How did judges decide prison sentences handed down in Hong Kong 47 trial?

The sentences handed down to former opposition activists in Hong Kong’s landmark national security case on Tuesday were proportionate, neither too lenient nor overly harsh, given the court’s decision that the plot they hatched undermined national security and was tantamount to wanting to overthrow the government, some legal experts have said.

The experts contacted by the Post also said the sentencing had its own unique circumstances that should not set a precedent for punishments in future subversion or national security-related trials.

At the close of the city’s largest and longest-running national security trial so far, 45 defendants received jail sentences ranging from four years and two months to 10 years for conspiracy to commit subversion. Another two defendants were cleared by the court in May.

Thirty-one of the 45 pleaded guilty and 14 others were convicted in May for taking part in a plot in 2020 to overthrow the government by securing a majority in the Legislative Council and indiscriminately voting down budgets and other bills to trigger a constitutional crisis.

05:14

Hong Kong 47: ‘Mastermind’ Benny Tai jailed for 10 years for plot to overthrow government

Hong Kong 47: ‘Mastermind’ Benny Tai jailed for 10 years for plot to overthrow government

The court sentenced former University of Hong Kong (HKU) legal academic Benny Tai Yiu-ting, who it said had “advocated for a revolution” and masterminded the scheme, to 10 years in prison as a principal offender under Article 22 of the 2020 national security law.

Grenville Cross, a barrister and former director of public prosecutions, said: “There are 45 sentences, and whereas some seem on the lenient side, others appear about right.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Cool, wet for Hongkongers on Thursday but temperature set to rise in coming days

Cool, wet for Hongkongers on Thursday but temperature set to rise in coming days

Hongkongers woke up to cool and wet weather on Thursday as temperatures dipped to 17 degrees Celsius in urban areas, with the mercury dropping to as low as 13 degrees on the city’s highest peak. Temperatures are forecast to rise slightly over the next five days to between 19 and 24 degrees with sunny periods

Officials Refuse to Discuss or Amend Hong Kong's Surfing Ban

Officials Refuse to Discuss or Amend Hong Kong’s Surfing Ban

Photo: Screenshot//YouTube//South China Morning Post Hong Kong’s Culture, Sports and Tourism Bureau (CSTB) has confirmed it “will not budge” on the longstanding surfing ban that’s seen an uptick in recent reinforcement. That’s according to a story published by the South China Morning Post after speaking to Adrian Pedro Ho King-hong, a lawmaker with the New

A Meituan drone landing on an express delivery station in Shenzhen. Photo: Xinhua

Meituan aims to launch drone deliveries in Hong Kong’s low-altitude economy

Food delivery giant Meituan is looking to launch its drone delivery services in Hong Kong, joining a slew of Chinese tech giants that are searching for new growth in the city amid stiff competition on the mainland. Meituan aims to be one of the first companies to operate a drone delivery fleet in Hong Kong,

A Meituan drone landing on an express delivery station in Shenzhen. Photo: Xinhua

Meituan aims to launch drone deliveries in Hong Kong’s low-altitude economy

Food delivery giant Meituan is looking to launch its drone delivery services in Hong Kong, joining a slew of Chinese tech giants that are searching for new growth in the city amid stiff competition on the mainland. Meituan aims to be one of the first companies to operate a drone delivery fleet in Hong Kong,

【Emily】《九龍城寨》展12‧16移師啟德 更廣更開放 - 20241121 - 港聞 - 每日明報

【Emily】《九龍城寨》展12‧16移師啟德 更廣更開放 – 20241121 – 港聞 – 每日明報

港聞 2024年11月21日星期四 港聞二 黎:見彭斯籲為港發聲 沒要求做事 稱會面「不知誰安排」 否認向外國政團捐款 稱《蘋果》反港獨反暴力 僅兩下編採指示 包括「一人一信救香港」 冀特朗普阻國安法實施 稱未敢視彭定康朋友 不識部分「共謀者」未聞IPAC 黎英語作供向親友微笑 市民冒雨等旁聽 美眾院引述黎指司法遭破壞 港府批污衊 「須嚴厲直斥」 河套設跨境行人橋「無感通關」 兩地先批核往返人員 工程開支分配待與深圳商討 發展綱要四方向 建國際產學研平台闢創新試驗田 灣仔7億元北都展館分開撥款 新田科技城造價料降至272億 「預設醫療指示」立法 18月過渡 盧寵茂:讓晚期病人尊嚴地走完旅程 管理毒倉月酬8萬 19歲女子被捕 房署查詢內地澳門 一年揭16戶申公屋瞞報物業 周日單車賽封路 往機場料多半句鐘 北大嶼港珠澳橋等受影響 警方料車龍4公里 政總後門遭擲油漆彈 警列刑毁 陳文敏:45人刑期處分級制範圍內 律政司上訴難度高 初選案散庭後舉標語 呂智恆養母涉行為不檢被捕 AI監察遇溺誤鳴 拯溺會:未宜推廣 騎單車強制戴頭盔 目標明年修例 意外黑點或限駕 研管電動單車 羅健熙集結罪脫遭上訴 律政司:原審誤判被告目的異示威者 男生社工集結蒙面罪脫遭上訴 發還原審 馬場設數碼遊戲 VR策騎AI助揀心水馬 扮水電師傅騙訂金 涉款3.2萬 兩人被捕 活在灣區:港人北上坐月 套餐豐儉由人 【Emily】議員收匙「驗樓」 讚新office四正光猛 有裝修味 梁君彥話仍需執漏盼包容 【Emily】下年多6個體育館可玩新興運動 【Emily】時裝薈「工裝」響頭炮 陳祖恒盼季季搞「說好香港時裝」 【Emily】藍田站→鰂魚涌站 港鐵航拍片重溫舊觀塘線過海 【Emily】《九龍城寨》展12‧16移師啟德 更廣更開放  Source link

Son of jailed Hong Kong activist on father’s potential life sentence

Son of jailed Hong Kong activist on father’s potential life sentence

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Now Playing ‘Time is running out’: Son of jailed Hong Kong activist on father’s potential life sentence 06:28 UP NEXT ‘I would call it saber rattling’: Adm. Stavridis on Russia’s nuclear threat against the West 04:56 ‘This is an autonomous

Cardinal Joseph Zen and Jimmy Lai’s wife, Teresa Lai, leave the court on Wednesday. Photo: Dickson Lee

Hong Kong’s Jimmy Lai admits donating money to overseas groups but denies having agenda

Former media boss and opposition activist Jimmy Lai Chee-ying took to the witness stand for the first time on Wednesday in his high-profile national security trial, admitting he had donated money to local and overseas groups but denying that he used those connections to manipulate foreign policies on Hong Kong and mainland China. Beijing rebuffed

Hong Kong government condemns red paint attack at headquarters

Hong Kong government condemns red paint attack at headquarters

The Hong Kong government has condemned the throwing of a bottle filled with red paint at its headquarters, warning authorities will follow up on the attack. Security personnel called police on Wednesday at about 7.40am after discovering red paint had been splashed near a flower bed at the headquarters in Tamar, Admiralty. Glass debris was

Hong Kong-Shenzhen I&T hub to fuel cross-border talent, capital and data flow: minister

Hong Kong-Shenzhen I&T hub to fuel cross-border talent, capital and data flow: minister

A new innovation and technology (I&T) hub co-developed by Hong Kong and Shenzhen will boost the flow of personnel, capital and data, starting with the building of two bridges, according to a blueprint shared by the technology minister. Authorities on Wednesday outlined their plans for the Hetao Shenzhen-Hong Kong Science and Technology Innovation Cooperation Zone,

Hongkongers heading to airport urged to take trains during National Games test event

Hongkongers heading to airport urged to take trains during National Games test event

Hongkongers should consider taking trains to the airport on Sunday as some roads on Lantau Island will be closed for a cross-border cycling race, the organiser of the test event for next year’s National Games has said. The race will also cause hours-long closures to parts of the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge and some border crossing

Hong Kong legal change to make helmets mandatory for cyclists postponed to 2025

Hong Kong legal change to make helmets mandatory for cyclists postponed to 2025

A proposed legal amendment to make helmets mandatory for cyclists in Hong Kong has been postponed to 2025, as authorities have said more time is needed to study the age requirements and practices in other jurisdictions. The government said on Wednesday it aimed to promote safety and reduce the number of accidents, while also ensuring

Explainer | US threatens sanctions: what Hong Kong can expect after the jailing of 45 activists

Explainer | US threatens sanctions: what Hong Kong can expect after the jailing of 45 activists

The United States has vowed to impose new visa restrictions on Hong Kong officials after 45 opposition activists were jailed for subversion, with former legal scholar Benny Tai Yiu-ting receiving the toughest penalty for orchestrating an unauthorised legislative “primary” election. Washington had previously imposed economic sanctions and other restrictions against the city after Beijing enacted

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x