For the longest time, Windows users never really had a lot of choices when it came to their file manager. Sure, there have been a couple of niche file managers that programmers and power users have sworn by for a couple of decades now, but today, every kind of user is spoilt for choice.
Now, to Microsoft’s credit, File Explorer is better now than it ever used to be, with its tabs and clean UI. But for Windows 11 daily drivers (over 60% of global desktop users), sluggish folder loads, inconsistent menus, and a not-so-great workflow are still friction-inducing problems to contend with. So, for an entire week, I replaced File Explorer with not one, but two alternatives, and by the end of it, I didn’t expect to hesitate between them.
8 Windows features you should replace with third-party apps
You can do so much better
File Explorer is good now, but still not enough
Microsoft has fixed the basics, but missed the experience
In the interest of complete honesty, I’ll admit that File Explorer in Windows 11 isn’t a complete disaster at all. In fact, with tabs, the command bar, and its overall modernizations, there isn’t a lot that the average user would find fault in. However, using it every day still feels like dealing with something that’s only been partially rethought, and that goes for anyone even partially on the power user spectrum.
The biggest issue has more to do with the overall experience than it has to do with any one missing feature, though. Folder navigation still has moments where it just slows down for no good reason. Before I turned off Automatic Folder Type Discovery, Explorer still liked to become lethargic out of the blue, and the context menus are definitely a problematic compromise between the old and the new, instead of feeling like a clean transition.
So, over the past few months, I caught myself working around File Explorer more than actually enjoying it. Opening multiple windows just to manage files, constantly resizing things, dealing with inconsistent layouts — it all added up to the point I found myself finally looking for alternatives.
Microsoft responds to feedback with long-requested Windows 11 features, including taskbar tweaks and improved file explorer
The tech giant says it’s listening to user feedback.
Files is the explorer Windows 11 should’ve had
It’s modern, clean, and built for how we actually use Windows
The first file explorer I decided to use was Files. The moment I launched the app, it immediately felt like what Microsoft meant File Explorer to be, but never quite managed to deliver. Out of all the file managers for Windows 11 available today, Files comes the closest to looking like it’s natively a part of the OS, thanks to its clean visuals and design. In fact, the design actually improves how you interact with your files. For starters, tabs in Files don’t feel like an afterthought (which we know they were since Microsoft added them to Windows 11 with a later update). Instead, tabs are central to the entire experience here.
The layouts are flexible, the navigation feels so much snappier than File Explorer’s, and there are small touches like tagging and better sidebar organization that genuinely make a difference in the daily user experience, especially when you’re juggling multiple folders. You’d be surprised, much as I was, that using Files almost immediately becomes second nature. That ease of use comes from how everything is where you’d expect it to be, but just… better thought out. Even simple tasks like copying files, or jumping between directories, felt smoother and more intentional.
There’s also a sense of cohesion in Files that File Explorer still lacks. Nothing feels bolted on. It’s all consistent, visually and functionally, in a way that makes daily use feel less like a chore. So, by day three, Files had become the go-to explorer for me, before I completely switched gears and tested the second, more recommended software.
Files 4.0 just came out, and these are my 6 favorite features
A fantastic file manager gets even better
7/10
Files in an open-source file explorer for Windows that offers a customizable interface.
OneCommander is what happens when power users take over
Dual panes, deep control, and zero hand-holding
OneCommander, right from the get-go, feels like you’re stepping into a completely different philosophy vis-à-vis file management. I’d spent half a week seeing Files refining the default experience, and in came OneCommander, throwing it out entirely and building something that gave me control over every file on my PC.
OneCommander is a pretty popular File Explorer alternative, and rightly so. The dual-pane layout is the headline feature here, and it genuinely changes how you work on Windows 11, immediately. Dragging files between directories, comparing folders, and organizing large batches are all tasks that become much faster and more deliberate, and once it clicks, going back to a single-pane view feels restrictive. I myself expected to be relieved when I switched back to a single-pane view, and yet, it almost felt like my brain itched to get the dual-pane view back.
OneCommander doesn’t stop there, either. It’s packed with customization options, alternative layouts like Miller columns, and the overall level of flexibility on offer here genuinely borders on overwhelming. It’s almost like playing a game that doesn’t hold your hand and has a steep learning curve: OneCommander expects you to meet it halfway. That’s why things slowed down initially, since I had to take the time to figure out where things were, and how best to set things up. Plenty of online tutorials helped, and once everything was good to go by the end of day one, I felt like I’d switched to a maximum-efficiency tool. This is not going to feel like a familiar file manager, but OneCommander isn’t trying to be one, either. It’s just trying to be better, and that too, on its own terms, where it undoubtedly succeeds.
6 reasons OneCommander is my favorite free file manager for Windows, and it’s not even close
What’s there not to love?
The one I chose wasn’t the one I expected
Files has won me over (for now)
Going into this, I fully expected to stick with OneCommander. On paper and while using it, it’s clearly the more powerful tool. And yet, after a full week of actually living with both, I kept coming back to the Files app. And the more I try to come to a reason for it, the simpler it gets: Files fits into my workflow without demanding that I change it.
Now, OneCommander is absolutely brilliant when you’re actively managing files, and moving, sorting, and organizing them at scale. On the other hand, Files works just as well when you’re not thinking about File Management at all. It’s the app I reached for when I just needed to grab something quickly, open a folder, or move between projects without breaking my flow. It’s also the app that made me breathe an audible sigh of relief when I switched back to it after three days of using OneCommander.
There’s a balance here that Files gets right. It significantly improves on File Explorer in meaningful ways, all without overwhelming the user with options they won’t always need. Think of it more as an upgrade to the established system instead of a replacement that you have to put in effort to adapt to. It’s not as efficient as OneCommander, of course, but it’s certainly more consistent, and instead of maximum control, I’m going for everyday usability, since that’s what I value more, for now, at least.
I fixed Windows 11 File Explorer lag by disabling this legacy service
A quarter-century old service we no longer need.
Which one should you use?
Files gives me something better to reach for daily, even if it doesn’t replace File Explorer entirely.
After a week of bouncing between both, I can state that the answer is more about which one aligns with how you work. If your day revolved around moving files in bulk, comparing folders, and managing directories, then OneCommander is, without a shadow of doubt, the one to go with. It’s the more powerful tool of the two, and the dual-pane workflow and depth are genuine time savers.
However, if you want something that feels more like a natural evolution of what Windows 11 already offers, then the Files app is the easier recommendation. It’s intuitive, it’s polished, and it improves your day-to-day experience without asking you to relearn anything.
The one thing to keep in mind here, however, is that neither option fully replaces File Explorer at the system level. Windows still steps in when it wants to, with File Explorer. With the option I’ve picked, I feel like my choice hasn’t been about replacing File Explorer entirely, but rather about having something better to reach for, most of the time.
