Israel’s muted response to Pope Francis’s death signals tensions over Gaza

Sebastian Usher

Correspondent

Getty Images Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, wearing a black suit, and Pope Francis, wearing his white papal garments, shake hands as they meet in Jerusalem in 2014Getty Images

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met Pope Francis in 2014 in Jerusalem

The office of the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has offered its condolences for Pope Francis, four days after his death.

An earlier offer of condolences posted on social media by the official state account of Israel had previously been deleted, causing considerable controversy within the country.

Israel is also sending a relatively low-level delegation to the late pontiff’s funeral on Saturday, with only the country’s Vatican ambassador in attendance.

All of this has been seen in Israel and elsewhere as a sign of the Israeli government’s displeasure with Pope Francis’s impassioned remarks on the war in Gaza.

Belatedly and somewhat impersonally, the Israeli prime minister’s office issued a two sentence offer of condolences on Thursday night.

It read: “The State of Israel expresses its deepest condolences to the Catholic Church and the Catholic community worldwide at the passing of Pope Francis. May he rest in peace.”

The tone of the original message tweeted by the verified @Israel account on X on the day of the Pope’s death was noticeably warmer.

It featured a photo of Pope Francis at the Western Wall in Jerusalem and concluded: “May his memory be a blessing.”

But it was swiftly withdrawn, without explanation.

Reuters Pope Francis stands with his hand outstretched to touch the Western Wall on May 26, 2014 in Jerusalem as he praysReuters

Pope Francis prayed at the Western Wall in Jerusalem in 2014

Several Israeli media outlets reported on it being deleted, with the Jerusalem Post quoting officials at the foreign ministry saying that it had been posted in “error”.

The Jerusalem Post also quoted Israel’s former ambassador to the Vatican, Raphael Schutz, describing the decision to delete the published statement as a mistake.

In the face of such criticism, Israeli officials did point out that the country’s current ambassador to the Vatican had offered his condolences in person.

And it is the ambassador, Yaron Sideman, who will represent Israel at the funeral of Pope Francis.

This is in marked contrast to the heads of state or government who will be attending from most major nations, including US President Donald Trump.

It is also very different from the funeral of the last pope to die while still in office – that of John Paul II in 2005. Israel sent the then-president, Moshe Katsav, and the then-foreign minister, Silvan Shalom, to attend the ceremony.

The current Israeli President, Isaac Herzog, did publish an eloquent and heartfelt tribute to Pope Francis in the hours after his death, describing him as a man of deep faith and boundless compassion.

But there appear to be no plans for him to attend the funeral. No reason has been given, although it may have something to do with the funeral taking place on Shabbat, the Jewish Sabbath.

But it seems clear that the Israeli government’s resentment of Pope Francis’s expressions of solidarity with the Palestinians, especially during the war in Gaza, has soured its response to his death.

Reuters Pope Francis prays at Israel's West Bank barrier during a visit to Bethlehem, in the occupied West Bank (25 May 2014)Reuters

Pope Francis also prayed at Israel’s controversial West Bank barrier during a visit to Bethlehem

Last November, Pope Francis suggested that the international community should examine whether Israel’s military offensive in Gaza should be classed as genocide – an allegation Israel has vehemently denied.

Earlier this year, he called the humanitarian situation in Gaza “shameful”.

In his very last public address on Easter Sunday – the day before his death – there was mention of Gaza once again. His address spoke of the suffering of both the Palestinians and the Israelis.

Since his death, more details have emerged of how Pope Francis would be in contact almost daily with the small Christian community sheltering in a church in Gaza City during the war.

Palestinians have spoken warmly of how much his expressions of empathy had given them hope.

As a sign of how highly they respected the Pope, the Palestinian Authority is sending Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa to the funeral.

All this has meant that some in Israel, especially among the coalition of religious and nationalist parties that buoy up Netanyahu’s coalition, believe that Pope Francis had taken the side of the Palestinians, despite his expressions of sympathy for Israelis and his efforts at bolstering multi-faith dialogue.

That sense of a rift between the current Israeli government and the Vatican may well be visible at the Pope’s funeral in Rome, where Israel’s leaders will be noticeable by their absence.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Trump did not say when the call with the Chinese leader took place or specify what was discussed.(Reuters/File Image)

China denies trade talks with US despite Donald Trump’s claim | World News

Apr 26, 2025 01:56 PM IST The world’s two biggest economies are locked in an escalating tit-for-tat trade battle triggered by Trump’s levies on Chinese goods. China repeated Saturday that it had held no talks with the United States on trade issues, despite President Donald Trump’s claim that he had taken a call from Xi

Pope’s coffin sealed ahead of funeral on Saturday morning

Pope Francis’ life recalled in Deed placed in coffin

The Deed for the Pious Passing of His Holiness Pope Francis has been placed in his coffin, which was sealed in a solemn rite ahead of his Requiem Mass. By Vatican News The coffin of the late Pope Francis was sealed in a ritual in St. Peter’s Basilica on Friday evening, after around 250,000 pilgrims

A view of the Santa Maria Maggiore (St. Mary Major) Basilica in Rome

Watch Live: Pope Francis’ funeral set to begin as Vatican lays late pontiff to rest

The funeral service for Pope Francis is taking place Saturday morning at the Vatican, after which the late leader of the Catholic Church will be buried in Rome. While the ceremony will follow many traditions developed over centuries of church history, there will also be some details uniquely chosen by Pope Francis. Watch the ceremony live

People pay their respects to Pope Francis on Friday during his lying in state in St. Peter's Basilica.

Crowds gather for Pope Francis’ funeral Mass at the Vatican

Vatican City CNN  —  Throngs of mourners are gathering in Vatican City and lining the streets of Rome on Saturday to give a final send-off to Pope Francis, who will be remembered as a champion of migrants and the poor, and for his efforts to reshape the Catholic Church. His funeral Mass is being held

How much has Elon Musk's Doge cut from US government spending?

How much has Elon Musk’s Doge cut from US government spending?

Lucy Gilder, Jake Horton and the Data Science team BBC Verify BBC Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (Doge) – set up to cut US government spending – claims to have saved, on average, more than $10bn a week since President Trump entered office. “We’re talking about almost $200bn and rising fast,” Trump told the

Diddy in a white tux

Diddy Suffers Major Setback As He Loses Bid To Keep Cassie Assault Video Out Of Court

Sean “Diddy” Combs‘ defense has suffered a massive setback as his trial draws near. A judge ruled that the assault video in which he’s seen beating up his ex-girlfriend, Cassandra “Cassie” Ventura, would be played in court for the jury to see. Sean “Diddy” Combs’ legal troubles were compounded when two new charges were leveled

The risk of asbestos in Gaza's rubble

The risk of asbestos in Gaza’s rubble

BBC Israel’s destructive military campaign in Gaza has released a silent killer: asbestos. The mineral, once widely-used in building materials, releases toxic fibres into the air when disturbed that can cling to the lungs and – over decades – cause cancer. Nowadays, its use is banned across much of the world, but it is still

A visual guide and timeline

A visual guide and timeline

Laura Gozzi and the Visual Journalism team BBC News BBC The funeral of Pope Francis will be simpler than those of previous popes, following instructions he set out himself. But as a head of state and leader of more than a billion Catholics worldwide, it will still be a spectacle of ceremony and tradition. His

Senior Russian general killed by car bomb in Moscow

Senior Russian general killed by car bomb in Moscow

INVESTIGATIVE COMMITTEE OF RUSSIA/HANDOUT/Getty Images A senior Russian general has been killed in a car bomb attack in Moscow, officials have confirmed. Russia’s Investigative Committee (SK) – the main federal investigating authority in the country – confirmed Gen Yaroslav Moskalik died when a Volkswagen Golf car exploded after an improvised explosive device stuffed with pellets

'My bananas were seized and destroyed'

‘My bananas were seized and destroyed’

Sammy Awami BBC News, Karonga BBC / Sammy Awami Jeniffa Mshani says small traders, mostly women, are being harassed at the border Traders are counting their losses as Tanzania clamps down on people trying to flout a ban on goods from neighbouring Malawi in an escalating regional trade row. On Friday, businesswomen told the BBC

Pope Francis's funeral presents chance for 'brush-by' diplomacy

Pope Francis’s funeral presents chance for ‘brush-by’ diplomacy

Reuters World leaders may be gathering on Saturday to pay their respects to a fellow statesman whose church has more members than their states have citizens. But they may also use the Pope’s funeral as a rare and unexpected opportunity to conduct a little impromptu diplomacy. For it will be one of the largest gatherings

Putin and Trump envoy Witkoff held constructive talks in Moscow, Russian aide says

Putin and Trump envoy Witkoff held constructive talks in Moscow, Russian aide says

AFP US envoy Steve Witkoff and Russian President Vladimir Putin had “constructive” talks in Moscow on Friday lasting three hours, according to an aide of Putin’s. Yuri Ushakov said the possibility of Russia and Ukraine resuming direct talks was a particular point of discussion. The US has not released details of what was discussed during

Stocks close higher, options playbook: Market Domination Overtime

DOJ pushes Google Chrome sale. Here’s who wants to buy

The US Department of Justice is pushing for Alphabet (GOOG, GOOGL) to sell Google Chrome as part of the remedy for its antitrust case. Yahoo Finance Senior Legal Reporter Alexis Keenan breaks down the latest as companies like OpenAI and Yahoo express interest in buying Alphabet’s browser business. To watch more expert insights and analysis

A hushed Rome reckons with Pope Francis's death

A hushed Rome reckons with Pope Francis’s death

AP The seat at the Vatican had been vacant for two days when a group of grey-clad nuns stood on St Peter’s Square and started to sing. Softly at first then louder, as if to encourage those who joined in timidly, the nuns broke into Ave Maria. Every so often they shuffled a few inches

WFP runs out of food aid after seven-week Israeli blockade

WFP runs out of food aid after seven-week Israeli blockade

Getty Images Palestinians have been relying on community kitchens, like this one in Jabalia, to provide around one million hot meals daily The UN World Food Programme says it has depleted all its food stocks in Gaza, where Israel has blocked deliveries of humanitarian aid for seven weeks. “Today, WFP delivered its last remaining food

The Pope's coffin is sealed

Pope’s coffin sealed ahead of funeral on Saturday morning

Pope Francis’ coffin is sealed in a private ceremony in St Peter’s Basilica, after some 250,000 mourners had paid their respects. By Anne Preckel On the eve of Pope Francis’ funeral Mass, his coffin has been solemnly sealed. The Pope had been lying in state in St Peter’s Basilica since Wednesday. After the huge crowds

A man walks in front of a damaged wall after the earthquake that struck the city of Esmeraldas, Ecuador on April 25, 2025. (AFP)

Earthquake of magnitude 6.3 strikes Ecuador, 20 injured | World News

Apr 25, 2025 11:56 PM IST Earthquake today: The quake struck at a depth of 23 km (14.29 miles), EMSC said, with Ecuadorean authorities ruling out issuing a tsunami warning. Earthquake today: A magnitude 6.3 earthquake struck near the coast of Ecuador on Friday, the European Mediterranean Seismological Centre (EMSC) said, injuring at least 20

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x