No Fire Critics Allowed in Hong Kong

At least 151 died as flames engulfed high-rise towers at Hong Kong’s Wang Fuk Court housing complex last week. The official response shows how this once free city is becoming more like mainland China by the day.

People look on near the Wang Fuk Court housing complex following the deadly fire on Wednesday, in Tai Po, Hong Kong, China December 1, 2025. REUTERS/Amr Alfiky(REUTERS) PREMIUM
People look on near the Wang Fuk Court housing complex following the deadly fire on Wednesday, in Tai Po, Hong Kong, China December 1, 2025. REUTERS/Amr Alfiky(REUTERS)

Authorities are seeking to chill speech related to the fire. Several civil-society figures had planned to hold a news conference Tuesday to discuss the response to the blaze. But the event was cancelled after one participant, solicitor Bruce Liu, was “invited to a meeting” with national-security police, the local press reports. Mr. Liu, former chair of the pro-democracy Association for Democracy and People’s Livelihood, reportedly left the police station later Tuesday.

Police on Saturday also detained student Miles Kwan, who called for a probe into any conflicts of interest or regulatory neglect that contributed to the fire, among other demands in a petition to the government. Our sources say he’s since been released.

The Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation says national-security authorities arrested former pro-democracy district councillor Kenneth Cheung after he called for an independent probe. Another unnamed volunteer was reportedly arrested for using the fire to incite hatred of the government, which means merely criticizing the government.

Hong Kongers have legitimate questions about what went so lethally awry. Before the blaze, residents of Wang Fuk Court had repeatedly raised safety concerns, and authorities now say some of the protective mesh around the buildings failed to meet flame-retardant standards. Other reports describe flammable construction materials and faulty alarms.

A decade ago the scrappy reporters at the Apple Daily newspaper might have followed up on residents’ complaints and exposed wrongdoing before tragedy struck. But authorities arrested Apple Daily’s founder Jimmy Lai in 2020 on national-security charges and later forced the paper’s closure. Mr. Lai has been in prison on trumped-up charges ever since.

Authorities have also made at least 13 non-speech arrests in relation to the fire, including the bosses of a construction company that a police superintendent called “grossly negligent.” Perhaps they are liable in some way, but the rapid arrests have a round-up-the-usual-suspects quality. That’s how authoritarian regimes respond when they need a scapegoat for the public to blame.

There’s early evidence of government shortcomings. Hong Kong’s Labor Department had told Wang Fuk Court residents that the fire risks were “relatively low,” Reuters reports. Hong Kong’s Fire Services Department conducts inspections and can take enforcement actions regarding fire safety at construction sites. Where were they?

By the way, the fire department is a subordinate agency of Hong Kong’s Security Bureau, and the bureau’s Secretary is Chris Tang, who is also in charge of implementing the national-security law that outlaws dissent. On Saturday Beijing warned “anti-China and pro-chaos elements who attempt to ‘use disasters to disrupt Hong Kong’” would be “severely punished” under the same law. Hong Kongers have little recourse as authorities tolerate neither scrutiny nor criticism.

Get the latest headlines from US news and global updates from Pakistan, Nepal, UK, Bangladesh, and Russia get all the latest headlines in one place with including 3I/ATLAS Liveon Hindustan Times.

Get the latest headlines from US news and global updates from Pakistan, Nepal, UK, Bangladesh, and Russia get all the latest headlines in one place with including 3I/ATLAS Liveon Hindustan Times.

All Access.
One Subscription.

Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines
to 100 year archives.

E-Paper

Full Archives

Full Access to
HT App & Website

Games

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Cheeky Float from Quinary’s new menu Flavours. Photo: Handout

Your Hong Kong weekend drinks guide for December 5-7

It’s the end of the year, and this weekend’s offerings are a decade plus in the making. Hong Kong’s original house of molecular mixology, Quinary, launched its newest menu this week, inspired by local flavours and images. On Sunday, Hong Kong’s original speakeasy 001 celebrates 15 years in the scene as three of its original

Hong Kong Property Sales Value Fall 9% Year on Year

Delayed Hong Kong S.E. 12:20:24 2025-12-03 am EST 5-day change 1st Jan Change 25,844.83 PTS -0.96% -0.31% +28.85% Published on 12/02/2025 at 09:19 pm EST MT Newswires This article is reserved for members Unlock the article: REGISTER NOW! © MT Newswires – 2025 09:19pm Hong Kong Property Sales Value Fall 9% Year on Year MT

Hu poses with fellow swimmers Simon Holliday (left) and Brett Kruse while training for their swim around Lantau Island. Photo: Instagram/edieswimshongkong

First woman to swim around Hong Kong’s Lantau Island defies her age

“Youth is overrated” is a mantra empowering open water swimmer Edie Hu to break records at 50 years of age. On November 20, the Hong Kong art dealer set off from the Disneyland Resort Pier to circumnavigate Lantau – Hong Kong’s largest island – in a tandem swim with friends Simon Holliday, 46, the founder

Hong Kong man, 87, with dementia found dead 9 days after going missing

Hong Kong man, 87, with dementia found dead 9 days after going missing

An elderly Hong Kong man with dementia who had been missing for nine days was found dead in the countryside by volunteer search teams. Leung Woon-yew, 87, a resident of Tai Hing Estate in Tuen Mun, was discovered in a bushy area near the top of Por Lo Shan at 12.40pm on Tuesday by the

As I see it | Hong Kong will miss its most popular philosopher

As I see it | Hong Kong will miss its most popular philosopher

Once, when pop diva Faye Wong was seen reading on a plane, the book reportedly on her lap was the perennial local bestseller Art of Thinking by Lee Tien-ming. Food critic, columnist and media personality Benny Li Shun-Yan reportedly said that after learning of her interest, he introduced Wong to Lee, arguably Hong Kong’s most

Residents of block to return to fire-ravaged Hong Kong estate to collect personal items

Residents of block to return to fire-ravaged Hong Kong estate to collect personal items

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. Get faster notifications on the latest updates by downloading our app. What we know so far: 156 people, including a firefighter, confirmed dead 79 injured, including 12 firefighters Status of about 30 people unclear

Waris Mills completed the 45km loop around Hong Kong Island in record time. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong has everything be top destination for world’s open water swimmers, Hu says

In the past several weeks, two of Hong Kong’s long-standing open water swimming records have fallen, and organisers of these testing events believe it could be just the beginning. With challenging currents, swirling seas and dramatic backdrops, the city has always been a draw for the adventurous, and one swimmer thinks it could soon become

From chips to noodles: the newcomers testing Hong Kong’s buoyant IPO market

From chips to noodles: the newcomers testing Hong Kong’s buoyant IPO market

Hong Kong’s booming fundraising market is set for another busy week, with four companies scheduled to debut this week and a string of billion-dollar listings – including Chinese luxury electric vehicle maker Avatr Technology – lining up behind them. Among this week’s newcomers, chip materials supplier Guangdong Tianyu Semiconductor plans to raise the highest sum,

警務處傷亡查詢中心主管曾淑賢(徐君浩攝)

大埔宏福苑五級火|增至156人死亡 29具遺體有待辨認 宏志閣居民明後兩日可返寓所取回財物 (17:07) – 20251202 – 港聞 – 即時新聞

新界北總區指揮官林敏嫻表示,警方今日完成宏昌閣40%單位及宏新閣90%單位的搜索,搜索行動於下午一時由於家屬拜祭而暫停,警方不欲死者家屬於儀式期間目睹遺體移送而觸景傷情。至於餘下約30宗失聯個案,警方傷亡查詢中心總警司曾淑賢指,遺體辨認程序包括辨認遺體相片,以及安排家屬到殮房認屍,若失蹤者家屬仍未能認出親人,將會再安排法證程序,例如DNA驗證或齒科驗證。 警務處傷亡查詢中心主管曾淑賢 至於未受火災波及的宏志閣,政府亦將容許宏志閣居民返回單位取回個人物品,有關安排屬一次性質,居民可於明日(12月3日)及後日(12月4日)返回寓所,政府將派員協助,包括搬運。 東區民政事務專員黎旨軒表示,宏志閣居民明日及後日早上9時至晚上9時任何時段帶同身分證明文件到廣福邨廣義樓旁的報到,每戶可以在上述時段回家一次,限兩人同時上樓,最多逗留一個半小時,由於現場仍需封鎖,警方要求居民取回重要的個人物品後必須離開,民政事務總署及公務員應急隊會派出公務員支援,確保每一戶上樓時都有公務員陪同,警務人員會駐守每一層樓維持秩序,如果住戶有需要及需搬運行李等,社會福利署的社工亦會在現場支援居民。 東區民政事務專員黎旨軒 民政及青年事務局、民政事務總署、房屋局和運輸署將有特別交通服務安排,包括免費交通服務如旅遊巴,接載居民由政府安排的青年旅舍、酒店或過渡性房屋來往現場,另亦安排車隊的士及客貨車在現場提供義載服務。黎呼籲,由於有兩天、每日12小時時間返回宏志閣,居民不需要急於在明天一早到場。  Source link

Residents of tower spared in Hong Kong blaze get 90 minutes to fetch belongings

Residents of tower spared in Hong Kong blaze get 90 minutes to fetch belongings

Residents of the only tower left untouched by the deadly blaze that destroyed seven others at Wang Fuk Court in Hong Kong’s Tai Po neighbourhood will be given 90 minutes on Wednesday and Thursday to collect their belongings. Civil servants will be on hand to help move their possessions, authorities have said. Amy Lam Man-han,

Hong Kong fire will not deter Filipino helpers from working in city: minister

Hong Kong fire will not deter Filipino helpers from working in city: minister

A deadly Hong Kong blaze that claimed the lives of several domestic helpers will not deter Filipinos from working in the city, the Philippines’ migrant workers minister has said, adding that the city has always been a “safe haven”. Speaking to the Post during a visit to Hong Kong on Tuesday, Hans Leo Cacdac, secretary

Hongkongers pray for the fire victims. Photo: Sam Tsang

Judge-led panel to probe deadly blaze as Hong Kong goes ahead with election

Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu has ordered the setting up of a judge-led independent review committee on the blaze that engulfed a Tai Po residential estate while formally announcing that the Legislative Council election will go ahead on Sunday as scheduled. The death toll from the inferno that swept through seven of the

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x