Trump’s claim to having had ‘no idea’ about Epstein and girls

When Trump acknowledged last year that Epstein accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell had recruited prominent Epstein victim Virginia Giuffre from Mar-a-Lago, he claimed he hadn’t known what for.

No, I don’t know really why,” Trump said in July.

Trump was even firmer back in 2019, when he was asked if he had any suspicions that Epstein was molesting underage girls.

No, I had no idea,” he said, repeating: “I had no idea.”

But plenty of other evidence has called those claims into question. And now we have the firmest suggestion yet that Trump at the very least had suspicions.

A newly discovered document describes Trump telling police in the mid-2000s, shortly after the investigation into Epstein became public, that he was glad they were “stopping him” because “everyone has known he’s been doing this.” (The document was first reported by the Miami Herald.)

The document comes from a 2019 FBI interview with a Palm Beach, Florida, police chief, who recounted a conversation he had with Trump around 2006.

Trump, in that conversation, also cited an occasion when he was around Epstein and some teenagers and said he “got the hell out of there,” according to the document.

The document also says Trump was one of the “very first people” to call the Palm Beach Police Department when he found out it had been investigating Epstein.

Asked about the matter Tuesday, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said she couldn’t confirm whether the 2006 phone call took place. But she said that if it did, it backed up Trump’s previous comments that he’d cut ties with Epstein in the early 2000s and viewed him as a “creep.”

The White House, however, hadn’t previously explained why Trump used that word for Epstein. And when Trump was asked about it in July, he lashed out at the reporter who asked the question.

Lawmakers got their first glimpse of un-redacted files on Monday, after which some claimed that multiple men are being protected by the redactions — including alleged co-conspirators.

GOP Rep. Thomas Massie, after viewing the files, told CNN’s Kaitlan Collins on Monday that the new documents raised questions about whether FBI Director Kash Patel gave false testimony when he said in September that said there was “no credible information” that Epstein had trafficked young women to anybody but himself.

“None,” Patel said at the time. “If there were, I would bring the case yesterday that he trafficked to other individuals.”

At a House hearing the same week, Patel denied there was anything in the files that pointed to other people having engaged in underage sex.

“That’s correct,” Patel said. “To my knowledge, no.”

But Massie and Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna of California said after reviewing the unredacted files that they contained at least six names of people that were redacted who were “likely incriminated.”

A hugely important caveat: a name appearing in the files is not evidence of wrongdoing, and it’s not clear what the six who Massie and Khanna mentioned are even suspected of.

One of the men they cited was listed on an internal FBI document as suspected “co-conspirators,” but that document does not provide any evidence of impropriety.

The Justice Department later removed the redactions for several names. CNN has reached out to the men whose names have been unredacted.

But that new un-redacting also contradicts how the administration initially billed the redaction effort.

When CNN brought some questionable redactions to the administration’s attention last week, a DOJ official suggested many of them were women who could be described as both “victims” and “participants” — and that none were men.

“In many instances, as it has been well documented publicly, those who were originally victims became participants and co-conspirators,” the official said. “We did not redact any names of men, only female victims.”

The officials also said FBI and law enforcement officials were being redacted.

But thanks to pressure from lawmakers who saw the unredacted files and the names we can now see, we can now say that the redactions included the names of some men (who weren’t law enforcement).

In the September House hearing, Patel testified that Trump’s name appeared in the Epstein files fewer than 100 times.

Asked whether Trump’s name was in there 1,000 times, 500 times and 100 times, Patel denied each of them.

“I don’t know the number, but it’s not that,” Patel said after being asked if the president’s name appeared 100 times.

But in fact, Trump appears in the Epstein files more than 1,000 times, CNN has reported. (A search for his name turns up thousands of documents, but some are duplicates.)

The Justice Department in late December announced the discovery of more than a million documents potentially related to the Epstein case. But given there are more than 3 million documents overall, it’s not clear that would account for the discrepancy between Patel’s testimony and the files that were released.

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said in an interview last year that he cut all ties with Epstein in 2005, after an uncomfortable encounter at Epstein’s home.

Lutnick told the New York Post in October that, after the encounter, he had resolved to “never be in the room with that disgusting person ever again.”

“So I was never in the room with him socially, for business — or even philanthropy,” Lutnick said. “That guy was there, I wasn’t going, ‘cause he’s gross.”

But the documents showed that’s not true. Lutnick on several occasions after 2005 sought to meet or speak with Epstein. And he confirmed in congressional testimony on Tuesday that he and his family visited Epstein’s island in 2012.

“And we had lunch on the island, that is true, for an hour. And we left with all of my children, with my nannies and my wife, all together. We were on family vacation,” Lutnick said. “I don’t recall why we did it.”

Lutnick joins Trump in downplaying his ties to Epstein in ways that are later contradicted.

Some Republicans have raised concerns about Lutnick’s initial claim, with Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana saying Tuesday that Lutnick had “a lot of explaining to do.”

But Leavitt said Tuesday that Trump “fully supports” Lutnick and called him a “very important member” of the president’s team.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Pam Bondi expected to face questions about Epstein files at House hearing

A sizable majority of Americans want significant changes to Immigration and Customs Enforcement — but while they largely disapprove of ICE and say its tactics have gone too far, the country is divided over just how much to reform the agency and how to handle immigration policy broadly, according to a new survey. The new NBC

The USS Honduras sets sail again | Donald Trump

It’s smooth sailing these days for the United States and Honduras, the diminutive Central American nation and original “banana republic” that has just elected a new right-wing president, Nasry Asfura, to the delight of US sociopath-in-chief Donald Trump. The gringo leader has even taken credit for Asfura’s victory, having threatened to cut off US aid

Trump won’t stop at trying to nationalize elections

Feb. 11, 2026, 4:04 a.m. ET President Donald Trump’s call to nationalize elections ahead of November has rightfully garnered plenty of opposition from Democrats, with many sounding the alarm for an authoritarian plot aimed at artificially boosting Republicans’ prospects.  Democrats are rightly concerned with the federal government administering elections, which are a constitutional responsibility of

Analysis: Lutnick’s grilling shows Trump a glimpse of a grim possible future

No wonder President Donald Trump is so worried about the midterm elections. A tough day for some of his top officials and political priorities on Capitol Hill invoked a possibly miserable future for the White House. If Democrats win back the House in November — or even the Senate, in a long-shot scenario — Trump

With co-founders leaving and an IPO looming, Elon Musk turns talk to the moon

CEO of SpaceX and Tesla, South African-Canadian-US businessman Elon Musk speaks during the World Economic Forum (WEF) annual meeting in Davos on January 22, 2026. The World Economic Forum takes place in Davos from January 19 to January 23, 2026. (Photo by Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP via Getty Images) | Image Credits:Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP

Ralph Lauren fashion show – Anne Hathaway, Lana Del Rey, more stun

Updated Feb. 10, 2026, 9:16 p.m. ET NEW YORK — Ralph Lauren’s latest fashion show served as the perfect pre-Valentine’s Day date night for Lana Del Rey and her husband. The songstress and husband Jeremy Dufrene stepped out together Tuesday, Feb. 10, looking loved up for a glamorous night out on the New York City

Governors to skip Trump meeting after White House excluded Democrats

Updated Feb. 10, 2026, 9:09 p.m. ET The National Governors Association will not attend a meeting with President Donald Trump later this month after the White House excluded Democratic governors, chairman Kevin Stitt told members on Monday, according to a source familiar with the matter. Governors from across the country gather every year in Washington

The March for Billionaires Was a Funeral for Irony

A couple of weeks ago, word began to spread around San Francisco that somebody was organizing a “March for Billionaires.” A mystery organizer had posted on social media that “billionaires get a bad rap,” and soon, some flyers appeared around the city. A website provided a time and rendezvous point; it also celebrated the societal

Racist Trump post demands accountability

Feb. 10, 2026, 8:00 p.m. ET President Donald Trump says he knows nothing of the racist post that went out on his social media account. We’re skeptical, considering the president’s juvenile impulses and predilection for crudity. A meme depicting former President Barack and Michelle Obama as apes is not outside his range. If he’s telling

躲避富豪稅 加州億萬富翁正選擇搬離 | 扎克伯格 | 大紀元

【大紀元2026年02月11日訊】(大紀元記者張婷綜合報導)佛羅里達州的邁阿密正在迎來更多的加州富豪。Meta首席執行官馬克‧扎克伯格(Mark Zuckerberg)成為最新在邁阿密買房的加州億萬富翁。背後推力是加州議員正在推動徵收超5%的億萬富翁稅。 據《華爾街日報》報導,知情人士透露,扎克伯格在邁阿密印第安溪(Indian Creek)正在購買一棟新建成的海濱豪宅。目前尚不清楚該交易是否已經完成。 億萬富翁汽車經銷商諾曼‧布拉曼(Norman Braman)和他的妻子艾爾瑪‧布拉曼(Irma Braman)就住在扎克伯格新家的隔壁。艾爾瑪在接受電話採訪時告訴《華日》,扎克伯格告訴他們,他計劃在4月前搬入該房產。 「我們很高興他的到來。」艾爾瑪說。 加州議員正提議徵收5%的億萬富翁稅。而佛羅里達州不徵收州所得稅,這對於扎克伯格和貝佐斯這樣的億萬富翁來說,意味著節省數百萬美元。 邁阿密的房地產經紀人表示,加州提出的「億萬富翁稅」令那裡的富豪們感到不安,許多人現在正四處搜尋南佛羅里達的高端住宅。 這一稅收若最終獲得批准,將對截至2026年1月1日淨資產超過10億美元的加州居民一次性徵收5%的稅。 《華日》援引Coldwell Banker Realty的邁阿密房地產經紀人丹尼‧赫茨伯格(Danny Hertzberg)的話說,「加州的5%稅收確實在很大程度上把人趕走了。」 據彭博社報導,道格拉斯‧埃利曼(Douglas Elliman)地產公司的豪宅經紀人迪娜‧戈爾登泰爾(Dina Goldentayer)說,「他們(加州富豪)來了,而且正在提交報價。」 她表示,許多加州購房者都專注於價值3000萬美元至1.5億美元的「頂級豪宅」。然而,也有一些人正在尋找價格較低的房產,以便儘快安家落戶,而不是等待完美房產。 知情人士向《華爾街日報》透露,谷歌聯合創始人拉里‧佩奇(Larry Page)在過去幾個月裡以約1.88億美元的價格在邁阿密椰林區(Coconut Grove)購買了多處房產,而另一位谷歌聯合創辦人謝爾蓋‧布林(Sergey Brin)也一直在商談以5,000萬美元的價格在邁阿密海灘購買一處房產。 據彭博社報導,已有超過六位億萬富翁因潛在的稅收威脅而離開加州,如果該稅收提案獲得通過,另有15至20個家庭計劃離開。 除了億萬富翁外,還有一些加州富人因為加州的累進稅制等原因而選擇搬離。 彭博社援引「Jackson Square Capital」創辦人、財富管理人安德魯‧格雷厄姆(Andrew Graham)的話說,其他房地產買家多為年紀較大、生活富裕的加州人,他們希望保護個人財富而離開加州。 據格雷厄姆估計,他的客戶中已有約8%離開加州,原因是「政府治理不善」以及加州的累進稅制,另有20%的客戶正在認真考慮搬離。 責任編輯:林姸#

We need the Washington Post too much to give up on it entirely

Jeff Bezos just about killed the Washington Post last week. It was awful. By the latest reckoning, nearly half the newsroom is gone. The Post is no longer a local newspaper. The Post is no longer an international newspaper. The Post has abandoned readers who care about sports, books, technology, and the arts. It no

Where Xi Jinping Stands Ahead of Lunar New Year

Welcome to Foreign Policy’s China Brief. The highlights this week: Chinese President Xi Jinping balances wins abroad and challenges at home, Hong Kong businessman Jimmy Lai is sentenced to 20 years in prison, and a Panamanian court voids Chinese-linked port deals. Welcome to Foreign Policy’s China Brief. The highlights this week: Chinese President Xi Jinping

Why is Elon Musk going to the moon instead of Mars?

Elon Musk has long had a passion for Mars. The moon? A diversion. That plan has now shifted. SpaceX will “prioritize going to the moon first,” said The Wall Street Journal. Just last year the world’s richest man called the prospect of a moon landing a “distraction.” The company was aiming to go “straight to

Celebrities at the 2026 DGA Awards

Here is a look at the notable celebrities who attended the 2026 Directors Guild of America Awards, which took place on Saturday evening in Los Angeles. Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images for DGA Caplet Seals The Deal Ginnifer Goodwin was easily my favourite of the night, wearing a fuchsia pink Simkhai Briella column dress. I know some

All the Celebrity Front-Row Looks From the Fall 2026 NYFW Shows

1 Sofia Coppola and Cosima Mars Coppola Gilbert Carrasquillo//Getty Images At the Marc Jacobs Fall 2026 show. 2 Monica Gilbert Carrasquillo//Getty Images At the Marc Jacobs Fall 2026 show. Advertisement – Continue Reading Below 3 Myha’la Gilbert Carrasquillo//Getty Images At the Marc Jacobs Fall 2026 show. 4 Julia Fox Gilbert Carrasquillo//Getty Images At the Marc

Trump Threatens to Block Bridge Between U.S. and Canada

President Donald Trump has threatened to block the opening of a $4.7 billion bridge connecting Detroit, Michigan, to Windsor, Ontario, in the latest display of frayed relations between the U.S. and Canada. In a lengthy social media post, Trump raised a number of issues against his northern neighbor and doubled down on his often-cited claim

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x