​Europe stands by Ukraine – but how long can that last? | World news

Europe woke up last Friday to another belligerent outburst from Donald Trump – this time berating Ukraine’s wartime leader Volodymyr Zelenskyy again. Just a few days after his diesel deal with the Kremlin, the US president said Zelenskyy was more difficult to deal with than Vladimir Putin and blamed Ukraine’s leader for rocketing oil prices – without any reference to the impact of his own war on Iran.

The contrast in Europe was obvious. When Zelenskyy walked into the multi-coloured summit room of the European Council headquarters in Brussels that Friday morning, the EU’s 27 leaders burst into applause, getting to their feet to offer big hugs and brisk handshakes. European Council president António Costa told Zelenskyy and the media: “This is no time to withdraw the support to Ukraine,” calling instead for increased pressure on Russia. Zelenskyy was thankful, pointedly saying he was happy to have “huge support” from “real leaders”.

The symbolism was powerful. As US support crumbles, Europe seems to be stepping up. According to the Kiel Institut’s Ukraine Support Tracker, Europe – including non-EU countries such as the UK and Norway – has spent €236bn supporting Ukraine from 2022 to April 2026, compared with a US outlay of €115bn.

While Trump is weakening sanctions, Europe is promising more. The EU has passed 21 rounds of sanctions against Russia and last year agreed to raise a €90bn loan for Ukraine – an unprecedented sum for a non-member state. Meanwhile the EU has opened accession negotiations with Kyiv and given shelter to 4.4million Ukrainian refugees.

Behind the declarations of Europe’s enduring support, the outlook is more complex and less encouraging for Ukraine, as it approaches its fifth winter since the launch of Russia’s all-out invasion.

First, Europe is not able to replace US military dominance in areas such as intelligence. This was brutally exposed by the disruption to the US SpaceX technologies that Ukraine uses in frontline drone operations and air-defences protecting civilians from Russian air attacks. Zelenskyy said the US had intentionally throttled its Starlink satellite internet access, a charge that senior figures in the Trump administration have denied.

Ukraine also depends on US-made Patriot interceptors capable of shooting down Russian ballistic missiles. Deepening the spat, Zelenskyy this week accused the Trump administration of preventing European countries from passing on their Patriot stocks to Ukraine.

Secondly, Europe’s monetary support for Ukraine is not evenly spread. Germany is the second-largest donor, having spent €54bn since the start of the war, a particularly crucial contribution since Trump ceased virtually all new US funding. But a report from the Kiel Institut describes this funding as “sizeable but not exceptional” given the scale of the German economy. Four Nordic countries together have given more than Germany, even though they total only a third of Germany’s population, the researchers note. The EU’s other big economies, France and Italy, give less than Germany.

The Nordic, Baltic and other north European states are Ukraine’s most generous donors when contributions are measured against national income, according to the Kiel Institut. Denmark, for instance, spends an equivalent to 4.17% of its gross domestic product supporting Ukraine, and Estonia 3.77%, compared with 1.49% spent by Germany, 1.1% by France, 1% by Italy and 0.86% by the UK. With Ukraine’s huge bill to defend itself growing, and Russia’s relentless attacks continuing to wreak a heavy toll, these more generous donors might arguably feel Europe’s biggest economies – and other western allies – could do more to shoulder these ever-rising costs.

Top donors to Ukraine by percentage of GDP

Financial aid from 24 January 2022 to 31 August 2026 as a % of a country’s 2021 GDP. Illustration: Guardian graphic/Source: Kiel Institute for the World Economy

Thirdly, and most critically, Europe’s support for Ukraine could be reaching its limits, as Europe enters a supercycle of elections in which the far-right are expected to make gains. National votes are due in Spain, France, Poland and Italy, four of the five biggest EU member states by population. Mujtaba Rahman, managing director for Europe at the Eurasia Group, argued that the biggest risk for Ukraine is not Trump’s opinions, but the potential for European support to fragment. There is a risk 2027 will be the year “when political reality, electoral reality, policy reality, economic reality catches up with Europe and prevents it being able to go further in its support for Ukraine”, he said.

France’s elections could be the most consequential. The far-right leader and frontrunner Marine Le Pen is seeking to present herself as the candidate to restore order and security, after days of rioting and looting across French cities. She has also vowed to cease aid to Ukraine within six months of taking office “because we simply cannot do it any more”. Speaking to the Financial Times (£), Le Pen vowed to slash France’s contributions to the EU budget, which raises questions about a proposed €100bn fund for Ukraine in the upcoming 2028-34 budget cycle. Beyond Ukraine, her election could plunge the EU into a deep internal crisis that will consume political energies and attention.


Putin’s ‘strategic patience’ rewarded?

skip past newsletter promotion


US patience is running out with Ukraine as US special envoy Steve Witkoff meets with Vladimir Putin in Russia. Photograph: Kristina Solovyova/Reuters

“European support for Ukraine is already fragmenting,” argued Rahman, who points out the €90bn loan for Ukraine was agreed by only 24 EU countries (Hungary, Czechia and Slovakia opted out). But a Le Pen victory could tilt the balance, especially if anti-Ukraine parties make gains in Spain, Poland and Italy. “Le Pen is the biggest gamechanger because she will provide cover for many other countries to say: ‘enough is enough, we can’t keep funding,’” Rahman said.

That scenario paints “a really dark picture for Ukraine, a really sad picture for Ukraine” he said. “Because it’s not about Ukraine’s performance on the battlefield – Ukraine has done a remarkable job of holding the line. This is the risk Europe has been talking about for a very long time, and has promised Ukraine many times it would not allow to happen: that through strategic patience, Russia gains in the negotiating room what it has not been able to gain on the battlefield. And that is precisely the risk Ukraine is now confronting.”

To head off this risk, EU leaders will seek to shore up support for Ukraine by agreeing another funding plan. The head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, confirmed that Kyiv has a €70bn funding gap in 2027, although she expects Ukraine’s other international partners to help raise the sum.

Jana Kobzová, co-director of the European Security Programme at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said an EU leaders summit in December will be the moment when “we should have a clear idea and mechanism” on providing the €70bn for Ukraine ahead of key elections. “I think the urgency and the consciousness on the side of the European leaders is already there.”

To some extent, EU Russia policy is protected, after a recent decision to keep sanctions in place for three years, avoiding the need for divisive rollover decisions every six months.

But a Le Pen victory in six months’ time could lead to a bigger problem than financing Ukraine, suggests Kobzová. “If there is a huge shift in Europe as a result of these elections that are going to affect the way the EU itself works, then Ukraine might become collateral damage.”

Guardian live Q&A

Alexander Hurst and Rokhaya Diallo. Composite: Guardian Design

At 3pm BST/4pm CEST on Friday 23 October, Guardian Europe columnists Rokhaya Diallo and Alexander Hurst will be live taking questions from our readers about the riots and protests in France. Click here to submit yours now, or join the discussion on Friday.

To receive the complete version of This Is Europe in your inbox every Wednesday, please subscribe here.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

COP31 Climate Deal in the Balance After Fractious Talks

ANTALYA, Turkey, Nov ⁠22 (Reuters) – ⁠The COP31 climate ⁠talks in Turkey neared a ​close on Sunday with a ‌deal far from certain ‌as countries argued over ⁠the ⁠pace of the clean-energy transition, the role ​of carbon capture, and financial support for developing nations. Below are reactions ​from delegates: COP31 PRESIDENT MURAT KURUM “No party

Alice Huang's alleged affair with Jensen Huang triggered a spree of investigations into Nvidia's chip dealings and the suspected chip smuggling to China. (Reuters)

Alice Huang and her husband’s close associate Li Ming routed Nvidia chips to China: Report

Alice Huang, a former executive at Singapore-based Megaspeed, has been at the centre of an alleged Chinese spy and suspected chip smuggling row ever since ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang admitted to having an affair. However, a 52-year-old Chinese national has now reportedly emerged as a key behind-the-scenes player. Alice Huang’s alleged affair with Jensen Huang

Emergency services personnel gathered near body bags outside the PT Fonusa Agung Mulia factory in Indonesia, following a fire. (REUTERS)

3 dead, 36 workers unaccounted for after fire breaks out at Indonesian candy factory

A fire swept through a candy factory in Indonesia’s Banten province Saturday, leaving three people dead and rescue teams searching for 36 workers who remained unaccounted for, officials said. Emergency services personnel gathered near body bags outside the PT Fonusa Agung Mulia factory in Indonesia, following a fire. (REUTERS)more The blaze broke out at the

South Korean Education Minister Choi Kyo-jin is facing questions about AI-related cheating during a plenary session of the education committee at the National Assembly in Seoul, South Korea, Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. The letters on the bottom reading "AI Cheating". (Seo Dae-yeon/Yonhap via AP) (Seo Dae-yeon/YONHAP via AP)

South Korea education minister Choi Kyo-jin resigns amid AI cheating scandal

South Korea’s education minister resigned Sunday over an AI-assisted cheating scandal that erupted ahead of the country’s key college entrance exams last week. South Korean Education Minister Choi Kyo-jin is facing questions about AI-related cheating during a plenary session of the education committee at the National Assembly in Seoul, South Korea, Monday, Nov. 16, 2026.

For only the second time in two decades, the US Navy had no aircraft carrier group in the Pacific between August and November. (Representational Image)

Trump-class battleships add to US Navy’s cost burden as Iran war stretches fleet

The US Navy’s fleet expansion plans have gone billions of dollars over budget, with the proposed Trump-class battleships adding to the cost, according to a report submitted to the US Congress. For only the second time in two decades, the US Navy had no aircraft carrier group in the Pacific between August and November. (Representational

Latest and Breaking News on NDTV

3 Dead, 36 Missing After Indonesia Confectionery Factory Fire

A fire at a confectionery factory west of Jakarta killed three people and 36 remain missing, an Indonesian rescue official said on Sunday. Drone footage showed large parts of the factory destroyed, with the roof collapsed in places and smoke still rising from the complex. Photos and videos shared by rescuers also showed officers entering

Gadi Eisenkot (L) and Benjamin Netanyahu. (Agencies)

Israel’s Eisenkot invites Netanyahu’s party for coalition talks to form next government

Israel’s Yashar Party, whose leader, Gadi Eisenkot, has been tasked by the country’s president with forming the next government, has invited its main opponent, the Likud party led by caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, for coalition talks. Gadi Eisenkot (L) and Benjamin Netanyahu. (Agencies) Gadi Eisenkot was given a 28-day deadline starting November 8, with

People gather around COP31 President Murat Kurum at a closing plenary during the COP31 U.N. Climate Summit (AP)

COP31 draft deal makes no mention of fossil fuels as talks go into double overtime

The newest and possibly final proposed agreement to come out of United Nations climate talks doesn’t contain the words fossil fuels, the chief cause of global warming, or specifically call for transitioning away from the coal, oil and gas that spew carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. People gather around COP31 President

COP31 President Murat Kurum speaks during a closing plenary session at the COP31 UN Climate Summit. (AP Photo/Khalil Hamra)

COP31 goes into overtime: Fossil fuel, adaptation finance impasse persists

COP31 president Murat Kurum on Saturday urged countries to “act responsibly” and reach a compromise, as the UN climate talks in Türkiye’s Antalya went past their scheduled close with no agreement on fossil fuels or adaptation finance. COP31 President Murat Kurum speaks during a closing plenary session at the COP31 UN Climate Summit. (AP Photo/Khalil

ET logo

Iran says Hormuz reopening possible if US accepts ‘reasonable’ terms

Tehran: Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi on Saturday (local time) said that reopening the Strait of Hormuz would not be difficult if the United States accepts reasonable conditions in accordance with international law, according to Iran‘s semi-official Tasnim news agency, as reported by Al Jazeera. He stressed that resolving the crisis would require Washington to

Canada's Defense Minister David McGuinty said he sees no change in military cooperation with the US. (Bloomberg)

Canada says military ties with US remain unchanged despite reported Pentagon memo on informal contact

A Pentagon memo has urged US military personnel to limit informal and social contact with their Canadian counterparts, but Canada’s defense minister says the guidance has not changed military cooperation between the two countries. Canada’s Defense Minister David McGuinty said he sees no change in military cooperation with the US. (Bloomberg)more Canadian Defense Minister David

An interceptor drone operates during the Multinational Force Ukraine military exercise in Nowa Deba, Poland, on Friday, Nov. 20. (Representational) (Bloomberg)

Bahrain alleges Iranian attack behind fire at civilian industrial facility; no injuries

Bahrain said on Saturday that an Iranian attack had struck and damaged a civilian industrial facility, causing a fire but no injuries, the latest incident as hostilities spread across the Middle East after the US and Israeli war on Iran started in February. An interceptor drone operates during the Multinational Force Ukraine military exercise in

UK intelligence chief warns Putin could trigger World War Three by mistake. (REUTERS)

‘He is under pressure’: Putin’s ‘miscalculation’ could trigger World War III, top UK intelligence official warns

Vladimir Putin could accidentally trigger World War Three through Russia’s increasingly aggressive actions, the UK’s Chief of Defense Intelligence has warned. UK intelligence chief warns Putin could trigger World War Three by mistake. (REUTERS)more Lieutenant General Matthew Jones said Russia was not actively seeking war with Nato but warned that a serious mistake could lead

Finland’s Defense Minister confirmed that a Russian helicopter was suspected of entering Finnish airspace. Representative Image (via REUTERS)

Finland says Russian helicopter possibly breached its airspace hours after drone hit on cargo ship

Finland’s Defense Minister Antti Hakkanen confirmed on Tuesday that a Russian helicopter was suspected of entering Finnish airspace. Finland’s Defense Minister confirmed that a Russian helicopter was suspected of entering Finnish airspace. Representative Image (via REUTERS)more “A Russian helicopter is suspected of violating Finnish airspace today. The suspected airspace violation may be linked to rescue

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x