German court rejects Peruvian farmer’s landmark climate case

Vanessa Buschschlüter

BBC News

Reuters Peruvian farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya poses for a photo in front of Lake Palcacocha. He is wearing a baseball cap and behind him the clear waters of the lake can be seen. Reuters

Saúl Luciano Lliuya says water in Lake Palcacocha has increased, putting his hometown at risk

A court in Germany has rejected a lawsuit brought by a Peruvian farmer against German energy giant RWE in a long-awaited decision.

Saúl Luciano Lliuya had argued that the firm’s global emissions contributed to the melting of glaciers in Peru – threatening his hometown of Huaraz with flooding.

He was seeking €17,000 (£14,250) in compensation – money he said he would use to pay for a flood defence project to protect the city.

However, the higher regional court in the German city of Hamm on Wednesday blocked the case from proceeding further and ruled out any appeals, putting an end to Mr Lliuya’s 10-year legal battle.

RWE said it was not active in Peru and questioned why it was singled out.

It also pointed to its plans to phase out its coal-fired power plants and become carbon neutral by 2040.

In their ruling on Wednesday, judges deemed that the flood risk to the property of Mr Lliuya was not high enough for the case to proceed.

However, in what climate change groups have hailed as a win, they did say that energy companies could be held responsible for the costs caused by their carbon emissions.

While the sum demanded by Mr Lliuya was very low, the case has become a cause celebre for climate change activists, who hope that it will set a precedent for holding powerful firms to account.

The 44-year-old mountain guide and farmer said he had brought the case because he had seen first-hand how rising temperatures were causing glaciers near Huaraz to melt.

He said that as a result, Lake Palcacocha – which is located above the city – now has four times as much water than in 2003 and that residents like him were at risk of flooding, especially if blocks of ice were to break off from Palcacocha glacier and fall into the lake, causing it to overflow.

He alleged that emissions caused by RWE were contributing to the increase in temperature in Peru’s mountain region and demanded that the German firm pay towards building a flood defence.

Mr Lliuya also said that he chose the company because a 2013 database tracking historic emissions from major fossil fuel producers listed the German energy giant as one of the biggest polluters in Europe.

Reuters Mr Lliuya is seen walking in front of Palcacocha Lake, in the Peruvian Andes. Snow-capped glaciers can be seen in the background. Reuters

Mr Lliuya says that as a mountain guide he has seen the effects of climate change at first hand

Mr Lliuya’s original case was rejected by a lower court in Germany in 2015, with judges arguing that a single firm could not be held responsible for climate change.

But in a surprise twist, Mr Lliuya in 2017 won his appeal with judges at the higher regional court, which accepted there was merit to his case and allowed it to proceed.

His lawyers previously argued that RWE was responsible for 0.5% of global CO2 emissions and demanded that the energy firm pay damages amounting to a proportional share of the cost of building a $3.5m-flood defence for Huaraz.

Reuters Mr Lliuya's lawyer, Roda Verheyen, can be seen smiling and embracing a woman outside the court in Hamm.Reuters

Mr Lliuya’s lawyer, Roda Verheyen, celebrated the court’s decision

Germanwatch, an environmental NGO which backed Mr Lliuya’s case, celebrated the court’s ruling saying it had “made legal history”.

“Although the court dismissed the specific claim – finding flood risk to Luciano Lliuya’s home was not sufficiently high – it confirmed for the first time that major emitters can be held liable under German civil law for risks resulting from climate change,” it said in a statement.

The group said it was hopeful that the decision could positively influence similar cases in other countries.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Realme P3 Ultra in for review

We had a quick hands-on with the Realme P3 Ultra in March but it’s now time for a review. Realme P3 Ultra The phone has a standout design, no matter which color you go for. The Neptune Blue and Orion Red both feature vegan leather finishes, while this Glowing Lunar White is unique. The moon’s

A Quick Look at 5 of Amsterdam’s Coolest New Cafés

Fresh off of the heels of the Amsterdam Coffee Fest, we explore some new faces in the city’s café scene. BY TANYA NANETTISENIOR ONLINE CORRESPONDENT Featured photo by Javier Melpri A couple of years ago, we highlighted four of Amsterdam’s coolest roasters, and now we’re back to spend a few days searching for visit-worthy coffee

Slender Honor MagicBook Art 14 2025 design shown off in official images

While the Honor Magic V5 is getting most of the attention, next week’s event will feature several other new devices. Honor already shared official images of the MagicPad 3, now let’s have a peek at the Honor MagicBook Art 14. Honor MagicBook Art 14 2025 More specifically, the Honor MagicBook

Study Finds Link Between Instant Coffee and Eye Disease Risk

A new genetics study found that drinking instant coffee may significantly increase the risk of developing dry age-related macular degeneration (AMD), a leading cause of vision loss in older adults. Published in the Wiley journal Food Science & Nutrition and led by a research team from multiple universities in China, the study found no such

iOS 26 Beta 2 tones down the Liquid Glass effect

Apple has released its second iOS 26 beta to developers, and the latest update tackles several user complaints associated with the new Liquid Glass design. There’s a more pronounced blur option for Control Center, which regulates the new Liquid Glass effect. The background uses a darker shade and adds more blur to help with legibility.

Future of Coffee Machines Market: 2025-2034 Analysis

According to a recent report by Expert Market Research (EMR), the global coffee machines market is expected to grow at a CAGR of 4.10% during the forecast period of 2025-2034. Driven by consumers’ evolving tastes and rising expectations for premium coffee experiences, the market is projected to witness substantial expansion by 2034. Coffee machines, from

Tecno Spark Go 2 brings updated design and affordable pricing

Tecno’s latest entry-level device is here with the Spark Go 2. As its name implies, this is the successor to last year’s Spark Go 1 and most of the key specs are identical between the two. Tecno Spark Go 2 in Ink Black and Titanium Grey Spark Go 2 does get an

Poco F7 price leaks ahead of today’s announcement

The Poco F7 is almost here – the big announcement is scheduled for later today. That said, Poco took a slightly weird approach with this launch and it sent us review units to unbox early – here is the Silver version and the Black version. Poco F7 in Silver and

vivo T4 Lite arrives with Dimensity 6300 SoC and 6,000 mAh battery

As promised, vivo has unveiled the T4 Lite as the latest member of the T4 series, which includes the T4, T4x, and T4 Ultra. vivo T4 5G The vivo T4 Lite has the Dimensity 6300 SoC under the hood, paired with up to 8GB of RAM and 256GB storage, which is expandable up to 2TB

Samsung announces the date of Galaxy Unpacked event for its new foldables

Last week, leakster Evan Blass said that Samsung would host its Galaxy Unpacked event for the unveiling of new foldables on July 9. Well, Blass’ claim has turned out to be true, as Samsung has confirmed the July 9 date for the Galaxy Unpacked event. The event will be hosted in Brooklyn, New York, and

T-Satellite with Starlink is launching next month — what you need to know about T-Mobile’s satellite-to-mobile service

Starting next month, it should be easier than ever to stay connected on T-Mobile’s wireless network, as the carrier has just announced plans to launch its satellite-to-mobile service starting July 23. T-Satellite launches initially with support for text messaging, with plans to offer data connectivity over satellite in October. The T-Satellite service is the result

The Phinoi Dripper—A New Take on Vietnamese Coffee

A modern interpretation of Vietnam’s traditional phin filter, the Phinoi made its debut last month at World of Coffee Jakarta. Today, we’re giving it a go. BY VASILEIA FANARIOTISENIOR ONLINE CORRESPONDENT Photos courtesy of Vasileia Fanarioti Can a modern phin filter reinvent how we experience Vietnamese coffee? That’s the question posed by the Phinoi, a strikingly

No one expected T-Mobile to dare so much: competitors should take note

T-Mobile has established itself as one of the major players in the mobile phone market in the United States. Its network is one of the most extensive and reliable in the country, and this has attracted not only millions of users. It has also drawn other companies interested in offering telecommunications services over its infrastructure.

Samsung Galaxy Z Fold7 and Z Flip7 prices leak ahead of launch

The Samsung Galaxy Z Fold7 and the Z Flip7 are reportedly just around the corner, so retailers are getting ready for the market release and putting up some preliminary listings. However, in order to prevent leaks, Samsung has started using codenames for its devices. Listings from an Italian retailer Unfortunately

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x