What each side wants from a peace deal

EPA A woman and two young girls walk near a makeshift memorial to the fallen Ukrainian servicemen and international volunteers, in Independence Square in Kyiv, Ukraine. The monument is covered in flags and photographs. Flowers adorn the foot of the structure.EPA

Ukraine’s future is the focus of the Munich Security Conference (MSC), just days after a shock phone call between US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in which they agreed to begin negotiations to end the Ukraine war.

Describing the call earlier this week as “great”, Trump said there was a “good possibility of ending that horrible, very bloody war”.

Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky warned that his country must not be left out of any peace talks.

European allies seemed surprised at the nature of the call, with French President Emmanuel Macron warning that any peace agreement which involved capitulating to Russia would end “badly for everyone”.

It is still unclear when peace negotiations could begin, but when they do issues around territory, security negotiations and Ukraine’s future in Nato will be among the key topics for discussion. Here’s where the different sides stand.

What territory has Ukraine lost and will it be returned?

Map of Ukraine showing the Russian control of Ukraine territory

The five territories annexed by Russia

Moscow currently controls around a fifth of Ukraine’s territory, mainly in the south and east.

Following the overthrow of Ukraine’s pro-Russian president in 2014, Russia annexed the Black Sea peninsula of Crimea and backed pro-Russian separatists in bloody fighting in the regions of Donetsk and Luhansk.

The conflict then burst into all-out war nearly three years ago after Russia’s full-scale invasion.

Moscow’s attempts to seize the capital Kyiv were thwarted, but Russian forces have since slowly expanded their territorial control, mostly in the east.

Ukrainian forces, supported by arms and equipment from the US and European allies, have made those advances as difficult as possible and have at times been able to retake territory, as well as stage a counter-offensive into western Russia.

Ukraine has always insisted any peace deal must include the full withdrawal of Russian troops from Ukraine back to the pre-2014 borders, including Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk.

“We will never recognise occupied territories as Russian,” Zelensky said at a press conference during the MSC.

Russia, on the other hand, has formally annexed four regions of east and south Ukraine and wants them to be recognised as part of Russia – despite not being in control of all the territory in those regions.

In an interview with the Guardian, Zelensky suggested that Russian-held territory in Ukraine could be swapped for territory seized by Ukraine in Russia’s western Kursk region as part of a peace deal. However, the Kremlin swiftly ruled that out.

Until recently, Ukraine’s western allies stood by Zelensky’s position that all of Ukraine, including Crimea, should be returned.

But the new US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth poured cold water on those hopes, saying at a summit in February that achieving pre-2014 borders was an “unrealistic objective”.

“Chasing this illusionary goal will only prolong the war and cause more suffering,” he said.

Could Ukraine become a Nato member?

A map showing Nato members across Europe

Ukraine wants to join Nato, arguing that the western military alliance – in which members pledge to defend one another if attacked – is the best way to ensure its security.

For Kyiv, Russia’s full-scale invasion is proof that only Nato membership can guarantee its security.

However, Russia has consistently opposed the idea of Ukraine becoming a member, fearing it would bring Nato forces too close to its borders.

As he arrived for the MSC, Zelensky said Ukraine trusted Nato’s security guarantees, before adding that he thought membership would be “the cheapest option for everyone”.

Europe needs to unite around Ukraine to protect itself, he added.

Nato members have consistently argued that Ukraine should become a Nato member in the future, with UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer telling Zelensky that the country is on “an irreversible path” to membership.

But those guarantees are now looking less solid, after the US defence secretary downplayed the likelihood of Nato membership for Ukraine in any peace settlement.

“The United States does not believe that Nato membership for Ukraine is a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement,” Hegseth said.

What security guarantees could be in place?

Getty Images Volodymyr Zelensky looks over reporters during a press conference. The yellow and blue of the Ukrainian flag can be seen over his shoulder.Getty Images

Zelensky also claimed intelligence shows Russia is preparing for a war against Nato

Zelensky has said previous discussions with US President Donald Trump are “definitely not enough to form a plan” for peace.

Speaking as he arrived at the MSC, he said that signals coming from the US were “strong” but “varied”.

Hegseth claimed Trump was the “one man in the world” capable of bringing both sides together and insisted US attempts to negotiate peace were “certainly not a betrayal” of the Ukrainian soldiers fighting invading Russian forces.

Meanwhile, the US vice-president said sending troops to Ukraine is “still on the table” should Russia fail to negotiate a peace deal in good faith.

“The president is not going into this with blinders on,” JD Vance told the told the Wall Street Journal.

Back in October, Zelensky laid out his victory plan to Ukraine’s parliament, which included key points like Nato membership, joint US and EU protection of critical natural resources, and the containment of Russia via a non-nuclear strategic deterrent package deployed on Ukrainian soil.

The US president at the time, Joe Biden, was given a briefing on this plan – as were then-presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump.

It is unclear whether any part of Zelensky’s plans will be taken forward to peace talks, but Hesgeth has warned there would be no US troops on the ground Ukraine in any future security arrangement.

Zelensky told the Guardian that he does not believe security guarantees without US involvement will work.

UK defence sources quoted in the Times newspaper claim that the US could provide some form of air defence – possibly Patriot missiles – to a peacekeeping force in Ukraine in return for access to minerals.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Netanyahu, the first sitting Israeli prime minister to be charged with a crime, denies charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust brought in 2019 after years of investigations. (Reuters file)

Israeli PM Netanyahu requests delay in his corruption trial testimony

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has asked to postpone giving testimony in his long-running corruption trial that was set to resume next week, citing the ongoing security situation in the region, Netanyahu’s lawyer said in a court filing on Friday. Netanyahu, the first sitting Israeli prime minister to be charged with a crime, denies charges of

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Ukrainians and Russians Doubt 32-Hour Easter Truce Will Lead to Lasting Peace

KYIV, April 10 (Reuters) – Ukrainian officials urged Russia on Friday to extend ⁠a ⁠ceasefire it announced for Orthodox Easter this ⁠weekend and restart talks to end the war, but people on the streets of Kyiv ​and Moscow doubted it would lead to lasting peace. Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday announced a 32-hour ceasefire

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Vance Warns Iran Not to ‘Play Us’ as He Leaves for Talks

LOS ANGELES, April ⁠10 (Reuters) – ⁠Vice President ⁠JD Vance said ​on Friday he was looking ‌forward to having ‌positive negotiations ⁠with ⁠Iran as he left for talks ​in Pakistan with a warning to Tehran not ​to “play us.” “We’re looking forward to ⁠the ⁠negotiation. I ⁠think it’s ​going to be positive,” Vance ​told reporters

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

China’s Top Diplomat Meets North Korea’s Kim, Calls for Closer Coordination

BEIJING, April 10 (Reuters) – China and ⁠North ⁠Korea should further ⁠enhance communication and coordination in major ​international and regional affairs, China’s foreign minister said in ‌a meeting with North ‌Korean leader Kim Jong Un on Friday, ⁠a ⁠Chinese official statement showed. Minister Wang Yi is on a ​two-day visit to Pyongyang from Thursday that

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

China Involvement in Iran Would Complicate Matters

WASHINGTON, April 10 (Reuters) – U.S. ⁠Trade ⁠Representative Jamieson Greer ⁠said on Friday that the United ​States is trying to maintain a stable ‌relationship with China, but ‌if Beijing gets involved with ⁠Iran in ⁠a way that is counter to U.S. interests, ​that would complicate matters. “The underlying goals of our economies are so different.

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Mali Backs Morocco’s Autonomy Plan for Western Sahara

BAMAKO, April 10 (Reuters) – Mali supports Morocco’s autonomy plan ⁠for ⁠Western Sahara, Foreign Minister Abdoulaye ⁠Diop said on Friday, becoming the latest African country to ​endorse Rabat’s vision for ending a 50-year conflict with the Algeria-backed Polisario Front. Morocco’s proposal would establish ‌a local legislative, executive and judicial ‌authority for Western Sahara elected by

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Kremlin Says Putin Envoy’s US Visit Does Not Mean Ukraine Talks Have Resumed

MOSCOW, April 10 (Reuters) – The Kremlin said ⁠on ⁠Friday that a ⁠visit to the United States by Russian President ​Vladimir Putin’s special investment envoy did not mean that negotiations on ‌a possible peace deal in ‌Ukraine had resumed. Reuters reported on Thursday, citing sources with ⁠knowledge ⁠of the visit, that Kirill Dmitriev, Putin’s envoy,

Strait of Hormuz is one of the world's most strategically vital maritime chokepoints, serving as the only sea link between the Persian Gulf and the Arabian Sea.

‘I’ll be upset if you pay’: Iran takes jibe at Hormuz blockade amid $2 million fee

As a fragile, two-week ceasefire holds between the United States and Iran, diplomacy is not just unfolding at negotiating tables — it is also playing out online, with Iranian missions across the globe responding to Washington’s pressure with humour. Strait of Hormuz is one of the world’s most strategically vital maritime chokepoints, serving as the

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Factbox-Details of U.S. Troops Based in Europe as Trump Mulls Removing Some

April 10 (Reuters) – U.S. President Donald Trump has discussed with his advisers the option ⁠of ⁠removing some U.S. troops from Europe, a senior ⁠White House official told Reuters on Thursday. The internal deliberations come after Trump expressed his discontent with what ​he sees as NATO allies’ lack of action to help secure the Strait

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

UK’s Starmer and Trump Discussed Military Options for Strait of Hormuz

LONDON, April 10 (Reuters) – British ⁠Prime ⁠Minister Keir Starmer ⁠said on Friday that he ​discussed military capabilities and the logistics of ‌moving vessels though the ‌Strait of Hormuz when he ⁠spoke ⁠to U.S. President Donald Trump a day earlier. “We’ve ​been pulling together a coalition of countries … working on a political, diplomatic plan,

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Ukraine in Talks With Oman, Kuwait, Bahrain on Security Cooperation, Zelenskiy Says

KYIV, April 10 (Reuters) – Ukraine ⁠is ⁠in talks with ⁠Oman, Kuwait and Bahrain to cooperate ​in the security sector and share its ‌drone defence expertise and ‌technology, President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said. Zelenskiy visited ⁠several ⁠Middle Eastern countries last month to offer Ukraine’s ​technology and expertise on how to counter Iranian drone attacks. Security cooperation

China’s car exports surge as expectations grow for EV pivot on Iran war energy shock

China’s car exports surge as expectations grow for EV pivot on Iran war energy shock

HONG KONG (AP) — China’s exports of passenger cars accelerated in March, an industry association said Friday, as Chinese automakers stepped up their push to grow overseas markets. Passenger car exports jumped 82.4% year-on-year last month to around 748,000 vehicles, according to the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers, up from the 586,000 vehicles exported in

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Taiwan’s Opposition Leader Meets China’s Xi Jinping as Both Sides Call for Peace

BEIJING (AP) — Taiwan’s opposition leader met Friday with Chinese President Xi Jinping at Beijing’s Great Hall of the People, the first such encounter in over a decade, with both sides affirming the need for maintaining peace around the self-ruled island island China claims as its territory. Both Xi and Cheng Li-wun, the head of

An abstract, avant-garde painting featuring overlapping, geometric shapes and waves of bold colors, representing the fractured and chaotic nature of the UK government's decision-making around local elections.

Labour’s U-Turn on UK Local Elections Sparks Fiery Debate

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. › As the UK government’s last-minute reversal on local elections sparks a fiery debate, the political turmoil is captured in a fractured, high-energy visual metaphor.Exeter Today The UK government’s sudden decision to reverse plans to postpone local elections in May has sparked a fiery debate, with Labour’s health

A devotee dressed as a townsperson takes part in a Way of the Cross reenactment in Arraijan, Panama, Good Friday, April 3, 2026. (AP Photo/Matias Delacroix)

Moscow Will Not Abandon Cuba, Help With Energy

April 10 (Reuters) – Russia will never abandon or betray ⁠Cuba ⁠and plans to help the ⁠Communist island tackle energy issues linked to a U.S. embargo, a Russian ​deputy foreign minister was quoted as saying early on Friday after talks in Havana. Sergei Ryabkov, quoted ‌by Russian news agencies at a ‌news conference in the

What will it take to get ships going through the Strait of Hormuz again?

What will it take to get ships going through the Strait of Hormuz again?

Crawley, Wednesday’s ceasefire announcement by President Donald Trump, linked to Iran reopening the Strait of Hormuz, prompted immediate optimism shipping would quickly resume. It didn’t. What will it take to get ships going through the Strait of Hormuz again? The following morning, traffic remained minimal. A handful of vessels, largely linked to Iran, made the

How the U.S.-Israeli Strikes on Iran Have Damaged Schools and Hospitals

How the U.S.-Israeli Strikes on Iran Have Damaged Schools and Hospitals

As a fragile cease-fire takes hold, Iran is sorting through the wreckage from U.S.-Israeli strikes, which have exacted a heavy toll on its civilian infrastructure. The New York Times has verified damage to 22 schools and 17 health care facilities, a fraction of the devastation in the war so far. Hedayat Boys’ High School Shajarah

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x