Fears Iran’s internet shutdown could lead to ‘extreme digital isolation’

Joe Tidy,BBC cybersecurity correspondentand

Farshad Bayan,BBC Persian

NurPhoto via Getty Images An armed Special Units police officer in Iran, dressed in black and holding a weapon, is standing on an armored vehicle while monitoring the surroundings. In the background, telecommunications towers and the Iranian flag can be seen. The photo was taken during a pro-government gathering in central Tehran.
NurPhoto via Getty Images

Iran is 10 days into one of the most extreme internet shutdowns in history, with 92 million citizens cut off from all internet services and even disruption to phone and text messaging.

The Iranian government cut off services on 8 January, apparently to stifle dissent and prevent international scrutiny of a government crack down on protesters.

Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said the internet was cut off in response to what he described as externally directed “terrorist operations”.

The government has not said when internet services will return, but new reports suggest that, behind the scenes, the authorities may be making plans to restrict it permanently.

On 15 January, the news website IranWire reported that government spokesperson Fatemeh Mohajerani told journalists that international web access will not be available until at least the Iranian New Year in late March.

Internet freedom observers at FilterWatch believe the government is hastily implementing new systems and rules to cut Iran off from the international internet.

“There should be no expectation of reopening international internet access, and even afterwards, users’ access to international internet will never return to its previous form,” FilterWatch said, citing unnamed government sources.

While the BBC cannot independently verify this report or the timing of its implementation, journalists who spoke to BBC Persian also said they were told that internet access would not be restored anytime soon.

From temporary outage to “communication black hole”

Iran has maintained a tight grip over the internet for many years, with most western social media apps and platforms blocked, as well as external news websites like BBC News.

However many people have managed to access popular apps such as Instagram using Virtual Private Networks (VPNs).

Internet freedom campaigners at Access Now say Iran has consistently used shutdowns as a way to mask mass violence and brutal crackdowns on protesters, as seen during the nationwide internet shutdowns during the November 2019 and September 2022 protests.

Kentik According to traffic data from Kentik, an increase in data flow into Iran began at 3:42am local time on Jan 17th. However, current connectivity remains extremely limited, accounting for only about 0.2% of the traffic volume recorded before the internet shutdown on 8 January.Kentik

Based on Kentik’s traffic data, the increase in inbound data flow into Iran (shown by the dotted line in the lower‑right corner) began at 3:42 a.m. local time on Jan 17th. However, the current level of connectivity remains extremely limited, amounting to only about 0.2% of the traffic volume recorded before the January 8 Internet shutdown.

A shutdown was also imposed during the Iran-Israel conflict in June 2025.

However, the current blackout has lasted longer than any previous shutdown.

In a public statement, the charity Access Now said that full restoration of internet access is imperative.

“Restricting access to these essential services not only endanger lives but embolden authorities to conceal and evade accountability for human rights abuses,” it said.

Already there are reports that livelihoods in Iran are being badly impacted by the shutdown with e-commerce particularly affected.

As of 18 January, the Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA) estimates that more than 3,300 confirmed protester deaths have been recorded, with more than 4,380 cases under review. It also reports that the number of arrests has reached 24,266 across 187 cities.

The real number of people killed and detained is believed to be significantly higher, but the lack of access means the figures cannot be independently verified.

Internet monitoring project, FilterWatch, says that the latest shutdown spells the start of a more extreme “digital isolation” and increased surveillance on what is said, sent and viewed online.

Amir Rashidi, director of cyber security and digital rights at the Miaan Group, which runs FilterWatch, told the BBC he believes the authorities are moving towards a tiered system in which access to the global internet would no longer be automatic but subject to approval.

Access would be granted through a registration and vetting process, he expects, adding that the technical infrastructure for such a system has been in place for years.

Who decides about the Internet?

According to FilterWatch, the plans are not being spoken about publicly, with key decisions increasingly concentrated within security bodies rather than civilian ministries.

Protecting Iran from cyber attacks – of which there have been many high profile and disruptive cases in recent years – may be another motivation for the extreme moves.

However, analysts caution that the plans may not fully materialise or could be applied unevenly due to internal power dynamics and broader economic and technical pressures.

Amir Rashidi notes that risks to internet providers, alongside users’ ability to adapt or migrate to alternative platforms, could further complicate implementation.

NurPhoto via Getty Images During a nighttime walk in northern Tehran, two young women are standing beside a small display of handmade pottery. One of them is entering information into a customer’s mobile phone. Pedestrians pass by, while the streetlights and surrounding trees illuminate the scene.
NurPhoto via Getty Images

The shutdown is affecting the livelihoods and daily activities of most Iranians

If Iran goes ahead with the plans being reported on, it will be following similar systems in Russia and China.

China has led the world on internet control not just with enormous state censorship over online discussion but also with what people are able to access abroad.

The so-called Great Chinese Firewall blocks citizens from much of the global internet and all western apps like Facebook, Instagram and YouTube are not reachable without VPNs – but they are also becoming harder to use.

In 2019, Russia began testing for a grand plan to create a similar system dubbed Ru-net.

But unlike China, which built state control into the internet as the web spread decades ago, Russia is having to retrofit state control into complex systems.

Russia is going a step further than China and planning to switch itself off from the world wide web with a “kill switch”, which will apparently be used at times of crisis.

The system will allow internal internet traffic and keep the country moving online but without traffic going outside or in – a digital border in effect. But it has yet to be fully tested.

Where is internet in Iran heading?

If the reports are accurate, it seems that Iran is planning to a quasi combination of permanent Chinese and Russian internet control.

“In Iran there seems to be a move to isolate everyone from any electronic access, unless approved by the government,” said computer security expert Prof Alan Woodward from Surrey University in the UK, after reviewing the reports of Iran’s plans.

He believes the Iranian regime has probably moved ahead with its longer term plans, using the current blackout as a reason to make the technical switches and orders now, whilst everything is cut off.

Amir Rashidi says the question is no longer technical, but political – arguing that whether such systems are fully implemented now depends on political will.

Mobina / Getty Images Men outside a bank using ATMs and one is walking by on his mobile phone.Mobina / Getty Images

Starlink and other internet-from-space services, known as Low Earth Orbit (LEO), have also complicated control for Iran during the protests.

LEO internet services allow users to get around all censorship and shutdowns by connecting via satellites.

The government was able to jam and interfere with some Starlink users but it has been confirmed to the BBC that other terminals remain operational after the company updated its firmware to bypass government blocking efforts.

The service, which is owned by Elon Musk, also waived subscription fees for Iranian users.

In spite of the increasing tools being used by repressive regimes, Woodward is surprisingly optimistic about the future of internet.

He cites advances in LEO and the fact that many phones can now use satellites even when the internet is down for things like SOS messages.

There are also emerging apps that use mesh networks relying on Bluetooth, which can bring connectivity where there is none.

“Its almost inevitable that internet access will be truly universal eventually but it’ll always be cat and mouse for repressive regimes”, Woodward says.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

A surge in patriotism and fewer US trips

A surge in patriotism and fewer US trips

Nadine YousifSenior Canada reporter EPA In the year since US President Donald Trump was inaugurated for his second term, he has brought with him significant global shifts. Like many countries, Canada – America’s closest neighbour to the north – has felt the impact and seen a change in the long-standing relationship with its close security

What to know about 'flashover fire' dangers

What to know about ‘flashover fire’ dangers

The Boston Globe/Getty Images Warning: This article contains themes you may find upsetting Gina Russo was watching a gig with her husband-to-be, Fred Crisostomi, one night in 2003 when she realised something wasn’t right. Great White, an 80s hair-rock band, had opened their set with a thrash of guitar chords, as four large pyrotechnic flares

Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said that the unrest resulted in “several thousand” deaths. (AFP/AP)

16,500 killed in Iran protests, claims report: ‘Genocide under digital darkness’

A new report quoting doctors on the ground has claimed that at least 16,500 protesters have died and 3,30,000 have been injured in Iran’s crackdown on weeks of demonstrations that initially began over economic issues but eventually turned into outrage calling for an end to the Iranian regime. Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said

Oracle Stock Quote

Prediction: These Stocks Will Collapse If the AI Bubble Pops in 2026

Oracle and CoreWeave are among the riskiest bets in the AI sector. There is a lot of talk of an artificial intelligence (AI) bubble. Echoes of 2000 are hard to ignore, with valuations reaching record highs and companies spending eye-watering amounts on infrastructure, racing to build as many colossal AI data centers as possible. While

The U.S. president, who appeared to have taken the country to the cusp of war, was pulling back from a military intervention as long as Tehran didn’t execute more demonstrators. (AP)

How Trump Went From ‘Locked and Loaded’ to Hitting Pause on Striking Iran

WASHINGTON—President Trump on Tuesday said he had canceled all meetings with Iran’s leaders, entreated Iranians protesting their government to overthrow the regime and declared that “HELP IS ON ITS WAY.” The U.S. president, who appeared to have taken the country to the cusp of war, was pulling back from a military intervention as long as

Gangland killing at a funeral shocks idyllic French island

Gangland killing at a funeral shocks idyllic French island

Chris BockmanIn southern France Pascal POCHARD-CASABIANCA/AFP Alain Orsoni was shot at his mother’s funeral service in his native village of Vero The mourners had gathered in the small village of Vero, a half-hour drive from Ajaccio, the capital of the picture-postcard Mediterranean island of Corsica. In their midst was former nationalist leader Alain Orsoni, 71,

YouTube star touches hearts in Africa during first tour

YouTube star touches hearts in Africa during first tour

Eswatini Tourism US YouTuber IShowSpeed took part in an initiation ceremony to become a warrior in Eswatini One of the world’s most popular content creators has been attracting huge crowds, mostly his young fans, as he undertakes a 20-nation tour of Africa, a continent he says is “full of surprises”. Pre-teen boys in Rwanda and

Protestors hold signs and portraits of the son of the last shah of Iran Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, Reza Pahlavi, during a demonstration in support of Iranian People in front of the Portuguese Parliament in Lisbon, on January 17, (AFP)

Reza Pahlavi says Iran is undergoing a revolution

For decades only diehard royalists took Reza Pahlavi seriously. Iran’s regime, its opponents and Western diplomats dismissed the son of the last shah as the “Clown Prince”. He seemed more interested in his suntan than recovering his sun-and-lion flag. When protests erupted on December 28th he was said to be on a beach holiday. For

Canada's deal with China signals it is serious about shift from US

Canada’s deal with China signals it is serious about shift from US

Nadine YousifSenior Canada reporter Watch: Canada-China trade relationship “more predictable” than with US, says Carney Prime Minister Mark Carney’s new approach to Canada’s foreign policy can perhaps be distilled in one line: “We take the world as it is, not as we wish it to be.” That was his response when asked about the deal

Trump's proposed credit card cap spotlights Americans' debt. Would it help?

Trump’s proposed credit card cap spotlights Americans’ debt. Would it help?

Danielle KayeBusiness reporter Getty Images Credit card debt is an increasingly heavy burden for millions of Americans. Selena Cooper, 26, is among those dealing with the strain. A former paralegal at the Social Security Administration, she was left without a stable income when the US government shut down a few months ago. She lost her

The South Korean millennials mocked for 'trying too hard'

The South Korean millennials mocked for ‘trying too hard’

Instagram/@detailance Ji says he has become more self-conscious interacting with younger colleagues Ji Seung-ryeol, 41, prides himself on his sense of fashion. He diligently shares mirror selfies on Instagram, where everyone knows the more likes you get, the cooler you are. So he was bewildered to find out that men his age have become the

Nasa's mega Moon rocket arrives at launch pad

Nasa’s mega Moon rocket arrives at launch pad

Rebecca Morelle, Alison Francis and Kevin ChurchScience team Watch: Timelapse shows Nasa rocket’s 12-hour journey to launch pad Nasa’s mega rocket has been moved to the launch pad in Cape Canaveral, Florida, as the final preparations get underway for the first crewed mission to the Moon in more than 50 years. Over almost 12 hours,

Trump's Greenland threats to allies are without parallel

Trump’s Greenland threats to allies are without parallel

Faisal IslamEconomics editor Getty Images US President Donald Trump’s apparently coercive threat to force Western allies not to oppose his proposed annexation of Greenland, or face further damage to their trade with the US, is without both parallel and precedent. We’ve had some unusual and unexpected economic threats from President Trump over the past year,

New snow map shows updated chance of snowstorm

New snow map shows updated chance of snowstorm

The Boston 25 weather team is tracking snow for Sunday and the possible effects it may have on the Patriots game. Boston 25 Meterologist Tucker Antico says to expect light, wet snow “around the hours of 6 to 10 p.m.” “Nothing crazy for the Pats game, some snow, but it will be light,” says Antico.

Westland Wessex, Lynx, and Wasp

Submarine-Destroying Aircraft of All Time

Submarines mauled shipping and threatened the survival of many nations in the second world war. One way to fight back was with anti-submarine warfare aircraft. Attacking a submarine from the air was a dangerous game, as surfaced submarines fired back at their attackers with machine guns and cannon. Converted bombers would roar a few hundred

Bangladesh's former Minister of Foreign Affairs Mohammed Hasan Mahmud speaks during the press conference at Press club of India, in New Delhi on Saturday. (ANI)

Fair polls impossible in Bangladesh under Yunus govt: Awami League

Bangladesh’s interim government is incapable of ensuring fair elections and has barred former premier Sheikh Hasina’s Awami League from participating in upcoming polls because it fears the party’s popularity, senior Awami League leaders said on Saturday. Bangladesh’s former Minister of Foreign Affairs Mohammed Hasan Mahmud speaks during the press conference at Press club of India,

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x