The hidden crackdown on PIP as benefit assessments get tougher

Securing disability benefits is getting harder for new applicants as assessors take a tougher approach, The i Paper can reveal.

The proportion of successful new claims for personal independence payments, known as PIP, has been steadily declining since April 2024, analysis of official Government figures shows.

Experts and insiders told The i Paper the downward trend is due to “harsher” assessments and that decisions were increasingly going against applicants.

The UK’s budget watchdog has revised down forecasted spending on working-age disability benefits by £1bn for 2030-31, although the wider welfare bill will still grow overall.

Shorts

Less money than previously expected will be spent on PIP in particular, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) revealed in its October forecast.

This is because “a much lower proportion of these [PIP] claims are being awarded after assessment compared to previous years”, the OBR said.

Decline in successful PIP claims

Benefits advisers and experts claim assessors are also facing pressure from managers to review – and potentially reduce – the points awarded to PIP applicants, which determine their eligibility for the benefit. They also say disabled people are often being awarded fewer points if they are able to work.

This month, ministers will set out how the Government intends to overhaul PIP as it faces growing pressure to cut welfare spending. Stephen Timms – the disability minister leading the review – has said the benefit is “not fit for purpose”.

The proportion of successful claims for PIP has fallen, the latest figures from the Department from Work and Pensions (DWP) show.

The proportion of new PIP claims resulting in an award after an assessment has decreased from 48 per cent to 42 per cent when compared to last year.

Analysis by The i Paper shows a steady decline in success rate since April 2024, when 54 per cent of new PIP claims were granted.

“It’s definitely getting more difficult to make a successful claim,” said James Merrell, a former PIP assessor who worked for a company contracted to carry out assessments from 2023 to 2024.

“The assessment process seems to set people up to fail,” added Merrell, who now advises PIP claimants going through appeals at tribunal. “The emphasis is on finding why someone doesn’t merit points [for a PIP award].”

Around 4.1 million people currently receive PIP, worth up to around £800 a month to support both their daily living needs and mobility.

Assessors ask a series of questions about how well someone can function with tasks such as washing, dressing and preparing food, aimed at working out how much help they need.

Eight points are needed to qualify for the basic rate of PIP, while 12 points qualifies them for the higher rate.

LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM - 2025/03/26: Wheel-chaired protestors hold placards during a rally against the cuts to disabled benefits outside Downing Street. Hundreds of demonstrators, many disabled, gathered to protest against the government's proposed cuts to the welfare spending bill which will see Personal Independence Payments (PIP) reduced for disabled benefit claimants. (Photo by Lab Ky Mo/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Protests were held against benefit cut last year, with plans scrapped under Keir Starmer (Photo: Lab Ky Mo/SOPAImages/LightRocket via Getty Images)

Managers at firms contracted to carry out assessments are asking assessors to review their points recommendations more often, said Merrell. “The number of times it can be sent back to the assessor is becoming a problem,” he said.

“The pressure is to reduce [points]. You can see the back and forth [between manager and assessor] multiple times in a case. It’s happening more often – you can see it in tribunal cases.”

Assessors have also become less flexible when it comes to judging fluctuating conditions, such as multiple sclerosis (MS) or the chronic pain disorder fibromyalgia, Merrell added.

PIP system ‘getting harsher’

Dylan Thomas, a pastor who supports PIP claimants at appeal tribunals, said he had noticed an under-the-radar shift toward more difficult assessments. “The system appears to be getting harsher,” he said.

In some cases, having a job, even a part-time role, is resulting in a cut to existing awards for some claimants, he said.

“Assessors seems to be saying, ‘They’re working, therefore they can’t possibly be as ill as they say’,” Thomas said.

Michelle Cardno, founder and advocate at Fightback4Justice, a non-profit organisation providing advice on benefit claims and appeals, said: “We have seen a noticeable deterioration in PIP decision-making this year.

“We are also seeing more disabled people refused PIP where their employment appears to count against them,” said Cardno. “PIP is not an out-of-work benefit, and employment alone should never be grounds for refusal.”

Pressure to cut welfare bill

Although the OBR has downgraded its forecast for spending on disability benefits by £1bn compared to its March forecast, the overall bill is still expected to increase.

Spending on disability benefits – including PIP, disability living allowance and attendance allowance – is set to rise from £50.2bn in 2026-27 to £65.9bn by 2030-31.

Disability minister Sir Stephen Timms (left) is leading the PIP review, with reforms set to be overseen by Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden (Photos: PA)

Despite the fall in the proportion of successful PIP claims, the overall number seeking the disability benefit is still on the rise. The number of registered PIP claims increased 17 per in the past year, DWP figures show.

Thomas puts this increase down to the damaging health impact of Covid and improved diagnosis of mental health conditions. Some people may also be making claims for the first time because they are aware of the possibility that ministers could restrict eligibility after the Timms Review, he said..

“I think some people who are struggling [with health problems] but have been reluctant to go through an assessment are thinking that if they can’t get it now they never will,” said Thomas.

Timms, the disability minister, has acknowledged that PIP assessments can be “demeaning” and have not “kept pace with changing understanding of health and disability”.

Planned reforms could “enable PIP to do a better job” to support more people into work, he has also said. But is not yet clear how the Government might tie PIP to job searches or training for the first time.

His review is also looking at whether the system can direct people towards help “in addition to or, in some cases, perhaps instead of a cash payment”.

Andy Burnham has said Labour would cut the welfare bill “as soon as we possibly can” but he does not want “crude cuts”. Instead, he plans to reduce spending over time through better employment support.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies previously told The i Paper that a boost to work support will not make any benefit savings for up to 10 years and would be expensive in the short term. 

A DWP spokesperson said the interim Timms Review had made clear that PIP “is no longer fit for purpose” and the final report “will lay the foundation for sustainable reform”. They added: “We have also more than doubled face-to-face assessments for PIP and have extended the PIP award review period while removing unnecessary pressure on disabled people.”



Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Leading Hong Kong Travel Agency EGL Tours Launches New Youth

Hii-Fly is a brand new travel brand under EGL Tours, designed specially for young travelers to explore with like-minded peers at a relaxed pace. Season 1’s inaugural trip heads to Sri Lanka, featuring a Yala National Park Safari, the UNESCO World Heritage Sigiriya Lion Rock, the tea country railway via the Nine Arch Bridge, the

US, UK, Australia and Canada tighten travel warnings on South Africa

Four of South Africa’s biggest long-haul tourism markets, the United States, United Kingdom, Australia and Canada, have all reiterated elevated travel advisories for the country in recent months, highlighting concerns over violent crime, sporadic unrest and targeted attacks on tourists even as visitor numbers continue to recover. Get the latest news straight to your inbox!

Tourism Ireland leads major drive for 2027 at world’s largest travel fair

Tourism Marketing Tourism Ireland leads major drive for 2027 at world’s largest travel fair Around 3,600 meetings at World Travel Market in London set to deliver overseas tourism business worth millions of euro &nbspTues 3rd November 2026 Pictured: Biddy Hughes, Westport Estate; Julie Wakley, Tourism Ireland; and Karina Dunne, EPIC The Irish Emigration Museum, at

Andy Burnham to agree new cheaper travel and pets rules with EU

It will end the need for expensive certificates Neil Shaw Assistant Editor 06:17, 04 Nov 2026 It will be the first new deal of its kind since Brexit Pet owners are likely to get easier access to the European Union for their animals for the first time since Brexit under a deal Prime Minister Andy

Matamoros, Mexico, shelter-in-place order lifted but warning for Americans remains

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! U.S. officials have lifted a shelter-in-place order for government employees in a Mexican border city, but Americans are still being urged not to travel to the area. The order applied to U.S. government employees in Matamoros, a Mexican city across the border from Brownsville, Texas. The U.S.

Americans Urged To Avoid Mexico’s Tamaulipas Despite Eased Shelter Orders

American travelers are being urged to steer clear of Mexico’s border state of Tamaulipas, which remains under the highest United States “Do Not Travel” warning, even as recent shelter-in-place alerts in other parts of the country have been lifted following a wave of cartel-related unrest. Get the latest news straight to your inbox! Level 4

Americans Urged To Skip Tamaulipas Despite Eased Orders

U.S. travelers are being warned that Mexico’s border state of Tamaulipas remains one of the riskiest places for Americans to visit, even as recent shelter-in-place instructions for U.S. government personnel in the city of Matamoros were lifted following several days of security operations and road blockages. Get the latest news straight to your inbox! Shelter

Measles Outbreaks Prompt Health Advisory for International Travelers from Hong Kong

DH reminds public to take appropriate preventive measures against measles amid outbreaks in multiple countries due to low vaccination rates Due to ongoing measles outbreaks in multiple countries around the world caused by low vaccination rates, the Centre for Health Protection (CHP) of the Department of Health (DH) today (November 3) reminded members of the

Why UK and US Travel Warnings for Italy Remain in Place

Italy continues to welcome millions of visitors each year, yet the United Kingdom and United States both maintain cautious travel advisories for the country, reflecting an evolving mix of security concerns, political tensions and temporary border controls rather than a blanket warning against tourism. Get the latest news straight to your inbox! What the Current

Hong Kong teenager jailed for eight years over acid attack on Singaporean tourist

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in A Hong Kong teenager has been sentenced to eight years in prison for throwing sulphuric acid over a Singaporean tourist in a premeditated attack that left her with second-degree burns

Regent Hong Kong Marks a Landmark Year of Global Recognition in 2026 

A series of international honours places the Victoria Harbour hotel among the most recognised luxury hotels in Hong Kong. SINGAPORE – Media OutReach Newswire – 3 November 2026 – Regent Hong Kong continues a strong year of international recognition, with honours across major travel, hospitality and reader-voted awards in 2026. The latest distinctions add to

Regent Hong Kong Marks a Landmark Year of Global Recognition in 2026

A series of international honours places the Victoria Harbour hotel among the most recognised luxury hotels in Hong Kong. SINGAPORE – Media OutReach Newswire – 3 November 2026 – Regent Hong Kong continues a strong year of international recognition, with honours across major travel, hospitality and reader-voted awards in 2026. The latest distinctions add to

Why Liverpool’s Leafy Georgian Quarter is One of the Coolest Neighbourhoods in the UK Right Now

A place doesn’t have to be contemporary and cutting-edge to be cool. Case in point: the Georgian Quarter in Liverpool. The 200-year-old locale has two cathedrals (the sci-fi-esque Metropolitan Cathedral and the gigantic Liverpool Anglican Cathedral), streets lined with classic 19th century townhouses, and an art deco Philharmonic Hall. But it also has an exciting creative edge, and is one of Time

Opportunities and challenges for decarbonised, adaptable and resilient transport systems in the United Kingdom

The findings from the review are discussed across four core themes, namely (i) building resilience to deal with an uncertain future, (ii) achieving decarbonisation, (iii) digitalisation and technology, and (iv) integrating updated climate science. While these themes are common across the transport sector, their treatment varies considerably across governance levels. National strategies tend to emphasise

Harry Potter set-jetting by train: Five magical rail journeys in the UK

It’s almost impossible to believe, but 25 years ago in November, the first Harry Potter film, “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone”, was released. Alongside all the magic and mayhem, there was another icon on the screen: The Hogwarts Express train, portrayed in the film by the GWR 4900 Class No. 5972 Olton Hall steam

Starmer says UK must get closer to Europe as US relationship changes | Keir Starmer

The UK and other European nations must draw closer together as the US becomes a less-reliable partner, Keir Starmer has said in his first significant political intervention since leaving No 10. The former prime minister warned European leaders of the threat posed by Russia, among others, and said the shift in relations with Washington during

Why There Is No Place Quite Like Hong Kong – Brian Wong

Hong Kong once thrived as a gateway between a largely closed-off China and the outside world, but its traditional role as an intermediary has diminished as the mainland opens up. The city can continue to play an important international role by fostering candid, two-way dialogue between China and the world, advancing cooperation on governance challenges

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x