German court rejects Peruvian farmer’s landmark climate case

Vanessa Buschschlüter

BBC News

Reuters Peruvian farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya poses for a photo in front of Lake Palcacocha. He is wearing a baseball cap and behind him the clear waters of the lake can be seen. Reuters

Saúl Luciano Lliuya says water in Lake Palcacocha has increased, putting his hometown at risk

A court in Germany has rejected a lawsuit brought by a Peruvian farmer against German energy giant RWE in a long-awaited decision.

Saúl Luciano Lliuya had argued that the firm’s global emissions contributed to the melting of glaciers in Peru – threatening his hometown of Huaraz with flooding.

He was seeking €17,000 (£14,250) in compensation – money he said he would use to pay for a flood defence project to protect the city.

However, the higher regional court in the German city of Hamm on Wednesday blocked the case from proceeding further and ruled out any appeals, putting an end to Mr Lliuya’s 10-year legal battle.

RWE said it was not active in Peru and questioned why it was singled out.

It also pointed to its plans to phase out its coal-fired power plants and become carbon neutral by 2040.

In their ruling on Wednesday, judges deemed that the flood risk to the property of Mr Lliuya was not high enough for the case to proceed.

However, in what climate change groups have hailed as a win, they did say that energy companies could be held responsible for the costs caused by their carbon emissions.

While the sum demanded by Mr Lliuya was very low, the case has become a cause celebre for climate change activists, who hope that it will set a precedent for holding powerful firms to account.

The 44-year-old mountain guide and farmer said he had brought the case because he had seen first-hand how rising temperatures were causing glaciers near Huaraz to melt.

He said that as a result, Lake Palcacocha – which is located above the city – now has four times as much water than in 2003 and that residents like him were at risk of flooding, especially if blocks of ice were to break off from Palcacocha glacier and fall into the lake, causing it to overflow.

He alleged that emissions caused by RWE were contributing to the increase in temperature in Peru’s mountain region and demanded that the German firm pay towards building a flood defence.

Mr Lliuya also said that he chose the company because a 2013 database tracking historic emissions from major fossil fuel producers listed the German energy giant as one of the biggest polluters in Europe.

Reuters Mr Lliuya is seen walking in front of Palcacocha Lake, in the Peruvian Andes. Snow-capped glaciers can be seen in the background. Reuters

Mr Lliuya says that as a mountain guide he has seen the effects of climate change at first hand

Mr Lliuya’s original case was rejected by a lower court in Germany in 2015, with judges arguing that a single firm could not be held responsible for climate change.

But in a surprise twist, Mr Lliuya in 2017 won his appeal with judges at the higher regional court, which accepted there was merit to his case and allowed it to proceed.

His lawyers previously argued that RWE was responsible for 0.5% of global CO2 emissions and demanded that the energy firm pay damages amounting to a proportional share of the cost of building a $3.5m-flood defence for Huaraz.

Reuters Mr Lliuya's lawyer, Roda Verheyen, can be seen smiling and embracing a woman outside the court in Hamm.Reuters

Mr Lliuya’s lawyer, Roda Verheyen, celebrated the court’s decision

Germanwatch, an environmental NGO which backed Mr Lliuya’s case, celebrated the court’s ruling saying it had “made legal history”.

“Although the court dismissed the specific claim – finding flood risk to Luciano Lliuya’s home was not sufficiently high – it confirmed for the first time that major emitters can be held liable under German civil law for risks resulting from climate change,” it said in a statement.

The group said it was hopeful that the decision could positively influence similar cases in other countries.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

2 Chinese scientists to stay in jail, accused of bringing biological material to US

發佈日期: 2025-06-14 21:57 TVB News 粵 已複製連結 Two Chinese scientists accused of smuggling or shipping biological material into the United States will remain in custody after waiving their right to a hearing in federal court. Yunqing Jian and Chengxuan Han made separate appearances in court in Detroit. Han was arrested on Sunday at Detroit Metropolitan

United Kingdom, United States, Japan, Spain, Malaysia, Thailand, Czech Republic, Turkey and Qatar Showcase Powerful Shifts in Luxury Travel as 2025 Hotel Index Reveals Where Five-Star Elegance Meets Unbeatable Value

Home » HOTEL NEWS » United Kingdom, United States, Japan, Spain, Malaysia, Thailand, Czech Republic, Turkey and Qatar Showcase Powerful Shifts in Luxury Travel as 2025 Hotel Index Reveals Where Five-Star Elegance Meets Unbeatable Value Saturday, June 14, 2025 In 2025, the global luxury travel landscape is undergoing a dramatic transformation, as revealed by the

Xiaomi Redmi Note 14 Pro vs. Redmi Note 14 Pro+ (global models)

You’re shopping for a mid-range phone in the €200–€300 range, and the Redmi Note 14 series clearly offers solid value. The problem? The lineup is packed with confusingly similar models -some even limited to 4G. We can also understand how comparing the Xiaomi Redmi Note 14 Pro 5G (Global) and the Xiaomi Redmi Note 14

Best Japanese Coffee Shops To Visit In Hong Kong

Image credit: fonji.cafe/Instagram Hong Kong — along with many other Asian cities — has fully embraced the café craze, with new spots popping up every month. But not every coffee bar may be your cup of Joe. Whether you seek a moment of calm or a flawless pour-over, we’ve found the best spots to savour

New TV Shows & Movies Being Added

Disney Plus’ schedule for June 16 to June 22, 2025, includes Underdogs (Season 1), SALLY, and Frozen: The Hit Broadway Musical. On June 16, Underdogs (Season 1) drops on Disney Plus. The reality show by National Geographic will be narrated by the celebrated actor Ryan Reynolds. The show focuses on the unknown and unexplored creatures

Gold Weekly Forecast: Geopolitics Could Push to New ATH

Gold Weekly Forecast: Geopolitics Could Push to New ATH

Gold weekly forecast is bullish amid geopolitical tension. Cooling US inflation data, which weighs on the dollar, boosted demand for gold. Market participants are now eyeing the FOMC meeting minutes. The gold weekly forecast turns strongly bullish, with an eye on testing the all-time highs around $3,500. The recent geopolitical tension stemming from the Israel-Iran

Commissioner of Police Joe Chow has said threats such as home-grown terrorism and soft resistance still remain. Photo: Jonathan Wong

Hong Kong police chief vows vigilance against lingering national security threats

Hong Kong’s police chief has pledged vigilance against lingering threats of external interference, home-grown terrorism and “soft resistance”, five years after the Beijing-imposed national security law was promulgated. Commissioner of Police Joe Chow Yat-ming said that while Hong Kong had returned to a state of stability in recent years, “undercurrents” remained that required the force

These are the 7 best fitness apps for Android (that aren’t Strava)

If you’re looking for the best fitness app to download onto your Android phone, you’re probably sick of having people recommend to you Strava. The social run app is ubiquitous, but if you’re not keen to overshare your workouts or don’t base your personality around your weekly 5k jog, you’ll want something different. Different is

United Kingdom, Spain, Turkey, and Cyprus Issue Urgent Travel Warning with Tougher Passport Rules That Could Disrupt Summer Holiday Plans for Thousands

Home » VISA AND PASSPORT NEWS » United Kingdom, Spain, Turkey, and Cyprus Issue Urgent Travel Warning with Tougher Passport Rules That Could Disrupt Summer Holiday Plans for Thousands Saturday, June 14, 2025 Holidaymakers planning trips to Spain, Turkey, Cyprus, or any destination from the United Kingdom this summer are being urged to take immediate

歐陽萬成Jimmy O.Yang棟篤笑開騷前遊香港 到訪中環文武廟求演出成功 大歎燒味滿足

歐陽萬成(Jimmy O.Yang)由今日起(13日)一連3日在紅館舉行「Jimmy O Yang Live in Hong Kong」棟篤笑。Jimmy O.Yang在社交平台宣布「回家」,隨即獲香港旅遊發展局(旅發局)邀請遊歷香港,從過百年歷史的上環文武廟、到乘搭昂坪360纜車,然後再品嚐亞洲最佳酒吧的雞尾酒及地道燒味等美食,一天內體驗香港獨特文化和美食,滋味十足又盡興! Jimmy O.Yang到文武廟求表演成功 歐陽萬成率先參觀擁有百年歷史的上環文武廟,一到埗他跟足傳統儀式,先摸「文昌筆」、再摸「關帝刀」,並親手為金鹿貼上金箔,祈求今晚舉行的棟篤笑騷表演順利兼成功。Jimmy O.Yang亦有乘坐昂坪360全景纜車,從高空俯瞰香港美麗景色。當他到達昂坪後,他走訪天壇大佛,體驗傳統文化。旅發局與昂坪360特別在纜車的玻璃上,貼上專屬貼紙歡迎Jimmy到訪,為這趟大嶼山之旅留下難忘的回憶。 歐陽萬成歎亞洲第一酒吧雞味酒 今次歐陽萬成回港亦有訪酒吧,並品嚐亞洲第一酒吧的招牌雞味酒。他與酒吧創辦人Lorenzo暢談香港夜生活的魅力;而Lorenzo更親手調製招牌雞尾酒搭配自家製煙燻橄欖給Jimmy細味,Jimmy一邊歎雞尾酒一邊吃佐酒小食。回到香港,Jimmy O.Yang不得不食港式燒味,他入座後隨即向店員落單點了半肥瘦梅頭叉燒,還有燒鵝「下庄」、茅台醬油和三黃雞等美食,令他回味無窮。旅發局總幹事程鼎一亦特意到場「探班」,為Jimmy開騷前加油打氣。 歐陽萬成開騷前遊香港尋成長回憶 歐陽萬成事後說:「我在香港度過了童年時光,一直深深感受到這座城市獨特的活力。這是一個融合傳統與創新的地方,一天之內便能穿梭於百年文化與自然美景之間。每趟旅程都充滿驚喜,展現香港多元的城市風貌。」他續稱香港的美食體驗亦充滿驚喜,從本地人氣燒味店品嚐半肥瘦梅頭叉燒,到細味亞洲頂級酒吧的招牌雞尾酒,滋味十足。他指:「我生於香港,這些滋味不僅是味蕾的享受,更是我成長回憶的一部分。」 延伸內容:歐陽萬成Jimmy O Yang棟篤笑美國爆紅 稱黃子華粉絲6月來港開騷 吳彥祖高呼Yeah難掩興奮之情 延伸內容:歐陽萬成Jimmy O. Yang快閃深水埗 訪60年周生生老店尋金 《東周網》訪談系列節目《星桄伴我心》6月重磅嘉賓:即睇:75歲翁倩玉爆初戀情人秦沛畫卡通追求 隨緣孤身走情路 紅着眼憶重病父 為見愛妻堅持站起來 Source link

Champions League Line-Up: Who Joins Liverpool in 2025

Liverpool’s Champions League Rivals Amid Evolving European Landscape The curtain is slowly rising on another Champions League campaign, and Liverpool are already centre stage. With 29 clubs confirmed for the 2025–26 edition of Europe’s most prestigious competition, the storylines are beginning to form, and the cast is nearly complete. Premier League’s Six Strong in Europe

New TV Shows & Movies Being Added

Netflix’s schedule for June 16 to June 22, 2025, includes The Last Witch Hunter, Somebody Feed Phil Season 8, KPop Demon Hunters, The Intern, and many others. On June 16, The Last Witch Hunter drops on Netflix. The action fantasy follows an immortal witch hunter named Kaulder, who realizes that the Queen Witch has been

New Annoucement Made by Hong Kong ‘s Cathay Pacific Airline of Increasing Accessibility to Johannesburg – Find Out How This Travel Game-Changer Impacts You!

Home » AIRLINE NEWS » New Annoucement Made by Hong Kong ‘s Cathay Pacific Airline of Increasing Accessibility to Johannesburg – Find Out How This Travel Game-Changer Impacts You! Saturday, June 14, 2025 Hong Kong tourists enjoy greater and more frequent access to South Africa than they have ever had before, as Cathay Pacific extends

Markets Enter High-Risk Phase as Geopolitical and Trade Risks Collide

Global Financial markets have endured months of turmoil, with overlapping concerns over the US debt downgrade, recession fears, and an intensifying global trade war. The sharp escalation in Middle East conflict last week has only deepened the anxiety, as Israel and Iran exchanged strikes, raising the specter of prolonged regional instability. With the 90-day reciprocal

Should Hong Kong hit Redhill Peninsula homeowners with heavier fines for illegal works?

Should Hong Kong hit Redhill Peninsula homeowners with heavier fines for illegal works?

Hong Kong authorities should appeal against the “light” penalties imposed on two property owners for erecting illegal structures at their luxury Redhill Peninsula homes, experts have said, warning that the fines are not hefty enough to deter offenders. The specialists weighed in after the two property owners were told to pay more than HK$110,000 (US$14,015)

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x