What each side wants from a peace deal

EPA A woman and two young girls walk near a makeshift memorial to the fallen Ukrainian servicemen and international volunteers, in Independence Square in Kyiv, Ukraine. The monument is covered in flags and photographs. Flowers adorn the foot of the structure.EPA

Ukraine’s future is the focus of the Munich Security Conference (MSC), just days after a shock phone call between US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in which they agreed to begin negotiations to end the Ukraine war.

Describing the call earlier this week as “great”, Trump said there was a “good possibility of ending that horrible, very bloody war”.

Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky warned that his country must not be left out of any peace talks.

European allies seemed surprised at the nature of the call, with French President Emmanuel Macron warning that any peace agreement which involved capitulating to Russia would end “badly for everyone”.

It is still unclear when peace negotiations could begin, but when they do issues around territory, security negotiations and Ukraine’s future in Nato will be among the key topics for discussion. Here’s where the different sides stand.

What territory has Ukraine lost and will it be returned?

Map of Ukraine showing the Russian control of Ukraine territory

The five territories annexed by Russia

Moscow currently controls around a fifth of Ukraine’s territory, mainly in the south and east.

Following the overthrow of Ukraine’s pro-Russian president in 2014, Russia annexed the Black Sea peninsula of Crimea and backed pro-Russian separatists in bloody fighting in the regions of Donetsk and Luhansk.

The conflict then burst into all-out war nearly three years ago after Russia’s full-scale invasion.

Moscow’s attempts to seize the capital Kyiv were thwarted, but Russian forces have since slowly expanded their territorial control, mostly in the east.

Ukrainian forces, supported by arms and equipment from the US and European allies, have made those advances as difficult as possible and have at times been able to retake territory, as well as stage a counter-offensive into western Russia.

Ukraine has always insisted any peace deal must include the full withdrawal of Russian troops from Ukraine back to the pre-2014 borders, including Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk.

“We will never recognise occupied territories as Russian,” Zelensky said at a press conference during the MSC.

Russia, on the other hand, has formally annexed four regions of east and south Ukraine and wants them to be recognised as part of Russia – despite not being in control of all the territory in those regions.

In an interview with the Guardian, Zelensky suggested that Russian-held territory in Ukraine could be swapped for territory seized by Ukraine in Russia’s western Kursk region as part of a peace deal. However, the Kremlin swiftly ruled that out.

Until recently, Ukraine’s western allies stood by Zelensky’s position that all of Ukraine, including Crimea, should be returned.

But the new US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth poured cold water on those hopes, saying at a summit in February that achieving pre-2014 borders was an “unrealistic objective”.

“Chasing this illusionary goal will only prolong the war and cause more suffering,” he said.

Could Ukraine become a Nato member?

A map showing Nato members across Europe

Ukraine wants to join Nato, arguing that the western military alliance – in which members pledge to defend one another if attacked – is the best way to ensure its security.

For Kyiv, Russia’s full-scale invasion is proof that only Nato membership can guarantee its security.

However, Russia has consistently opposed the idea of Ukraine becoming a member, fearing it would bring Nato forces too close to its borders.

As he arrived for the MSC, Zelensky said Ukraine trusted Nato’s security guarantees, before adding that he thought membership would be “the cheapest option for everyone”.

Europe needs to unite around Ukraine to protect itself, he added.

Nato members have consistently argued that Ukraine should become a Nato member in the future, with UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer telling Zelensky that the country is on “an irreversible path” to membership.

But those guarantees are now looking less solid, after the US defence secretary downplayed the likelihood of Nato membership for Ukraine in any peace settlement.

“The United States does not believe that Nato membership for Ukraine is a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement,” Hegseth said.

What security guarantees could be in place?

Getty Images Volodymyr Zelensky looks over reporters during a press conference. The yellow and blue of the Ukrainian flag can be seen over his shoulder.Getty Images

Zelensky also claimed intelligence shows Russia is preparing for a war against Nato

Zelensky has said previous discussions with US President Donald Trump are “definitely not enough to form a plan” for peace.

Speaking as he arrived at the MSC, he said that signals coming from the US were “strong” but “varied”.

Hegseth claimed Trump was the “one man in the world” capable of bringing both sides together and insisted US attempts to negotiate peace were “certainly not a betrayal” of the Ukrainian soldiers fighting invading Russian forces.

Meanwhile, the US vice-president said sending troops to Ukraine is “still on the table” should Russia fail to negotiate a peace deal in good faith.

“The president is not going into this with blinders on,” JD Vance told the told the Wall Street Journal.

Back in October, Zelensky laid out his victory plan to Ukraine’s parliament, which included key points like Nato membership, joint US and EU protection of critical natural resources, and the containment of Russia via a non-nuclear strategic deterrent package deployed on Ukrainian soil.

The US president at the time, Joe Biden, was given a briefing on this plan – as were then-presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump.

It is unclear whether any part of Zelensky’s plans will be taken forward to peace talks, but Hesgeth has warned there would be no US troops on the ground Ukraine in any future security arrangement.

Zelensky told the Guardian that he does not believe security guarantees without US involvement will work.

UK defence sources quoted in the Times newspaper claim that the US could provide some form of air defence – possibly Patriot missiles – to a peacekeeping force in Ukraine in return for access to minerals.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Auto executive tells CNBC auto tariffs will drive auto industry into recession

GM, Stellantis shares fall after Trump’s auto tariff announcement

The border wall is shown in a background as a semi-truck carrying Toyota trucks crosses a bridge after clearing U.S. Customs while entering the United States from Mexico along the border in San Diego, California, on March 4, 2025. Mike Blake | Reuters Auto stocks are digesting President Donald Trump’s announcement that he would place

Eight killed in several attacks in southwest Pakistan: police

Eight killed in several attacks in southwest Pakistan: police | World News

At least eight people have been killed in multiple attacks in southwestern Pakistan, police said Thursday, with assailants targeting bus passengers based on their ethnicity and security forces. Eight killed in several attacks in southwest Pakistan: police Pakistan has been battling a separatist insurgency in Balochistan for decades, where militants target state forces, foreign nationals

President Donald Trump speaks to the press after signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House on Wednesday in Washington, DC.

Live updates: Trump presidency news, Signal leak and car tariff

In Donald Trump’s White House, it matters less what you screw up than how hard you fight back. The uproar over operational details of military strikes on Yemen posted on a group chat among top administration officials is highlighting this fundamental rule of life in the president’s orbit. Naive and sloppy behavior by top Trump

How strong wind, pine trees and dry land fuelled the blaze

How strong wind, pine trees and dry land fuelled the blaze

Getty Images Strong wind, dry land and pine trees are a dangerous combination for wildfires, experts say Strong winds, dense forest and unusually dry weather – that’s the deadly combination that experts say is fuelling the largest wildfires in South Korea’s history. The inferno in the south-east has burned through 35,810 hectares (88,500 acres) as

Coeliac disease impacts one in 100 people. (Getty Images)

What we know about coeliac disease as Rebecca Adlington diagnosed with condition

Rebecca Adlington has called on the government to help raise awareness of coeliac disease after revealing she has been diagnosed with the condition. The Team GM Olympic swimmer, 36, shared shared a video clip to Coeliac UK’s Instagram account on Wednesday (26 March) revealing details of the condition and highlighting a petition, given to the

Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky answers journalists during a TV special with the European Broadcasting Union's medias.(AFP)

Ukraine’s Zelensky predicts Vladimir Putin’s death: ‘…it will come to an end’ | World News

Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky has made a bold assessment while speaking on the ongoing war with Russia when he predicted that his counterpart “Vladimir Putin will die soon”, calling it a “fact”, The Mirror reported. Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky answers journalists during a TV special with the European Broadcasting Union’s medias.(AFP) The Ukrainian leader was

On The Ground

Turkey protests: Students pepper sprayed, arrested in clash over Istanbul mayor’s arrest

On The Ground newsletter: Get a weekly dispatch from our international correspondents Get a weekly dispatch from our international correspondents Get a weekly international news dispatch Tensions flared anew in Turkey’s capital, Ankara, as police clashed with student protesters early Thursday, deploying pepper spray, plastic pellets, and water cannons. This latest confrontation threatens to reignite

Trump's autos tariffs are a 'nightmare' scenario: Bernstein

Trump threatens ‘far larger’ tariffs on EU and Canada

U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to the media in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., March 26, 2025. Evelyn Hockstein | Reuters U.S. President Donald Trump threatened to impose “far larger” tariffs on the European Union (EU) and Canada if they work together to combat trade tariffs. “If the European

King Charles meets local media journalists at Buckingham Palace. Picture: PA Media

King pays tribute to UK local media at Buckingham Palace

King Charles meets local media journalists at Buckingham Palace. Picture: PA Media Journalists from Elgin to Exeter were honoured last night at a lavish Buckingham Palace reception to celebrate the work of local media across the UK. Both the King and Queen were present and spent time circulating and meeting many of the 400 guests

South Korea accused of 'mass exporting' children in overseas adoptions

South Korea accused of ‘mass exporting’ children in overseas adoptions

Tessa Wong, Hosu Lee and Jean Mackenzie BBC News News1 The commission’s chairperson Park Sun-young (left) comforted adoptee Yooree Kim (right) during an emotionally charged press conference South Korean governments committed numerous human rights violations over decades in a controversial programme that sent at least 170,000 children and babies abroad for adoption, a landmark inquiry

NewJeans tell BBC why they spoke out

NewJeans tell BBC why they spoke out

Juna Moon & Fan Wang Reporting fromSeoul and Singapore Watch: Hanni got emotional as the group reacted to court ruling “It took a huge amount of courage to speak out,” NewJeans have told the BBC in their first interview since a court blocked their attempt to leave their record label, in a case that has

An-unrestrained-Israel-is-reshaping-the-Middle-Eas

An unrestrained Israel is reshaping the Middle East | World News

Israel’s 15-month assault on Gaza has battered Hamas; it can no longer mount a serious attack. Hizbullah, a Shia militia in Lebanon, is also reeling after Israel pummelled it, too. In addition, the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad, Syria’s dictator, has cut Hizbullah’s main supply line to Iran. The “ring of fire” around Israel that Iran

Taiwan sentences four soldiers for spying for China

Taiwan sentences four soldiers for spying for China | World News

Four Taiwanese soldiers, including three from a unit in charge of security for the president’s office, have been sentenced to prison for photographing and leaking confidential information to China, a court said. Taiwan sentences four soldiers for spying for China The number of people prosecuted for spying for Beijing has risen sharply in recent years,

Why are India's private firms not investing despite record profits?

Why are India’s private firms not investing despite record profits?

Nikhil Inamdar BBC News, Mumbai Getty Private sector expenditure in overall investments in India’s economy dipped to a decadal low What will it take for India’s private companies to begin investing in building new factories and firms? It’s a question that’s confounded policymakers for years. As a share of gross domestic product (GDP), private investment

DR Congo conflict tests China's diplomatic balancing act

DR Congo conflict tests China’s diplomatic balancing act

Jack Lau Global China Unit, BBC World Service Getty Images Rwandan-backed M23 rebels have taken control of two major cities in eastern DR Congo in the past two months China’s efforts to build up huge business interests across Africa have been accompanied by a careful policy of maintaining neutrality – but the conflict in the

Three sensitive messages from Yemen strike Signal chat unpacked and explained

Three sensitive messages from Yemen strike Signal chat unpacked and explained

Bernd Debusmann Jr BBC News, White House Watch: How the Signal group chat fallout unfolded in 36 hours A discussion by high-ranking US security officials about US air strikes on Yemen has been published in full by the Atlantic magazine. The group chat on the Signal app mistakenly included the Atlantic’s editor-in-chief Jeffrey Goldberg. After

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x