Why the FA Cup, not the Premier League, is English football’s prized jewel – and how it’s refusing to die thanks to underdogs like Plymouth, writes OLIVER HOLT

I felt lucky to be at Home Park on Sunday. For all sorts of reasons. Lucky to witness the drama of an FA Cup giant-killing. Lucky to feel the passion of a crowd at a club that still value their own fans more highly than tourists and day-trippers.

Lucky to be at a club that nurse pride in their own regional identity. Lucky to be sitting in the beautiful Mayflower Grandstand with its echoes of history. Lucky to see what a result such as Plymouth Argyle’s victory over Liverpool means to a local community.

Sometimes, it can feel as if the FA Cup represents a disappearing world, a last vestige of tradition in a sport whose broadcasters pretend it began in 1992 and whose money-makers see more lucrative opportunities elsewhere.

Arne Slot gave his first team the day off on Sunday. He didn’t even include any of them in the squad that travelled to the West Country. He picked a second-string team for the FA Cup because Liverpool have five matches in 15 days from Wednesday and have bigger priorities.

So when I listened to BBC Radio 5 Live on the drive home from Plymouth, I tuned in to the phone-in Robbie Savage and Chris Sutton host and heard Savage talking to a Plymouth fan. ‘Congratulations on beating Liverpool’s reserves,’ he said.

And he was right. Plymouth had beaten mighty Liverpool but it wasn’t the best Liverpool available. And that is not Slot’s fault. His priorities are the Premier League and the Champions League. His players have a crazy schedule and something has to give. And something, more often than not, is the FA Cup.

The Home Park crowd had the passion of a club that value their own fans more than tourists

The Home Park crowd had the passion of a club that value their own fans more than tourists

It was a day that illuminated the best of our game as Plymouth Argyle knocked out Liverpool

It was a day that illuminated the best of our game as Plymouth Argyle knocked out Liverpool

Arne Slot selected a second-string Liverpool team because the Reds' priorities are elsewhere

Arne Slot selected a second-string Liverpool team because the Reds’ priorities are elsewhere

Some felt, in fact, that Liverpool’s 1-0 defeat at Home Park might be a blessing in disguise for Slot and his team. Liverpool have bigger fish to fry and fighting on one  front fewer will give tired players the chance to recuperate as they chase shinier prizes.

It fits a context where the traditions of the tournament are being eroded. UEFA have established a European Super League by stealth in the form of the ever-expanding Champions League and our elite clubs are committed to a calendar that tries to squeeze the life out of everything else.

The FA Cup is still a showcase for the best our game has to offer, yet the FA themselves are betraying it by degrees and the Premier League, who see threats to their greed everywhere, are trying to kill it. When Crystal Palace chairman Steve Parish spoke about a battle between supermarkets and corner shops, it was the voice of the elite.

Both the FA and the Premier League will deny that, of course, but the facts tell a different story. The FA’s abolition of replays, their spreading of matches in the fourth round over five days and their moving of the FA Cup final to the penultimate weekend of the season are all betrayals.

And yet despite all this, despite the betrayals and the weakness and the compromises and the cowardice of the people who run the game, the FA Cup continues to defy them because it continues to thrive.

That was the other thing that was so beautiful about being at Home Park on Sunday. It was to realise that whatever those who have grown out of touch with the English game do, however blinded they have become, English football fans love the FA Cup too much to let it wither.

Sure, Liverpool played a second team at Plymouth so the giant-killing wasn’t quite the same as it was in the days when Hereford beat Newcastle United and Wimbledon held a Leeds United team that featured Peter Lorimer, Billy Bremner, Johnny Giles, Paul Madeley and the rest of Don Revie’s first-choice selection.

And maybe some of the fans at Home Park were disappointed not to see Mohamed Salah and Virgil van Dijk run out in Liverpool colours. But that disappointment went when the final whistle blew and when it was written in the record books that their team had beaten Liverpool.

Slot's players have a crazy schedule coming up in the next fortnight and something had to give

Slot’s players have a crazy schedule coming up in the next fortnight and something had to give

The result still played to our love of the underdog. It was still a black eye for the giants. There was still something about the occasion that got to the kernel of the appeal of the Cup: that ordinary players from lower-league clubs with uplifting stories and lives that seem almost like yours and mine can fight with the gilded elite and sometimes, they can come out on top.

That’s why the Premier League and UEFA will find it hard to kill the FA Cup. Because the competition is at the heart of what we love about football and it is at the heart of what gives English football its unique selling point.

The elite think our unique selling point is the Premier League but it isn’t. What makes English football special is its pyramid system. It is the depth of our game, the fact eight clubs in our fourth tier this season boast average crowds of more than 7,000.

In the third tier, two clubs average more than 20,000 for their home crowds. Five more average more than 10,000. That is in League One. The sickness of the Premier League is that they see that as competition, not as a brotherhood of football.

The beauty of our league is in its combination of the mighty, storied clubs such as Manchester United and Liverpool and Arsenal and the local teams such as Plymouth and Stockport County and Carlisle United and Grimsby Town.

Most football fans in this country know that. They love their own team but at some level, they love what our game stands for, too. The best of it resides in the FA Cup and the people who measure things only in money will not be able to kill it, however hard they try.

Plymouth fans may have been disappointed not to see Virgil van Dijk and Mohamed Salah play

Plymouth fans may have been disappointed not to see Virgil van Dijk and Mohamed Salah play

The best of football is in the FA Cup and those who think only of money will not be able to kill it

The best of football is in the FA Cup and those who think only of money will not be able to kill it

It’s more like Mission Impossible at United!

I don’t think I quite have the will to try to keep up with the various Missions and Projects spewing out of Old Trafford now that the influence of Sir Dave Brailsford is growing at Manchester United.

So far, the only tangible effect of Mission 1, which is predicated around United’s women’s team winning the WSL for the first time, has been to drive Alan Brazil to the brink of a hernia live on talkSPORT.

Mission 21, you will be astonished to know, revolves around the ambition of the men’s team winning another Premier League title. No one had ever thought of doing that before Sir Dave came along. That’s blue-sky thinking for you.

Inconveniently, Brailsford has helped lead United to 13th place in the table, closer to the bottom three than the top four. So maybe we’re all misunderstanding what the mission statement is. Perhaps Mission 21 means Sir Dave is committing to winning the next title before the end of this century.

Rasmus Hojlund might even have scored another goal by then.

Sir Dave Brailsford (left) has devised a plan to help Manchester United win another league title

Sir Dave Brailsford (left) has devised a plan to help Manchester United win another league title

United boss Ruben Amorim has struggled to embed his playing style since arriving last autumn

United boss Ruben Amorim has struggled to embed his playing style since arriving last autumn

Old Trafford won’t miss Sancho 

When Marcus Rashford left Manchester United on loan for Aston Villa and made his debut on Sunday, Jadon Sancho posted a one-word message on Rashford’s Instagram feed. It said, simply: ‘Freedom.’

Given that Sancho, who is on loan at Chelsea, is still a United player, it is hardly surprising some supporters at Old Trafford are less than impressed by his attitude.

They have been paying the player’s wages, on and off, for the last three years, for very little in return.

Liberation works both ways. I suspect they will be glad to be shot of Sancho when Chelsea make his move permanent in the summer.

Jadon Sancho commented on Marcus Rashford's Instagram post on Sunday to say: 'Freedom'

Jadon Sancho commented on Marcus Rashford’s Instagram post on Sunday to say: ‘Freedom’ 

Most United supporters will be happy when Sancho joins Chelsea permanently in the summer

Most United supporters will be happy when Sancho joins Chelsea permanently in the summer

Nothing quite like sport

I was at Twickenham on Saturday for England’s stunning last-gasp victory over France and the best player in the world, Antoine Dupont.

On Sunday morning, I drove down to the West Country to witness Plymouth’s FA Cup giant-killing of Liverpool and revel in the rich culture of English football. 

On Tuesday, I’ll be in Manchester to see Manchester City take on the Real Madrid of Vinicius Junior, Federico Valverde and Jude Bellingham. And on Wednesday, I’ll get to say what might be goodbye for me to one of the great cathedrals of our game, Goodison Park, when Everton host Liverpool in the Merseyside derby.

Very, very occasionally, I may need to be reminded of how fortunate I am to work in something as captivating and rich and unpredictable and inspiring as the world of sport, but it doesn’t happen often.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Cameron Norrie beats Zachary Svajda to reach Delray Beach Open second round

British number two Cameron Norrie beat American Zachary Svajda in straight sets to reach the Delray Beach Open second round. Norrie, the 2022 winner, needed 90 minutes to seal a 7-5 6-4 win over the world number 169. The players traded breaks of serve in a tight first set played in hot and humid conditions

Football gossip: Balde, Bakayoko. Delap, Cordero, Kean, Huijsen, Ancelotti, Garcia

Barcelona defender Alejandro Balde is a summer transfer target for Manchester United, with the Red Devils also battling Chelsea for Ipswich striker Liam Delap, while Newcastle eye PSV Eindhoven forward Johan Bakayoko. Manchester United are ready to submit a bid of £33.3m (40m euros) for Barcelona’s 21-year-old Spain left-back Alejandro Balde in the summer. (El

Inzaghi praises Inter’s resilience in redemption win over Fiorentina

Inter Milan manager Simone Inzaghi commended his side for their maturity and impressive mental resilience after they avenged last week’s defeat by Fiorentina with a 2-1 victory in the re-match on Monday. Inter managed to turn around their poor performance in last Thursday’s 3-0 loss to secure an important win at home, with Inzaghi praising

Transfer rumors, news: Madrid, Man Utd battling for Huijsen

Real Madrid and Manchester United are keeping tabs on AFC Bournemouth‘s Dean Huijsen, while Chelsea are exploring a deal for Nico Williams. Join us for the latest transfer news, rumors, and gossip from around the globe. Transfers homepage | Done deals | Men’s January grades | Women’s January grades TOP STORIES – Marcelinho named as

Exploring the most geographically diverse Winter Olympics venues

CORTINA D’AMPEZZO, Italy — The Milan Cortina 2026 Winter Olympics are being called the most widespread Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games in history. The nearly five-hour drive between Milan and Cortina, Italy, highlights just how geographically broad the Games’ venues are. Why so spread out? Milan Cortina 2026 is the first Winter Games to fully

Celtic host Hibs in last eight of Scottish Cup, Hearts meet Dundee

Scottish Cup holders Celtic will be at home to Hibernian in the quarter-finals of this season’s competition. Hearts, who progressed with a penalty shootout win over St Mirren prior to the draw, host Dundee, while St Johnstone go to Livingston. Queen’s Park knocked Rangers out of the tournament on Sunday and are rewarded with a

Chelsea looking at Jarrad Branthwaite again for summer move

Chelsea are once again looking at a potential deal to sign one of the Premier League’s most imposing centre backs this summer. The Blues recalled Trevoh Chalobah to the back line in the January window but other than that, they didn’t do much at all really. The transfer window closed a couple of weeks back

Marcelinho named as coach of two Brazilian clubs within 24 hours

Marcelinho played for former club Hertha Berlin in a testimonial match in 2017. Boris Streubel/Getty Images Coaching one football club is usually considered a full-on and demanding job but Marcelinho Paraiba will be dealing with double the stress after being appointed as coach of two Brazilian sides — Carioca A2 side Americano-RJ and Nacional de Patos

FA Cup draw: Plymouth rewarded with trip to face Man City

Plymouth Argyle‘s stunning victory over Liverpool on Sunday has seen them rewarded with a trip to face Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City in the fifth round of the FA Cup. The Championship’s bottom club miraculously knocked out Arne Slot’s previously all-conquering Liverpool side with a 1-0 win at Home Park thanks to Ryan Hardie’s 53rd-minute penalty.

Feyenoord sack Arne Slot’s successor before Champions League clash

Feyenoord have parted ways with manager Brian Priske, two days ahead of their Champions League knockout tie with AC Milan, the Dutch club said on Monday. Priske signed a three-year contract in June last year when he replaced Arne Slot, who left to take charge at English side Liverpool, but has been under pressure in

Madrid derby drama, Liverpool’s FA Cup exit, more reactions

The European soccer weekend didn’t disappoint — does it ever? Let’s review. In LaLiga, Real Madrid and Atlético served up a feisty derby draw that both teams can ultimately feel good about as the title race (and Champions League) look like they’ll go right down to the wire. The English FA Cup, the sport’s oldest

Espanyol complain over Barcelona’s Mapi León crotch touch

Espanyol have condemned Barcelona‘s Mapi León for touching Daniela Caracas in the crotch area during Sunday’s Catalan derby in Liga F. León and Caracas clashed in the 15th minute of the game as they lined up at a set piece, with the Barça centre-back saying something to her opponent while briefly touching her inappropriately. “Espanyol

International Olympic Committee face legal action for letting gender-row boxers Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-ting fight at the Olympics

Khelif and Yu-ting won Olympic gold in Paris despite a row over their eligibility  Both fighters had previously failed gender eligibility tests back in 2023  Now, the International Olympic Committee face legal action over the matter  By DAVID COVERDALE Published: 14:17 GMT, 10 February 2025 | Updated: 14:29 GMT, 10 February 2025 The International Olympic

Man City vs Real Madrid: Pep Guardiola plays down Ballon d’Or rift

Pep Guardiola has said Manchester City have drawn a line under the Ballon d’Or controversy with Real Madrid ahead of their Champions League showdown. The Spanish giants boycotted the ceremony in Paris in October in protest at City midfielder Rodri winning the award ahead of Vinícius Júnior. The two teams face each other in the

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x