Opinion | Seat belt U-turn in Hong Kong another case of ill-fitting policy

People generally don’t like change. But if you have ever had to take the worst seat on a bus – lower deck, last row, middle seat – then you would have probably put on the seat belt to avoid being catapulted down the aisle should the driver slam on the brakes. And if you’re on the upper deck and the only available seats are in the front row, then again, you would buckle up, to avoid going through the window in an accident.

A responsible person would wear a seat belt when sitting anywhere in the vehicle, right? Seat belts save lives, simple.

Except it’s not that simple. As ridiculous as the public backlash was against new rules requiring passengers on public and private buses to wear a seat belt where available – rules that only came into effect last week but are already being suspended – some of the whining isn’t unreasonable.
For one, people took issue with the improper fit of the seat belt on buses – too tight, too loose, the diagonal strap not lying as the Transport Department says it should: “midway across your shoulder, staying in contact with your chest up to about your collar bone”. Parents also voiced concerns over risks to child safety posed by the diagonal straps.

For parents with babies in a carrier, it gets “complicated”, as Lai Siu-chung, director of the KMB branch of the Motor Transport Workers General Union, put it. Parents would need to remove the baby carrier, fasten the seat belt, then hold their baby firmly in their arms – and reverse that process when alighting.

But Lai’s observation that “the reality is quite messy” applies to other commuters too. Yes, the reality is complicated and can get messy. That’s why the government should have done a better job of preparing for it.

01:42

Hong Kong to suspend bus seat belt rules over ‘deficiencies’ in law

Hong Kong to suspend bus seat belt rules over ‘deficiencies’ in law

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hong Kong to formulate first 5-year plan to align with national blueprint

Hong Kong to formulate first 5-year plan to align with national blueprint

A new task force led by Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu will formulate Hong Kong’s first five-year blueprint to align with China’s 15th five-year plan, with a political analyst saying the move signals greater government involvement in shaping the city’s development. Lee also said on Monday that he would prioritise visits to Eastern Europe and

Small Hong Kong firms struggling with scaffold net safety costs: contractor

Small Hong Kong firms struggling with scaffold net safety costs: contractor

Hong Kong’s construction watchdog should help small firms procure approved scaffolding nets at a lower cost, a leading contractor has said after inspectors found two sites using plastic meshes that failed security tests. Lawrence Ng San-wa, permanent honorary president of the Hong Kong Construction Sub‑contractors Association, said on Monday that the industry was concerned about

Man arrested after 20 cats, hamster found dead in Hong Kong flat

Man arrested after 20 cats, hamster found dead in Hong Kong flat

Hong Kong police have arrested a man after discovering the bodies of 20 cats and a hamster, as well as other animals in poor condition, in his flat. The force said it received a report at about 7pm on Sunday from a resident of Chau Tau Tsuen in Lok Ma Chau complaining of an odd

International placement for HK young legal talents

International placement for HK young legal talents

發佈日期: 2026-02-02 11:34 TVB News 已複製連結 The Office of the Commissioner of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in the HKSAR held a briefing session to promote opportunities for Hong Kong’s young legal talent to be seconded to work in international legal organizations. Around 100 participants attended the briefing, including representatives from international legal organizations based

Lunch at Duddells

Architect André Fu’s insider guide to Hong Kong

Lunch at Duddell’s Duddell’s Dim sum at Duddell’s “I recently helped to renovate Duddell’s in Central, a one-Michelin-starred restaurant with a really fun dim-sum brunch. We took cues from Lingnan architecture for the design, reflecting Hong Kong as a place where different cultures are juxtaposed together. It’s part of an art and culture that is

BYD's new generation ATTO3 has been launched in Hong Kong with an indicative price of 188,000 Hong Kong dollars.

BYD’s new generation ATTO3 has been launched in Hong Kong with an indicative price of 188,000 Hong Kong dollars.

BYD (01211.HK) announced that the 2026 model of its next-generation “ATTO 3” has officially launched in Hong Kong. Under the “One-for-One Replacement” scheme, the indicative price is set at HKD 188,000. While retaining the original platform, the new model enhances user experience through detailed upgrades. This facelift marks the third generation of the “ATTO 3,”

Hong Kong steps up oversight of retail payments

Hong Kong steps up oversight of retail payments

The framework seeks to keep digital payments stable and efficient while holding major payment systems to consistent standards. / Credit: Sorbis via Shutterstock The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) has outlined details of its updated regulatory regime for retail payment systems, reinforcing oversight of payment networks, clearing and settlement processes used by individuals and businesses.

Ex-Hong Kong chief secretary Rafael Hui, jailed for graft, dies at 77

Ex-Hong Kong chief secretary Rafael Hui, jailed for graft, dies at 77

Rafael Hui Si-yan, a former Hong Kong chief secretary who was jailed for pocketing nearly HK$20 million from a prominent land developer, has died at the age of 77. “Mr Rafael Hui passed away at [Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital] peacefully on Sunday after a brave fight with an acute illness,” a source told the

CK Hutchison faces limited legal options after Panama voids port rights: experts

CK Hutchison faces limited legal options after Panama voids port rights: experts

Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison Holdings faces limited legal avenues to challenge a Panama court ruling that nullified its rights to operate two major ports at the country’s canal, while taking the case to the International Court of Justice will require Beijing to act on its behalf, a legal expert has said. Basil Hwang, managing partner

A dozen companies listed in the city in January, raising US$4.2 billion, up 447 per cent from a year earlier, Photo: Jelly Tse

Hong Kong back in global IPO spotlight after strongest January in years

Nearly 100 companies filed new listing applications in Hong Kong in January, marking a strong start to 2026 for initial public offering (IPO) activity. A total of 95 companies applied to list on Hong Kong’s main board, while one sought a place on the Growth Enterprise Market, which primarily served smaller and growth-stage firms, according

Adidas concerned after woman complains fitting room opened twice at Mong Kok shop

Adidas concerned after woman complains fitting room opened twice at Mong Kok shop

Adidas has expressed concern over a woman’s complaint about a staff member and other customers opening the curtain of a fitting room at a Hong Kong branch on two occasions while she was inside, saying it would review its facilities and store operations. The German sportswear giant issued a response on Sunday, four days after

Soaring Hong Kong rents: tenants pay more – and fight for shrinking space

Soaring Hong Kong rents: tenants pay more – and fight for shrinking space

For business owner Tracy Sung, flat-hunting in Hong Kong was complicated by two things – her pets and the intense competition in the rental market. Sung, who used to live in a 500 sq ft flat in Happy Valley, had to offer more than the landlord’s asking price to secure an 800 sq ft property

Hong Kong tourism chief targets more than 50 million visitors in 2026

Hong Kong tourism chief targets more than 50 million visitors in 2026

Hong Kong’s tourism chief has struck an upbeat note on tourist arrivals during Lunar New Year and expressed confidence that visitor numbers will cross the 50 million mark by the end of the year. Secretary for Culture, Sports and Tourism Rosanna Law Shuk-pui said she was optimistic about a year-on-year increase in tourist arrivals over

Hong Kong’s public expenditure growth cannot exceed revenue rise: Paul Chan

Hong Kong’s public expenditure growth cannot exceed revenue rise: Paul Chan

Hong Kong’s public expenditure growth should not exceed that of its revenue despite signs of improving finances, Paul Chan Mo-po has said, while noting that the market expects increased government investment to speed up economic development. But the financial secretary on Sunday also painted a rosy picture for the city’s retail sector, revealing that sales

Hong Kong road accident scam reports double to over 70 in a week: Chris Tang

Hong Kong road accident scam reports double to over 70 in a week: Chris Tang

The number of suspected scams involving unusually high and belated compensation claims for minor or non-existent traffic accidents in Hong Kong has doubled to more than 70 in less than a week, according to the security minister. Secretary for Security Chris Tang Ping-keung told a radio programme on Sunday that the increase was recorded after

‘Technical issue’ forces Hong Kong-bound Cathay flight to return to Kaohsiung

‘Technical issue’ forces Hong Kong-bound Cathay flight to return to Kaohsiung

A Hong Kong-bound Cathay Pacific flight had to return to Kaohsiung after take-off on Sunday morning due to a technical problem, with around 200 passengers affected. A spokesman for Cathay Pacific confirmed flight CX449 returned to the Taiwanese city shortly after departure due to an unspecified “technical issue”. “We sincerely apologise for the inconvenience caused

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x