South African education reform threatens GNU

AFP South African President Cyril Ramaphosa (L) smiles as South African Minister of Agriculture John SteenhuisenAFP

President Cyril Ramaphosa (L) and John Steenhuisen (R) agreed to form a coalition government after the ANC lost its majority in May’s election

The durability of South Africa’s uneasy governing coalition is set to be tested as President Cyril Ramaphosa signs new education measures into law at a public ceremony on Friday.

Before May’s general election, the result of which forced Mr Ramaphosa’s African National Congress into a coalition, the two main partners in the current government were at loggerheads over the Basic Education Laws Amendment (Bela) Bill.

Even though the ANC and the Democratic Alliance (DA) now share power, there is still no agreement over the changes.

DA leader John Steenhuisen said that if the signing goes ahead, the party will “have to consider all of our options on the way forward”.

What is in the Bela bill?

The disputed bill passed by the previous ANC-dominated parliament just before the election proposes controversial and significant amendments to existing education law.

The major reforms include:

  • School admissions and the language of instruction will be regulated nationally
  • Home schooling will be regulated
  • Parents who fail to ensure their child is in school may face jail
  • Grade R, for four and five-year-olds, will be the new compulsory school starting level – a year earlier than currently
  • The abolition of corporal punishment will be backed by fines and possibly jail time for those who administer it

The ANC says the changes are necessary in order to transform the education system and address continued inequalities.

Why is there such fierce opposition?

The clause which has caused the most controversy is the one concerning strengthening government oversight over language and admission policies.

This is a sensitive topic relating to racial integration.

The previous ANC government argued that language and other admission criteria were being used to “derail access to schools [for] the majority of learners”.

Even though apartheid – a system of legally enforced racism – ended more than three decades ago, the racial divide it created still persists in some areas of education.

Afrikaans is not specifically mentioned in the legislation, but the ANC says that some children are being excluded from schools where the language of the white-minority Afrikaners is used as the medium of instruction.

The DA has defended the right of school governing bodies to determine their language policies, citing the constitution and the importance and protection of learning in one’s mother-tongue.

The strongest opposition has come from the Afrikaans-speaking community.

Civil rights group AfriForum has described the bill as an attack against Afrikaans education and has said it remains committed to opposing the legislation as “it poses a threat to the continued existence of Afrikaans schools and quality education”.

The Freedom Front Plus – another one of the 10 parties in the coalition government and seen as representing the interests of Afrikaners – is also opposed to Bela. It called it “ill-conceived”, saying it would “cause needless uncertainty and disputes about clearly established rights and responsibilities related to Basic Education”.

Some are also concerned about the reforms to home schooling. There are currently many unregulated schools popular with the middle classes because of the poor state of government schools.

These are allowed to continue through a loophole in the current law where the students are registered as “home learners” and the teachers offer “tuition”. But through the Bela bill, the government wants to close the loophole and ensure they are regulated like state schools.

Could this threaten the coalition government?

After the ANC lost its outright majority in parliament, it needed coalition partners to remain in power.

It reached a deal with its long-time opponent, the DA, and several other parties to form the Government of National Unity.

Steenhuisen, who is the agriculture minister, has said that enacting the Bela bill would violate “the letter and spirit” of the coalition agreement as the DA had made it clear that the bill was unacceptable “in its current form”.

But he does not yet appear to be pulling the plug on the coalition.

On Thursday, the DA leader said conflict over policy was not necessarily “an existential threat to the government”, echoeing similar comments from the president’s spokesperson.

But Steenhuisen said this did not mean it would never walk away, especially if the ANC was “trashing the constitution”. The DA has said it has some simple amendments to the bill which would make it acceptable and, as it sees it, bring it in line with the constitution. However, these have not been incorporated in the bill signed by President Ramaphosa.

More South Africa stories from the BBC:

Getty Images/BBC A woman looking at her mobile phone and the graphic BBC News AfricaGetty Images/BBC

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

SpaceX Crew Dragon Endeavour, seen Wednesday as it undocked from the International Space Station at 5:05 p.m. EDT. The spacecraft carries four Crew-8 astronauts as it begins its 34-hour journey back to Earth. It is scheduled to splashdown off the coast of Florida early Friday morning. Photo courtesy of NASA

SpaceX Crew-8 astronauts undock from ISS, begin journey home to Earth

1 of 2 | SpaceX Crew Dragon Endeavour, seen Wednesday as it undocked from the International Space Station at 5:05 p.m. EDT. The spacecraft carries four Crew-8 astronauts as it begins its 34-hour journey back to Earth. It is scheduled to splashdown off the coast of Florida early Friday morning. Photo courtesy of NASA Oct.

Musk with giant check

Elon Musk PAC warned by DOJ that $1 million sweepstakes may be illegal

The Department of Justice (DOJ) recently contacted Elon Musk’s America PAC about its historic $1 million giveaway to swing-state voters after the agency was warned by lawyers who claimed that the initiative may be illegal. On Monday, the DOJ was sent a letter from a “group of attorneys and public officials” requesting an investigation into

North Korea troops in Ukraine would escalate conflict, Lukashenko tells BBC

North Korea troops in Ukraine would escalate conflict, Lukashenko tells BBC

Alexander Lukashenko says North Korea troops in Ukraine would escalate conflict There aren’t many world leaders who’ve been in power for 30 years. Alexander Lukashenko of Belarus has been accused of stealing elections, crushing dissent and dismantling democracy. The UK, the EU and the US do not recognise him as the legitimate president of Belarus.

Headshot of Darren Orf

Scientists Say They Know How the Universe Will End

How the universe will end is an ongoing debate among cosmologists, and outcomes vary depending on specific theories. A new paper analyzes the end of the universe in relation to a theory known as “holographic dark matter,” in which gravity and space form a quantum illusion of our true, 2D reality. The study finds that,

Tyre

Israeli strikes pound Lebanese southern coastal city of Tyre | Hezbollah News

Israeli warplanes have attacked multiple buildings in Lebanon’s southern coastal city of Tyre, sending up large clouds of black smoke, as the Lebanese armed group Hezbollah confirmed that a top official widely expected to be the group’s next leader had been killed in an Israeli strike. There were no reports of casualties in Tyre, where

Ivanishvili holds mass rally before crucial vote

Ivanishvili holds mass rally before crucial vote

GIORGI ARJEVANIDZE/AFP Georgian Dream’s founder Bidzina Ivanishvili is under pressure from four opposition groups Three days before Georgians vote in an election billed as a decisive moment in their country’s future, the founder of the governing Georgian Dream party has told thousands of supporters “we choose peace, not war”. After 12 years in government, Bidzina

Texas Cop Fired After Road Rage Shooting

Texas Cop Fired After Road Rage Shooting

Read the full story on The Auto Wire Texas Cop Fired After Road Rage Shooting A Fort Worth, Texas police officer has been fired after he shot another driver in a road rage incident. William Martin wasn’t on the clock, in uniform, or in a police department vehicle when the fight unfolded, but he reportedly

Why Trump should avoid talking about intelligence leaks and Israel

Why Trump should avoid talking about intelligence leaks and Israel

Some classified U.S. intelligence documents related to Israel and a potential strike on Iran appeared online in recent days, and while officials in Israel have said the disclosure isn’t likely to have a meaningful practical impact, it’s nevertheless a problem when information like this is divulged. The FBI, not surprisingly, has launched an investigation. At

At least four dead in terror attack at Turkish aviation company

At least four dead in terror attack at Turkish aviation company

Getty Images Smoke rises as rescuers arrive at the scene At least four people have been killed and 14 injured in an attack at the headquarters of an aviation company near the Turkish capital Ankara, authorities have confirmed. Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya posted on X that two attackers were “neutralised” in the incident, which saw

Dividend Investor Earns $300K Per Year On $4.4M Investment: Their Top 10 Picks

Dividend Investor Earns $300K Per Year On $4.4M Investment: Their Top 10 Picks

Dividend Investor Earns $300K Per Year On $4.4M Investment: Their Top 10 Picks Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below. Dividend-paying stocks offer a versatile approach to enhancing income and growth potential, regardless of your life stage. For those years away from retirement, reinvesting dividends

Russia hosts meeting of world leaders aimed at challenging the West

Russia hosts meeting of world leaders aimed at challenging the West

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Now Playing Russia hosts meeting of world leaders aimed at challenging the West 04:55 UP NEXT Paul Whelan speaks out after more than five years in Russian prison 02:29 Ukraine’s Zelenskyy references North Korea’s ‘effective involvement’ in war with Russia

New £13m-a-year support package announced

New £13m-a-year support package announced

BBC Four mothers who spoke to BBC Spotlight said they were struggling to get the support they need to care for their sons Health Minister Mike Nesbitt has pledged £13m a year to boost support for families of children with complex needs. The announcement follows a BBC Spotlight programme highlighting the plight of families of

Breaking News

Who is Hashem Safieddine, Hezbollah heir to Nasrallah Israel claims to have killed?

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Israel claims to have killed Hashem Safieddine, heir apparent to slain Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, in an early October airstrike on southern Beirut. The Israeli military said on

Prajvi Mathur

Seattle teen detained after allegedly killing parents, siblings

Disclaimer: Some readers may find the story disturbing. Discretion is advised. A 15-year-old boy has been detained after allegedly killing five members of a family and injuring another at a Fall City home in Washington, authorities said on Tuesday, October 22. Police found two adults and three children dead at the lakeside house 25 miles

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x