Could Trump’s bid to become peacemaker-in-chief sideline the struggling UN?

Lyse Doucet profile image

Lyse DoucetChief international correspondent

BBC Montage image showing Donald Trump, the UN logo and the Board of Peace crestBBC

“Together we are in a position to… end decades of suffering, stop generations of hatred and bloodshed, and forge a beautiful, everlasting and glorious peace for that region and for the whole region of the world.”

Such was the soaring promise of US President Donald Trump as he inaugurated his new Board of Peace on the stage of stages that is the Davos Economic Forum this week.

The world of all too much suffering and strife badly wants to believe him.

But for many observers and officials in capitals the world over, it is yet more proof of Trump’s drive to dismantle the post-war international architecture and replace it with new institutions – dominated by him.

“We will not let anyone play us,” Poland’s Prime Minister Donald Tusk warned tersely on social media.

Reuters President Donald Trump takes part in a charter announcement for his Board of Peace initiative Reuters

The idea – born last year in US-led efforts to end the war in Gaza and endorsed by a UN Security Council resolution – now has a much greater, far grander, more global ambition

But from Trump’s biggest backer in Europe, Viktor Orban, came effusive praise: “If Trump, then peace.”

What exactly will this Board, headed in perpetuity by Trump himself, do? Could this really be a bid to build a UN mini-me?

Power of the Board chairman

The idea – born last year in US-led efforts to end the war in Gaza and endorsed by a UN Security Council resolution – now has a much greater, far grander, more global ambition. And it pivots around the president.

In leaked details of the draft charter he is the Board’s chairman for life even when he leaves office. Under that charter his powers would be vast: authority to invite member states or not; to create or dissolve subsidiary bodies; and the mandate to appoint his successor whenever he decides to step down, or if he is incapacitated.

If any other country would like to become a permanent member, the price is an eye-watering $1 billion (£740m).

This latest bombshell lands in what is already a head-spinning month. In a few short weeks there’s already been the US capture of Venezuela’s leader, Trump threats and preparations for military action against Iran, and demands to acquire Greenland which sent shock waves across Europe and beyond.

Reuters Donald Trump at the charter announcement for his Board of Peace initiativeReuters

‘Once this Board is completely formed, we can do pretty much whatever we want to do and we’ll do it in conjunction with the United Nations,’ Trump has said

Nineteen countries showed up in Davos for the Board’s inauguration from all corners of the compass – from Argentina to Azerbaijan, from former Soviet republics to Gulf kingdoms. Many more are said to have “agreed to join”.

“In this group, I like every single one of them,” Trump grinned as he eyed leaders and officials whose names are now on this Board or the layers of executive bodies beneath it.

Many more potential members have so far politely demurred.

“This is about a treaty that raises much broader issues, and we do also have concerns about President Putin being part of something that is talking about peace” explained the UK’s Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper.

Trump says Russia is on board although the message from Moscow was that they were still “consulting partners”.

“As the text stands right now,” we’re not joining, replied Sweden.

“The proposal raises unanswered questions that require further dialogue with Washington” was Norway’s diplomatic response.

Even a group of seven predominantly Muslim countries, including six Arab nations, as well as Turkey and Indonesia, made it clear they were in it for a “just and lasting peace in Gaza,” including the reconstruction of the shattered enclave.

However leaked details of the Board’s charter don’t mention Gaza.

Reuters A UN security officer stands guard at the Security Council Chamber ahead of a UN Security Council vote on a draft resolution demanding a ceasefire in Gaza, in September 2025Reuters

Prime Minister Robert Golob made his concern about the Board clear – it “dangerously interferes with the broader international order”

For some of the critics, including some countries reluctant to join, it’s a vainglorious project for a president who doesn’t hide his fixation with winning the biggest accolade – the Nobel Peace Prize, which was was won by President Obama in 2009 at the start of his first term in the White House.

World leaders know there may be a price to pay for not joining this new club.

“I’ll put a 200% tariff on his wines and champagnes, and he’ll join, but he doesn’t have to join.” This was the president’s rebuke to France’s President Emmanuel Macron with a threat to wield his weapon of choice.

Only Slovenia said the quiet part out loud. Prime Minister Robert Golob made his concern clear – it “dangerously interferes with the broader international order”.

Trump addressed this concern head-on.

“Once this Board is completely formed, we can do pretty much whatever we want to do and we’ll do it in conjunction with the United Nations,” he explained to the packed hall hanging on his every word.

But he likes to keep the world guessing.

A day earlier, when asked by a Fox TV journalist whether his Board would replace the UN, he replied “Well it might. The UN just hasn’t been very helpful.”

Then he added “I’m a big fan of the UN potential, but it has never lived up to its potential. The UN should have settled every one of the wars that I settled.”

A new contender for peacemaker-in-chief?

The UN, 193 members strong, has indeed long lost its role as peacemaker-in-chief.

When I interviewed the Secretary General António Guterres in October 2016, on his first day in his first term, just hours after a rare unanimous endorsement by the Security Council, he promised “a surge in diplomacy for peace”.

For the past decade, the UN’s efforts were thwarted by the gridlocked Security Council, the growing number of spoilers and state sponsors in wars the world over, as well as the steady erosion in its own standing vis-a-vis the world’s most powerful players, including the United States.

“We must all welcome the activism of Mr Trump on ending wars,” says Martin Griffiths, a UN veteran who believes this new effort is “obviously a reflection of the failure of the UN Security Council and of the UN writ large.”

But the former Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator cautioned that “what we’ve learned over these last 80 years, through lots and lots of failures and clunkiness, we learned the value of inclusion, of being representative of the global community, not just the friends of Mr Trump.”

Guterres himself recently regretted that “there are those that believe the power of law should be replaced by the law of power”.

Asked in an interview with the BBC’s Today programme about Trump’s constant claim that he’s ended eight wars, he replied matter-of-factly “they are ceasefires.”

Some have already broken down.

The temporary peace deal between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo soon fell apart, Cambodia and Thailand started hurling accusations and more across their border, and India disputed Trump’s central role in ending its conflagration with Pakistan.

EPA Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a debate in the Knesset, the Israeli parliamentEPA

As this new Board slowly takes shape, it includes Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu

But only Trump’s muscular mediation could have ended the 12-day war between Iran and Israel.

His own personal involvement finally secured a ceasefire in Gaza’s destructive confrontation last October which eased both the suffering of Palestinians, and the agony of Israeli hostages. His decision to finally and fully focus on this disaster, partly in response to urging from his closest Arab allies and grieving Israeli families, pushed him to pressure Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu and Hamas, to do a deal.

But even the Board’s first test – to move from the first phase of the deal to end the Gaza war – is daunting. Even now, as this new Board slowly takes shape, it includes Netanyahu who has vowed to stop the establishment of a Palestinian state, and Arab leaders who insist the only pathway to a sustainable peace must lead to Palestinian self-governance and the end of Israeli occupation.

And the other big war on America’s – and Europe’s agenda – is Ukraine. President Zelensky has balked at being at the same table as Moscow and Minsk.

Three layers lie beneath this Board, most focusing on Gaza – an Executive Board, a Gaza Executive Board, and the National Committee for the Administration for Gaza.

They bring together a mix of senior American officials and billionaires, as well as respected former politicians and ex-UN envoys who know Gaza well, along with Arab ministers and intelligence chiefs, and Palestinian technocrats.

Reuters Destruction in Gaza as seen from the Israeli side of the Israel-Gaza border in southern Israel, January 21, 2026Reuters

Three layers lie beneath this Board, most focusing on Gaza

Even some critics credit the president with putting an age-old battle of a different kind on the table – the incessant demand to reform the UN’s post-war architecture including a Security Council which no longer aligns with the world’s political map of major powers in every region. It’s simply not fit for purpose.

“Maybe an unintended good consequence of what Trump has done is those issues will be pushed back towards the top of the international agenda,” reflected Mark Malloch Brown, the former UN deputy secretary-general.

“We’re coming out of a period of extremely weak UN leadership and I think this could be a call to action.”

Ironically, Trump’s bid to lead the world towards peace comes as discussions gather steam in many capitals to replace Guterres who completes his second term at the end of this year.

The president, who previously declared that he could end the Ukraine war in a day, has learned in his last year in power that peacemaking is a protracted and perilous process.

But today he hailed a Middle East region where only “little fires” were burning now. He promised that a settlement in Ukraine “is coming very soon”.

And he revelled in his new role as would-be peacemaker-in-chief.

“This is for the world” he exclaimed.

Top picture credit: Reuters

Thin, lobster red banner with white text saying ‘InDepth newsletter’. To the right are black and white portrait images of Emma Barnett and John Simpson. Emma has dark-rimmed glasses, long fair hair and a striped shirt. John has short white hair with a white shirt and dark blazer. They are set on an oatmeal, curved background with a green overlapping circle.

BBC InDepth is the home on the website and app for the best analysis, with fresh perspectives that challenge assumptions and deep reporting on the biggest issues of the day. Emma Barnett and John Simpson bring their pick of the most thought-provoking deep reads and analysis, every Saturday. Sign up for the newsletter here

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Latest and Breaking News on NDTV

How Ukraine War Triggered Europe’s Biggest Migration Wave Since World War II

New Delhi: Europe is witnessing waves of protests across several countries, including France, Spain, Portugal, Italy and Albania, with the high cost of living, housing shortages and economic pressures emerging as common themes. While US President Donald Trump has linked the unrest in France to migration and Islam, Europe has mostly been dealing with the

Tropical Storm Vance has formed in the Pacific Ocean

Tropical Storm Vance has formed in the Pacific Ocean

This satellite image from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration shows Tropical Storm Vance strengthening in the Pacific Ocean on Wednesday, Oct. 21, 2026. (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration via AP) (Uncredited, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) MIAMI – Tropical Storm Vance formed Wednesday in the Pacific Ocean, the National Hurricane Center said. The center

​Europe stands by Ukraine – but how long can that last? | World news

​Europe stands by Ukraine – but how long can that last? | World news

Europe woke up last Friday to another belligerent outburst from Donald Trump – this time berating Ukraine’s wartime leader Volodymyr Zelenskyy again. Just a few days after his diesel deal with the Kremlin, the US president said Zelenskyy was more difficult to deal with than Vladimir Putin and blamed Ukraine’s leader for rocketing oil prices

Data compiled from the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) World Economic Outlook 2026 and World Trade Organization (WTO) trade statistics tracks economic performance around leadership changes in five countries.

Regime change doesn’t translate into economic recovery: Data

Regime change doesn’t translate into economic recovery or chart a country’s growth path, recent data from South Asia shows. Economic indicators in some South Asian countries have shown signs of gradual improvement following major political upheavals, but they have yet to fully recover, with persistent challenges regarding GDP growth, inflation and trade. Data compiled from

President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026, in Washington. AP/PTI(AP10_21_2026_000003A) (AP)

Donald Trump, human wrecking-ball | World News

“INEVER MEANT to start a war…I just closed my eyes and swung,” sings Miley Cyrus in “Wrecking Ball”, a break-up ballad that seemed to play on every American radio in 2013. Though melodically a bit relentless, the pop song deserves a revival as a guide to the second-term statecraft of President Donald Trump. President Donald

The Chinese national flag is pictured at half mast to mourn the death of China's former premier Zhu Rongji at the Red Building of Peking University, the site of early Chinese Communist Party revolutionary activities, in Beijing on August 18, 2026. (AFP FILE)

China’s universities are rich. But they’re getting squeezed

In its competition with China, America sometimes commits self-sabotage. Under Donald Trump, cuts in federal support for universities have been particularly damaging. To convey their anguish, some American scientists have drawn attention to the advantage that their country’s strategic rival may gain from these retrenchments. China had been handed the future “on a silver platter”,

Add image caption here

At 117, Albanian May Be World’s Oldest Woman Qamile Marra: Life Is Beautiful

Albania: At 117, Qamile Marra is not particularly concerned with proving she may be the world’s oldest woman — or even persuading Albanian pension officials that she is not dead. For a woman born under Ottoman rule, who turned 36 a fortnight before the end of World War II and outlived Albania’s communist dictatorship, her

Elon Musk with US President Donald Trump. (AP/File)

Elon Musk behind Starlink slowdown order that disrupted Ukraine’s drones: Report

A slowdown in SpaceX’s Starlink satellite network that disrupted Ukraine’s drone operations was triggered by an order from company’s CEO Elon Musk, The Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, citing unnamed US officials and other sources. Elon Musk with US President Donald Trump. (AP/File) The move reportedly restricted Ukraine’s access to the satellite service, affecting

Anthropic Recorded Net Loss Of Over $80 Billion In 1st Half Of 2026: Report

Anthropic Recorded Net Loss Of Over $80 Billion In 1st Half Of 2026: Report

That compares to a net loss of $13 billion during the same period a year earlier, according to report.  AI startup Anthropic recorded a net loss of more than $80 billion in the first half of this year, the Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, citing a draft initial public offering prospectus. That compares to

Restrictions In Paris To Remain In Place On Tuesday After Curfew Brings Calm

Restrictions In Paris To Remain In Place On Tuesday After Curfew Brings Calm

A ban was also issued for any public gatherings from 1800 GMT Tuesday in les Halles Paris police ordered a new curfew for parts of the city for Tuesday overnight, after one the previous night that authorities said resulted in calm being restored following weekend riots and looting. The fresh curfew runs from 2100 GMT

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Curfews Bring Calm to Paris as France Cracks Down on Weekend Rioters

At least 2,400 people were arrested after rioters in cities across France on Saturday clashed with police, set cars on fire, stormed public buildings and engulfed a historic city hall in flames, during nationwide protests against rising living costs and poor conditions in schools. On Sunday evening, small groups set fire to trash bins, bicycles

Latest and Breaking News on NDTV

Reform Or Regime Change? What Global Movements Tell Us About Protest Goals

Whenever thousands of people take to the streets in any corner of the world, the primary fear in the corridors of power is of a coup or regime change. The recent downfall of Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh, the flight of the Rajapaksa family in Sri Lanka, and the political reshuffle in Nepal have further strengthened

Trump 'Frustrated' Over Claims He Is Causing 'Harm' To Ukraine: Marco Rubio

Trump ‘Frustrated’ Over Claims He Is Causing ‘Harm’ To Ukraine: Marco Rubio

Rubio is on a visit to India US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Tuesday that President Donald Trump was “frustrated” by accusations that he had deliberately harmed Ukraine, including claims he ordered intelligence sharing to be halted. “The president is frustrated because, first of all, he doesn’t like to be blamed for things that

Blow to Reform UK motion refugee motion voted down

Blow to Reform UK motion refugee motion voted down

County Hall Chichester. Image: LDRS A call from Reform UK councillors in West Sussex for the county council to withdraw from all voluntary refugee resettlement schemes has been voted down. The motion was tabled by group leader Tim Charters (Southgate & Gossops Green) during a meeting on Friday (October 16), and seconded by Callum Johnson (Ref,

WOL.com Announces Global Launch of Its Real Time World News Platform

WOL.com Announces Global Launch of Its Real Time World News Platform

WOL.COM launches Online World News The platform delivers timely updates about World, Business, Technology, Politics, Lifestyle, and Culture, with a focus on accuracy and international reach ATLANTA, GA, UNITED STATES, October 19, 2026 /EINPresswire.com/ — WOL.com today announced the worldwide launch of its digital news platform providing real time global coverage through a modern, mobile

Trump Says Zelensky Should Get "Somebody Else" To Negotiate To End War

Donald Trump Says Volodymyr Zelensky Should Get Somebody Else To Negotiate To End War

Trump also told reporters that Russia has been “fine” with regards to Ukraine. US President Donald Trump on Monday said he thought someone other than Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy should negotiate on Kyiv’s behalf as it seeks to end the war with Russia. “Maybe it’s time for Zelenskiy to get somebody else to negotiate,” said

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x