Why Hong Kong’s legislative election is far from democratic – DW – 12/05/2025

In the shadow of a devastating high-rise apartment fire that has claimed more than 150 lives, Hong Kong is preparing to elect a new city parliament, known as the Legislative Council (LegCo), in vote set for Sunday.

Approximately 4.5 million Hong Kong residents will be able to vote for the legislative body of the former British colony. The parliament plays an important role within Hong Kong’s system of government, primarily in approving the budget.

However, only 20 seats in the 90-member parliament are elected by direct vote. In ten constituencies, the first two candidates who receive the most votes are elected directly to the LegCo.

The other 70 seats are appointed by pro-Chinese committees. Thirty of these are delegated by socially relevant groups such as finance, trade unions, and tourism, and another 40 by an electoral commission. This process is enforced by electoral regulations.

Hong Kong fire critics detained under National Security Law

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

Beijing vetting Hong Kong’s leadership

One thing is already certain: Just like the outgoing assembly, the new Hong Kong parliament will have no real opposition.

After new election laws handed down by China in 2021 the wake of pro-democracy protests, Legco is set up for “patriots only,” a euphemism for lawmakers loyal to Beijing.

Voters have since grown more apathetic, and analysts expect a low turnout on Sunday. Four years ago, turnout in the legislative vote  was just over 30%. 

Hong Kong’s electoral system is the result of a compromise agreed upon by China and the United Kingdom during the handover in 1997.  The agreement with the UK states: “One country, two systems – Hong Kong will be administered by Hong Kongers with a high degree of autonomy from Beijing.”

Since Hong Kong was returned to China, however, Beijing has been actively shaping the political according to its own interests. The central government in Beijing does not tolerate any voices or political actions aimed at establishing a Western-style democratic order in the administrative region. Most of the candidates running have been pre-selected by Beijing.

John Lee was the only candidate in the 2022 election for the last chief executive. Beijing considers the former police chief and hardliner to be a “patriot.” Non-patriots are not allowed to run, according to the recently amended election law.

National security law puts a stop on pro-democracy efforts

In the years after the 1997 handover, Hong Kong maintained a diverse political landscape. One political current was promoting pro-Beijing policies, while a second faction was made up of parties leaning towards Western-style democracy. The latter alliance was also in favor of direct and universal elections for the chief executive and Legco.

The Legislative Council in Hong Kong seen in 2024
Since at least 2021, Hong Kong’s LegCo has been packed with Beijing-backed lawmakers Image: Vernon Yuen/NurPhoto/picture alliance

Ultimately, Beijing stepped in and clamped down on large-scale pro-democracy movements, including the one seen in 2019. The Chinese People’s Congress in Beijing subsequently passed a “national security law” for Hong Kong.

Since 2020, this law determines punishment for offenses defined as “sedition,” “subversion,” and “collusion with foreign forces.” In practical terms, anyone in Hong Kong who has had contacts with foreign governments, parties, or government-affiliated foundations could be prosecuted.

Notably, Hong Kongers are also no longer allowed to hold a memorial service for the victims of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre in Beijing, which includes a march of mourners.

Foreign activists close their doors

Ironically, the security law was imposed as a replacement for a 2019 bill by the Hong Kong government that sparked the pro-democracy protests. The now-scrapped bill would have allowed Hong Kong suspects to be extradited to the Chinese justice system. The initiative failed after months of street protests and had to be withdrawn.

Under the new and more strict national security law, however, Hong Kong officials report receiving over 900,000 criminal complaints thus far.

With any links to the outside world placed under scrutiny, many international organizations have left Hong Kong in a hurry and closed their regional offices, including the human rights organization Amnesty International and the German Friedrich Naumann Foundation.

Hong Kong’s disappearing democrats

By summer 2025, more than 300 suspects had been prosecuted under the national security law. Almost half of them were found guilty and sent to jail, including pro-democracy leader Joshua Wong and media tycoon Jimmy Lai. Others, such as former LegCo member Nathan Law and activist Frances Hui, went into exile.

The Hong Kong police are currently searching for these dozens of suspects, offering a reward of up to 1 million Hong Kong dollars (approximately €110,000) for each of them.

“I knew I could go to prison for trying to make a difference, but the extent was greater than I had imagined,” said “Kelly,” a pro-democracy activist.

She is now 18 years old. In 2021, while  still a minor, she was arrested for “conspiracy to incite subversion” and “conspiracy to manufacture explosives” and spent four years in prison. Now, she is free and back in the city she no longer recognizes. “Everything feels strange,” she told DW.

End of Hong Kong Democratic Party

Hong Kong’s pro-democracy movement has never recovered from the crackdown on the protest movement and the national security law in 2020. The largest opposition party, the Hong Kong Democratic Party, was forced to dissolve in April 2025, 31 years after its founding.

Hong Kong’s last democratic opposition party disbands

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

“Following the introduction of the national security law and electoral reforms, the party’s ability to act was severely restricted.,” Stephan Ortmann, political scientist at Hong Kong Metropolitan University, told DW.

“Its members were arrested and its remaining efforts were undermined by the Chinese government’s increasing control over the political landscape, reflecting the dwindling scope for promoting liberal democracy in Hong Kong,” he added.

Hong Kong flies high as Asia’s finance hub

In 1997, China also promised that Hong Kong would retain its capitalist system for 50 years

And while prospects for true democracy remain bleak in the city, Beijing remains keen on strengthening its role as an international financial hub. Chinese stock corporations like to list themselves on the Hong Kong stock exchange to gain access to international capital markets.

The “Greater Bay Area” project, which encompasses the region around the Pearl River estuary in southern China, aims to form a more cohesive economic whole with Hong Kong and cities in the neighboring province of Guangdong.

“In recent years, Beijing has moved to connect Hong Kong more to the mainland,” analysts Lindsay Maizland und Clara Fong at the US think tank Council on Foreign Relations wrote in a recent study.

Guangdong is already China’s strongest economic province measured by gross domestic product.

“Many firms and investors are betting that this increased connectivity will boost the amount of wealth flowing from the mainland into Hong Kong,” the authors wrote.

China’s clampdown has stifled Hong Kong’s democracy movement

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

This article was translated from German 

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hong Kong’s strategy for HKIC to prop up city’s office market seen as challenging

Hong Kong’s strategy for HKIC to prop up city’s office market seen as challenging

Hong Kong’s government-backed investment fund is being redeployed to support the city’s sluggish commercial property sector, signaling authorities’ growing willingness to use public funds as a policy tool to steady office valuations and align real estate investment with the city’s industrial ambitions. Attracting foreign institutions, however, might prove challenging. The city’s elevated vacancy rates, looming

Xia Baolong is scheduled to meet local delegates in a closed-door session on Tuesday. Photo: HKMAO

‘Two sessions’ to ‘focus on Hong Kong’s financial role, Northern Metropolis’

Hundreds of Hong Kong politicians and business leaders head to Beijing on Tuesday for the nation’s annual “two sessions”, with observers expecting discussions to focus on the city’s role as an international financial centre and the Northern Metropolis megaproject. The annual session of the country’s top political advisory body, the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference

無綫新聞 TVB News

Financial Secretary calls Middle East an essential market to HK

發佈日期: 2026-03-02 21:35 TVB News 粵 已複製連結 Financial Secretary Paul Chan stressed the Middle East is an essential market to Hong Kong, adding that maintaining decent ties between the nation and the region will greatly benefit the city. This as the FS said Hong Kong remains a safe haven-port in times of conflict, further noting

Everyware rolls out self-checkout kiosks for Hong Kong restaurants

Everyware rolls out self-checkout kiosks for Hong Kong restaurants

The kiosk supports a range of digital payment options, including local and international e-wallets. Credit: Everyware Limited / PR Newswire. Restaurant tech company Everyware has introduced Caterlord Checkout, a self-service payment kiosk for restaurants in Hong Kong. According to the company, the new system is intended to expedite bill settlement, ease pressure on staff and

HK residents in Middle East prioritize return of people and capital

HK residents in Middle East prioritize return of people and capital

Planes are parked at Terminal 3 of the Dubai International Airport, following the United States and Israel strikes on Iran, in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, March 2, 2026. (PHOTO / REUTERS) Some of the over 400 Hong Kong residents stranded in the Middle East, as the United States and Israeli militaries continued to launch airstrikes

Middle East tensions highlight Hong Kong’s stability, opportunities: labour minister

Middle East tensions highlight Hong Kong’s stability, opportunities: labour minister

Conflicts in the Middle East highlight Hong Kong’s attractiveness as a talent hub promising safety and stability, the city’s labour chief has said. Secretary for Labour and Welfare Chris Sun Yuk-han on Monday said that while Hong Kong already drew global talent because of its status as an international city, its safety and security were

Middle East conflict to drive up airfares for Hong Kong travellers: analysts

Middle East conflict to drive up airfares for Hong Kong travellers: analysts

The escalating conflict in the Middle East is set to drive up travel costs for Hong Kong passengers as many are forced to opt for more expensive direct routes to Europe, according to analysts. They said on Monday that the suspension of major transit hubs in Dubai in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Doha

HKUST may reserve 20% of new medical school inaugural intake for non-locals

HKUST may reserve 20% of new medical school inaugural intake for non-locals

About 20 per cent of the 50 places in the inaugural intake of Hong Kong University of Science and Technology’s new graduate medical school in 2028-29 may be reserved for non-local students, with most of them likely to be from mainland China, according to the institution. Applicants for the four-year graduate entry-level medicine programme must

Hong Kong skyline

Hong Kong to move forwards with tax exemption for ILS investments

Hong Kong’s Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury Christopher Hui explained today that the government aims to enhance its preferential tax regime and extend the eligible asset classes for tax exemptions to include insurance-linked securities (ILS), such as catastrophe bonds.The goal is to enhance competitiveness of its financial marketplace and attract more investors to

Hong Kong man gets 4 years for fatal fight over bicycle payment

Hong Kong man gets 4 years for fatal fight over bicycle payment

A Hong Kong man has been sentenced to four years in prison for fatally assaulting a construction worker who refused to pay HK$800 (US$102) for a bicycle from the defendant. The High Court on Monday sentenced Wong Koon-ming for manslaughter after a seven-member jury earlier this year cleared him of murder but convicted him of

Hong Kong, Shanghai sign pact on digital trade finance, cross-border data link

Hong Kong, Shanghai sign pact on digital trade finance, cross-border data link

Hong Kong and Shanghai have signed an accord deepening their collaboration in promoting digitised cargo trade finance and strengthening mainland China’s connection to the global data ecosystem. The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) on Monday signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the Shanghai Data Bureau and the National Technology Innovation Centre for Blockchain, according

Mainland Chinese firm to build Northern Metropolis supercomputing centre

Mainland Chinese firm to build Northern Metropolis supercomputing centre

A mainland Chinese firm has secured the tender to build a supercomputing centre in Hong Kong’s Northern Metropolis as the sole bidder, agreeing to pay a premium of HK$581 million (US$74.25 million) and boost the city’s computing power 36-fold. Unveiling details of the plan on Monday, Secretary for Innovation, Technology and Industry Sun Dong said

Liberty logo

Cynthia Sze to lead Liberty’s unified Hong Kong unit as CEO

Liberty, part of Liberty Mutual Insurance Group, a property and casualty insurer, has appointed Cynthia Sze as Chief Executive Officer (CEO), Hong Kong, effective May 2026, subject to regulatory approval. Liberty’s Hong Kong entity will be unified following the integration of its operations under a single licence, proposed to go into effect on April 1st,

Rainy Tuesday expected in Hong Kong, with temperatures dipping to 16 degrees Celsius

Rainy Tuesday expected in Hong Kong, with temperatures dipping to 16 degrees Celsius

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. Hongkongers should brace for cooler and rainy weather on Tuesday as temperatures are expected to drop progressively to as low as 16 degrees Celsius (61 Fahrenheit) as a cold front approaches, according to the

Hong Kong to expand tax exemptions for family offices, AIIB and pension fund investment

Hong Kong to expand tax exemptions for family offices, AIIB and pension fund investment

In a financial affairs panel meeting, Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury, Christopher Hui Ching-yu, said the government would submit a bill to the Legislative Council within the first half of this year that would make more products that family offices and funds invest in eligible for tax exemptions. These include private credit, gold

Hong Kong exporters and exhibitors face fallout from US-Israel strikes on Iran

Hong Kong exporters and exhibitors face fallout from US-Israel strikes on Iran

Adverse impacts from the US-Israel strikes on Iran unfolded on Monday, disrupting supply chains, driving up oil prices and leaving many Middle East business leaders at a major trade fair in Hong Kong in an awkward position. As the strikes entered a third day, oil prices surged 13 per cent – the biggest rise in

Hong Kong, Kyrgyz Republic sign pact to avoid double taxation

Hong Kong, Kyrgyz Republic sign pact to avoid double taxation

Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury Christopher Hui Ching-yu (right) and Minister of Economy and Commerce of the Kyrgyz Republic Bakyt Tolomushevich Sydykov (left) sign on behalf of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government and the Government of Kyrgyz Republic, respectively, a comprehensive avoidance of double taxation agreement during an online bilateral meeting

Liberty confirms Cynthia Sze appointment to lead unified Hong Kong unit as duo depart

Liberty confirms Cynthia Sze appointment to lead unified Hong Kong unit as duo depart

Liberty confirms Cynthia Sze appointment to lead unified Hong Kong unit as duo depart March 2 2026 by Andrew Mullen Liberty have confirmed the appointment of Cynthia Sze as CEO of its combined Hong Kong unit, effective from May, subject to regulatory approval, confirming an earlier report from  InsuranceAsia News.… To continue reading the full

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x