The Last Look… – The Full FX

Welcome to 2025, and in the spirit of a happy new year, let’s start by giving someone a kicking! What is happening to fill rates in the FX market?

This has been raised to me by several traders in recent months, but is reinforced by public and private data from platforms – and what they are seeing is a decrease in fill rates, largely, I am told, via last look, but also because of an increasing number of quick price changes.

I understand that we have had a volatile few months, and this could, perhaps, be a reflection of that, but the conspiracy theorists amongst my contacts have another reason – new LPs to the market. There has been a fair bit of noise around a couple of major non-bank LPs entering the FX space in the last six-to-nine months, seeking to replicate their success in equity and futures markets in OTC FX, but I wonder if all they have done is slightly worsened the ecosystem? It’s either that or an existing major LP has recalibrated its systems and I have yet to hear any suggestion of that.

One factor that makes me think the cause is not volatility is the timing of small changes in the ecosystem. I was first alerted to this in May by a friend who shared with me details from a platform that does not publish reject or fill rates, but does, naturally, provide it to their clients. This indicated an increase in reject rates – from a trade volume perspective – of around 3% from the start of 2024.

This prompted me to look at the data from those platforms who do the right thing and publish these datapoints and while at first there didn’t seem much to it, as the year prgoressed a similar pattern emerged. As an example, the fill rate on Euronext FX’ skew safe streams started the year in the 82-84% range, but in June it dropped to 80.6%. It recovered in July (when things were quite lively in markets), before dropping to around 80% for the rest of the year (it was 81.4% in November).

The firm’s platform fill rate was largely around the 81-83% range until July 2024, when it fell sharply to 78.3%, and then again in August to 72.8%, before finishing the year in the 73-75.3% range. Even Euronext’s Full Amount streams saw a dip, from just under 95% to between 93 and 93.9%.

The situation is not as obvious at Cboe FX, but even here, there was a drop off, from over a year sitting in the 89-91% range, in August it dropped to 88%, went to 87% in the following two months, before ending the year at 88% and 89% for November and December respectively.

My friend tells me the situation on the other platform has not improved (nor has it worsened), therefore, we have at least three platforms with data indicating a fall in fill rates. Given this comes at a time when we have seen an increase in volatility and new LPs enter the market – are they linked? It is hard to see how they can’t be, and, again, given the timing, it is not clear it is linked to volatility. Liquidity consumers I have spoken to say that there have been periods during which it has been harder to access liquidity, but generally they have been short and the market has recovered quickly. This tells me the LPs have dealt with the situation well, but either someone has changed their style, or new LPs – about whom we have heard a lot regarding grabbing market share – are having an influence in certain areas.

One quant analyst I spoke with on the buy side suggested their models indicated the increased volatility should have led to a drop in fill rates of around 0.5-0.7%. I don’t know the maths behind it, (and probably couldn’t understand it if I did!) but it sounds reasonable, which means that on certain venues, the drop off has been steeper. The analyst said that fill rates on “more than three platforms” had worsened over the year, but that things were stable on disclosed or bilateral streams.

Any platform now basking in volume growth and higher reject rates might want to tread carefully

One swallow does not make a summer, but perhaps the rebound we saw in December is a good sign and things are “normalising”. It is to be hoped it does, because otherwise we clearly have parties raising the ante when it comes to the use of last look, and that ends up in one place – a poorer liquidity ecosystem. And if anyone is thinking that is OK, perhaps it is, these are, after all, different times, but for those who like their history, this could have echoes of 2007-2013 and EBS, which boomed as new market makers entered the business, bringing with them higher reject rates and information leakage.

The complaints about the trading environment on EBS around that time were very public and loud, leading to other venues getting the rest of their torso through the door after spending the best part of a decade with a foot holding it open. Equally, a number of attractive (to the LPs) liquidity consumers learned that top-of-book was not always equated with best execution.

EBS over the years dealt with the problem, but thanks to internalisation it, and its peers, are not going to get back to those days of $150-200 billion monthly ADV – the decline was inevitable, but was it given impetus by the decline in the trading environment? It is hard to answer that definitively, but I would suggest the balance of probabilities is that it was, which means any platform now basking in volume growth and higher reject rates might want to tread carefully.

We cannot predict the future, but what we can say is that competition in the FX platform world is unlikely to diminish, which means it is no time for a platform to risk its trading environment becoming even slightly toxic. Talking to people on the consumer side, they remain comfortable with their choice of venues, but are increasingly alert to signs of deterioration, which does at least highlight their growing understanding of the nuances of FX execution.

Spot volumes on the platforms are up across the board for 2024, which is good news, and I am comfortable that some platforms at least, will ensure that the trading environment remains a positive one. But while things are going strong, it would be wise not to take their eye off the bigger picture, and to ensure that any new LPs to the venue are actually improving the environment rather than polluting it.

colin@thefullfx.com

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

NZD/USD Analysis Today 02/04: Trading Range Prevails (Chart)

NZD/USD Analysis Today 02/04: Trading Range Prevails (Chart)

Created on April 02, 2025 The NZD/USD has come off of lows around the 0.56475 ratio this Monday, and as of this writing is near the 0.57400 level with fast trading being displayed in a known range. After testing lows early on Monday which had not been seen since the 4th of March, the NZD/USD

Forex Signals Brief April 2: Big Tariff Day Arrives, Markets Brace for Impact

btc-usd Skerdian Meta•Wednesday, April 2, 2025•3 min read Add an article to your Reading List Register now to be able to add articles to your reading list. ” aria-hidden=”true”> Share in Facebook “> Today the US will announce trade tariffs, but details will be most important, which could send markets both ways. Trade Tariffs Keeping

All Eyes on Trump Tariffs Today

Created on April 02, 2025 President Trump will today announce the imposition of new tariffs, with the details being keenly awaited by markets and likely to cause significant volatility. President Trump will announce new tariffs today, Wednesday 2nd April, with markets expecting a 25% tariff on all imports of automobiles, pharmaceuticals, and on almost all

Continues to See Buyers (Video)

Continues to See Buyers (Video)

Created on April 01, 2025 Well, another day, another massive gain for gold. At this point in time, we aren’t getting stretched and I am looking for pullbacks to occur. Those pullbacks for me are going to be buying opportunities as I do not wish to get too cute here and I don’t want to

GBP/USD Forecast Today 01/04: Stalls Below 1.30 (Video)

GBP/USD Forecast Today 01/04: Stalls Below 1.30 (Video)

Created on April 01, 2025 The British pound has gone back and forth during the trading session on Monday as we continue to see a lot of noisy behavior. The market is currently hanging around a range between the 1.30 level above and the 1.2880 level or so below. At this point, the market is

Avenix Fzco Introduces Avexbot: Data-Driven Precision for Forex Traders

LIMASSOL, CYPRUS, April 01, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Avenix Fzco announces the launch of Avexbot, an advanced algorithmic trading system leveraging high-quality tick data to enhance forex trading accuracy. ​In 2025, the trading world is buzzing about the importance of top-notch data, the quality of your data can make all the difference between success and

BoE’s Greene: Trade War likely disinflationary for UK

BoE Monetary Policy Committee member Megan Greene said today that a trade war involving retaliatory tariffs would likely be “disinflationary” for the UK overall. Though she cautioned against putting too much weight on early modelling at this stage. Greene pointed out that exchange rates would be a key transmission channel for the effects of global

USD/JPY technical price analysis

USD/JPY Price Analysis: Yen Rebounds as Tariff Fears Mount

The USD/JPY price analysis shows a rebound in the safe-haven yen. Data on Tuesday revealed poor business sentiment among Japanese manufacturers. The dollar drifted on Tuesday, ahead of the start of new tariffs. The USD/JPY price analysis shows a rebound in the safe-haven yen as traders increasingly worry about the looming Trump tariffs. However, trading

Institutional FX trading ends Q1 strong with March 2025 volumes up 9%

Institutional FX trading ends Q1 strong with March 2025 volumes up 9%

Heightened capital markets volatility in the wake of impending Trump tariffs led to a very good month in the institutional FX trading market in March 2025, with trading volumes well above monthly and seasonal norms. Average trading volumes at the leading eFX venues surveyed by FNG rose by an average of 8.7% in March 2025,

trading

Choosing the Right Timing for Profitable Trading

Timing in forex trading is a fundamental factor for every successful strategy. The decision about trading time in Nigeria’s markets between different time zones determines whether traders will achieve profits or experience losses. This guide will tell you about the best trading hours for maximum success. Global Structure of the Forex Market  The forex market

April forex seasonals

A ray of sunshine at a cloudy moment — TradingView News

At the start of March, I highlighted the seasonals for the month and one of them was yen weakness. Despite all the turmoil, USD/JPY rose about 200 pips in the month. Even AUD/JPY managed a gain in the month. Another one was oil, and though it started soft, it managed to gain on the month

COMMENT-China Policy Watch-PBOC signal is an amber light — TradingView News

Tariffs on “All Countries” — TradingView News

Key points: US dollar hugs the flatline Markets await Trump update Tariffs to include “all countries” Greenback was treading water Tuesday but can you blame it — there’s this big news coming tomorrow and the uncertainty is huge. 🔔 Tariff Update Draws Closer The US dollar index DXY was floating sideways early Tuesday with forex

DIGITEC hires Fenics / 360T alum Darryl Hooker to head BizDev and Partnerships

DIGITEC hires Fenics / 360T alum Darryl Hooker to head BizDev and Partnerships

Hamburg based FX Swaps tech and data provider DIGITEC has announced that Darryl Hooker had joined the company as Head of Business Development and Partnerships. Darryl Hooker has more than 40 years of experience working in the FX market, and an extensive knowledge of FX Swaps and NDFs. In his new role he has responsibility

BTC/USD Forex Signal Today 01/04: Bearish Sentiment (Chart)

BTC/USD Forex Signal Today 01/04: Bearish Sentiment (Chart)

Created on April 01, 2025 Bearish view Sell the BTC/USD pair and set a take-profit at 78,000. Add a stop-loss at 89,000. Timeline: 1-2 days. Bullish view Buy the BTC/USD pair and set a take-profit at 89,000. Add a stop-loss at 78,000. The BTC/USD pair remained under pressure as investors abandoned risky assets ahead of

Trade war turning FX traders bearish on the dollar

Trade war turning FX traders bearish on the dollar

Currency trader positioning is turning bearish on the dollar and becoming more bullish on the currencies of major U.S. trading partners as the United States prepares to launch a multinational trade war.  A new round of tariffs is set to take effect on Wednesday. Moreover, risks around efforts by Washington to devalue the dollar as

USD/MXN Analysis Today 31/03: Nervous Conditions (Chart)

USD/MXN Analysis Today 31/03: Nervous Conditions (Chart)

Created on March 31, 2025 The USD/MXN is about to encounter another week of loud trading conditions based on the ongoing tariff rhetoric coming from the U.S White House, short-term traders need to be ready for fast changing values. The USD/MXN after traversing below the 20.00000 momentarily last Tuesday began to see a solid reversal

USD/CAD technical outlook

USD/CAD Outlook: Loonie Takes a Nosedive Amid 25% Tariff

The USD/CAD outlook shows a sharp decline in the Canadian dollar to start a week.  On Wednesday, Canada might finally start feeling the pain of a high blanket tariff. Data in the previous session also showed hotter-than-expected underlying US inflation. The USD/CAD outlook shows a sharp decline in the Canadian dollar to start a week

Gold Analysis Today 31/03: Upcoming Upward Targets (Chart)

Gold Analysis Today 31/03: Upcoming Upward Targets (Chart)

Created on March 31, 2025 Gold Analysis Overview: Today’s Gold Trend: Upward. Today’s Gold Support Points: $3055 – $3020. Today’s Gold Resistance Points: $3100 – $3128. Gold Price Technical Analysis and Expectations Today: The spot gold price trend remains upward. According to gold analysts’ forecasts, prices will continue their upward trajectory as long as they

USD/JPY Analysis Today 31/03: Ascending Channel (Chart)

USD/JPY Analysis Today 31/03: Ascending Channel (Chart)

Created on March 31, 2025 For three consecutive weeks, the USD/JPY currency pair has been moving in an ascending channel formation, with gains reaching the 151.20 resistance level. This is the highest for the pair in nearly a month, before closing the week’s trading stable around the 149.80 level. The currency pair will remain subject

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x