Unfairly maligned or calcio in crisis? Atalanta’s success shouldn’t distract from the failings of Italy’s top teams in the Champions League

The symbolism of Christian Vieri and Ronaldo turning up to watch Inter get knocked out of the Champions League by Bodo/Glimt wasn’t lost on anyone. The Nerazzurri may be the strongest side in Serie A right now, but Italian football is no longer producing world-class strikers like the former Azzurri ace or signing superstars like ‘Il Fenomeno’.  

As Thierry Henry quipped in the CBS Sports studio before kick-off, “They could do with both of you tonight!” Ronaldo responded, “We could maybe play five minutes!” Inter fans probably would have taken him up on that offer!

More than 70,000 of them – almost double the population of Bodo – had arrived at San Siro hoping to see their side prove that the plastic pitch was the problem in last week’s shocking 3-1 first-leg loss. They instead witnessed a Norwegian team put on a show at ‘La Scala del Calcio’ for the second time in three months that made a complete mockery of Italian football. 

Juventus legend Alessandro Del Piero joked about being on the verge of tears before the play-off round second legs, given all three Italian teams were trailing on aggregate, and the nation’s reigning champions, Napoli, had failed to even get out of the league phase. However, the Juventus legend did argue that “not everything is as bad as it seems”. And he had a point. At least in the case of Atalanta, who really shouldn’t be cast in anything like the same negative light as Inter, Juve or Napoli.

“This is a match that will go down in history, not just here in Bergamo for all the Atalanta fans, but for Italian football as a whole,” coach Raffaelle Palladino told Sky Sport Italia. “I heard a lot of comments about Italian football and I think it ought to be protected, above all from the inside. We are too harsh when things don’t go well, we need more constructive criticism, to be a bit more positive, and we proved that this evening.”

Atalanta, though, are something of a rarity in Italy: a wonderfully well-run club renowned for its ability to both identify and develop young players before later selling them at an enormous profit – while at same time remaining competitive in Serie A and Europe. Indeed, La Dea’s dismantling of Xabi Alonso’s seemingly unbeatable Bayer Leverkusen in the final of the 2024 Europa League was the culmination of an ambitious, long-term project rooted in the economic reality of modern football that provided the perfect template for other Serie A sides to follow.

However, while Bologna and a very well-funded Como are also now showing what’s possible with a clear, coherent strategy, Italy’s top teams are nowhere near as shrewd, stable – or even successful.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Champions League: Atalanta only Serie A team into last 16 – so what is going on with Italian football? | Football News

Atalanta pulled off a thrilling, last-gasp turnaround to make it to the Champions League last 16. Juventus battled valiantly into extra-time with 10 men. But that show of fight hasn’t lifted the dark cloud which settled over Italian football this week. A 98th-minute penalty, converted by Atalanta’s Lazar Samardzic, means there will be Italian representation

Cristiano Ronaldo buys 25 per cent stake in Saudi-owned Spanish side Almeria

Cristiano Ronaldo has bought a 25 per cent stake in Spanish second-tier side UD Almeria. Ronaldo, 41, has joined an ownership group led by the Saudi Media Company, the operator of Al Nassr’s stadium Mrsool Park, via a subsidiary of the forward’s investment brand CR7 SA. Almeria are third in Spain’s second division, two points

Haaland, Rice, Semenyo: Who is your Premier League Player of the Year?

Feb 26, 2026, 04:55 AM ET We’re fast approaching the business end of the 2025-26 Premier League season, and heading into March, everything is still very much to play for. The title race has coalesced into a two-team battle between leaders Arsenal and chasers Manchester City, while the push for Champions League soccer next season

The Alternative Premier League Table: No 28 – Late goals

Welcome to the latest edition of The Alternative Premier League Table, where each week, The Athletic analyses the entire division through a specific lens. After looking at crosses in last week’s edition, this week we will dive into late goals, with 85 minutes into games our chosen threshold for a late strike throughout this article.

The top 10 biggest derbies and rivalries in German football, including Der Klassiker

Robert Lewandowski of Bayern Munich and Marco Reus of Borussia Dortmund in conversation on December 5, 2021 – photo via speedpix / Alamy / Iconsport Germany’s football culture is one of the strongest in the world, and as such there are a huge number of rivalries and derbies contested every season, even if clashes between

Only Atalanta made the Champions League last 16. But is Serie A really that bad?

The shock value is notable. The Serie A champions not making it through the Champions League league phase. The current best in class and league leaders by 10 points going out to Bodo/Glimt. Two teams exiting in the play-off round this season. Three last season. Eliminations at the hands of Belgians and the Dutch in

Manchester United set sights on summer move for Villarreal star

Manchester United are set to explore the La Liga market this summer, as they seek to improve Michael Carrick’s squad. They have plans to bring in a new midfielder, with former Real Madrid man Casemiro already confirmed to be leaving at the end of the season. There are an abundance of top midfielders currently plying

Arsenal vs Manchester City: Analysing the Premier League title race

Strap yourselves in, we have ourselves a proper title race. Five points separate Manchester City from league leaders Arsenal, which could close to just two if City win their game in hand on Mikel Arteta’s side.  With the pair due to play each other in the Premier League in April, that means the title is

The danger is real for Tottenham as specter of Premier League relegation looms

What’s been increasingly apparent to despairing Tottenham fans for some months is now suddenly clear for everyone: their team could genuinely be relegated from the Premier League. Spurs have been regarded for some time as part of England’s so-called “Big Six” — so much so that they were involved in the quickly aborted Super League

This late-season trend means value bets in the Premier League and Bundesliga

Heidenheim, Real Oviedo and Burnley are among Europe’s struggling teams that have taken a more proactive approach in their bid for survival. Goal markets Odds Werder Bremen vs Heidenheim – Over 2.5 & BTTS +101 Burnley vs Brentford – Over 2.5 -125 Fulham vs West Ham – Over 2.5 & BTTS +105 Odds courtesy of

Kylian Mbappe Injury Updates Sours Champions League Win for Real Madrid

Real Madrid manager Álvaro Arbeloa could not specify a recovery timeline for superstar forward Kylian Mbappé, only revealing that the Frenchman will be out for as long as it takes his “discomfort to disappear.” Mbappé was an unexpected absence for Los Blancos in their 2–1 victory over Benfica in the second leg of the Champions

The biggest and fiercest rivalries in Spanish football

Spain is regarded as one of the biggest football nations in the world, boasting iconic teams and a national side that has enjoyed success in major competitions. The Iberian nations are also home to one of the game’s greatest rivalries between two massive sporting institutions in the shape of Real Madrid and Barcelona. El Clasico

UCL talking points: Madrid, PSG or Italian football — who is worse off?

Sam Tighe Close Sam Tighe ESPN Sam is a writer, broadcaster and podcaster for ESPN. He will write on the Premier League, scouting and transfers. ,  Mark Ogden Close Mark Ogden Senior Writer, ESPN FC ,  Julien Laurens ,  Gab Marcotti Close Gab Marcotti Senior Writer, ESPN FC Multiple Authors Feb 25, 2026, 08:24 PM

Down to 16! Check out the possible Champions League last-16 clashes 🔥

Now there are 16 teams left in the fight for the Uefa Champions League 2025/2026. The last four qualifiers from the round of 16 playoffs were determined this Wednesday (25). A day that began with Atalanta advancing in epic fashion. And ended with more insanity. Advertisement The round of 16 matches will be determined next

Champions League: How Atalanta became the ‘darlings of Italian football’

Since the reintroduction of the last-16 knockout round to Europe’s showpiece competition in 2003-04, there has always been at least one Italian representative. Not since 1987-88, when Napoli went out in the first round of the European Cup to Real Madrid, has Serie A had no teams in the last 16 of the competition –

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x