Brazil’s Congress Weakens Protection of Indigenous Lands, Defying Lula


Brazilian officials served up an array of plans and figures at the recent COP28 climate summit in Dubai, presenting itself as a world leader, on track to protect its forests and the people who live there.

But on Thursday, Brazil’s Congress approved a law that threatens Indigenous people’s rights to most of the land they inhabit or claim, potentially opening vast territories to deforestation, farming and mining.

The new law requires that Indigenous people must provide concrete evidence that they occupied the land they claim on Oct. 5, 1988, when the country’s current Constitution was enacted — a requirement that many of them have little or no hope of meeting.

Under the new rule, not only can Indigenous land claims currently going through the legal process be thrown out for lacking such documentation, but established legal protections for Indigenous territories can also be challenged in court and rescinded.

“We have watched the entire world at COP28 saying that we need to change the direction the planet is taking,” said the leftist congressman Tarcísio Motta, who voted against the bill, “but congress has just withdrawn the rights from the people who point to the future of the planet.”

Studies have repeatedly shown that protected Indigenous territories have helped prevent Amazon deforestation, meaning the forest can better store carbon to fight climate change.

In September, Brazil’s Supreme Court ruled against a 1988 cutoff date for Indigenous land claims, but backers of the new law, who include powerful agricultural interests, hope it will change the legal calculus.

The Congress passed the legislation last month, but President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva quickly vetoed most of its provisions. Then on Thursday, the House and Senate overrode the president’s veto, with many of his own allies joining his opponents in voting to defy him. Lawmakers also recently passed a measure that environmentalists call the “poison bill,” which relaxes rules on pesticides, and sent it to the president.

The Congress “has agreed with the agenda of the agribusiness caucus and of environmental setbacks,” said Marcio Astrini, the executive-secretary of the Climate Observatory, a network of environmental and civil society organizations in Brazil.

The law on Indigenous lands is expected to take effect by next week. Legal experts expect it to be challenged in the Supreme Court, and members of Apib, a leading Indigenous rights movement in Brazil, have already prepared a request for the court to review it.

Yet it could take months or more for the court to rule on the case, and environmentalists and Indigenous rights activists fear the harm that could be done by then.

“We will watch total chaos in jurisprudence and threats to the lives of these vulnerable people who depend on state action and on these territories to survive”, said Beto Marubo, an Indigenous leader and advocate of Indigenous rights from the Javari Valley of the Amazon basin, home to some of the most isolated people in Brazil.

Brazil has more than 1.7 million Indigenous people, according to official figures, and more than half live in the Amazon region. But only 20 percent of households with at least one Indigenous person live within designated Indigenous territories.

Those who do live in the territories already struggle against illegal forest-clearing for ranching and mining, and live with legal uncertainty, but the rate of deforestation is much lower in the Indigenous territories than elsewhere.

Across Brazil, 483 such territories have been granted full legal protection, and 278 others are going through the process to gain protection, according to FUNAI, a government agency.

Altogether, they cover more than 1.1 million square kilometers, or about 425,000 square miles, the size of Texas and California combined, almost 14 percent of Brazil’s area.

Advocacy groups say that under the new law, more than 90 percent of these lands could have protection lifted, and they have called out the government for undermining Mr. Lula’s environmental agenda, including preservation of the Amazon rainforest.

“It is a very contradictory situation for the country to have a policy to cut deforestation, and, on the other hand, have a Congress that fights tirelessly to end the richest instrument we have for protecting the Amazon: the Indigenous lands,” said Mr. Astrini.

Indigenous and environmental groups say that tribes with traditional lifestyles can have occupied an area for centuries without having any way to prove it. Some have had only passing contact with the developed world.

Congressmen who support the law argue it is needed to give landowners confidence that their land would not be taken from them, which would also create a better business environment for agriculture.

“What is happening today, with the overturning of the veto on the ‘time frame bill,’ is admirable because it brings legal certainty to those who own rural properties in Brazil,” said Márcio Bittar, a right-wing senator.

But it is the Indigenous whose land has been — and is being — taken from them, their advocates say, and the law ignores their history of dispossession and marginalization.

Outside of the government buildings in Brasília on Thursday, at least 100 Indigenous people and their supporters, including the government’s minister of the Indigenous Peoples, Sônia Guajajara, protested the bill as lawmakers inside voted to override the veto. Afterward, they headed to the nearby Supreme Court building to symbolically file their request for review.

Flávia Milhorance reported from Rio de Janeiro and Paulo Motoryn from Brasília.



Source link

Visited 3 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026, in Washington. AP/PTI(AP10_21_2026_000003A) (AP)

Donald Trump, human wrecking-ball | World News

“INEVER MEANT to start a war…I just closed my eyes and swung,” sings Miley Cyrus in “Wrecking Ball”, a break-up ballad that seemed to play on every American radio in 2013. Though melodically a bit relentless, the pop song deserves a revival as a guide to the second-term statecraft of President Donald Trump. President Donald

The Chinese national flag is pictured at half mast to mourn the death of China's former premier Zhu Rongji at the Red Building of Peking University, the site of early Chinese Communist Party revolutionary activities, in Beijing on August 18, 2026. (AFP FILE)

China’s universities are rich. But they’re getting squeezed

In its competition with China, America sometimes commits self-sabotage. Under Donald Trump, cuts in federal support for universities have been particularly damaging. To convey their anguish, some American scientists have drawn attention to the advantage that their country’s strategic rival may gain from these retrenchments. China had been handed the future “on a silver platter”,

Add image caption here

At 117, Albanian May Be World’s Oldest Woman Qamile Marra: Life Is Beautiful

Albania: At 117, Qamile Marra is not particularly concerned with proving she may be the world’s oldest woman — or even persuading Albanian pension officials that she is not dead. For a woman born under Ottoman rule, who turned 36 a fortnight before the end of World War II and outlived Albania’s communist dictatorship, her

Elon Musk with US President Donald Trump. (AP/File)

Elon Musk behind Starlink slowdown order that disrupted Ukraine’s drones: Report

A slowdown in SpaceX’s Starlink satellite network that disrupted Ukraine’s drone operations was triggered by an order from company’s CEO Elon Musk, The Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, citing unnamed US officials and other sources. Elon Musk with US President Donald Trump. (AP/File) The move reportedly restricted Ukraine’s access to the satellite service, affecting

Anthropic Recorded Net Loss Of Over $80 Billion In 1st Half Of 2026: Report

Anthropic Recorded Net Loss Of Over $80 Billion In 1st Half Of 2026: Report

That compares to a net loss of $13 billion during the same period a year earlier, according to report.  AI startup Anthropic recorded a net loss of more than $80 billion in the first half of this year, the Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, citing a draft initial public offering prospectus. That compares to

Restrictions In Paris To Remain In Place On Tuesday After Curfew Brings Calm

Restrictions In Paris To Remain In Place On Tuesday After Curfew Brings Calm

A ban was also issued for any public gatherings from 1800 GMT Tuesday in les Halles Paris police ordered a new curfew for parts of the city for Tuesday overnight, after one the previous night that authorities said resulted in calm being restored following weekend riots and looting. The fresh curfew runs from 2100 GMT

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Curfews Bring Calm to Paris as France Cracks Down on Weekend Rioters

At least 2,400 people were arrested after rioters in cities across France on Saturday clashed with police, set cars on fire, stormed public buildings and engulfed a historic city hall in flames, during nationwide protests against rising living costs and poor conditions in schools. On Sunday evening, small groups set fire to trash bins, bicycles

Latest and Breaking News on NDTV

Reform Or Regime Change? What Global Movements Tell Us About Protest Goals

Whenever thousands of people take to the streets in any corner of the world, the primary fear in the corridors of power is of a coup or regime change. The recent downfall of Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh, the flight of the Rajapaksa family in Sri Lanka, and the political reshuffle in Nepal have further strengthened

Trump 'Frustrated' Over Claims He Is Causing 'Harm' To Ukraine: Marco Rubio

Trump ‘Frustrated’ Over Claims He Is Causing ‘Harm’ To Ukraine: Marco Rubio

Rubio is on a visit to India US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Tuesday that President Donald Trump was “frustrated” by accusations that he had deliberately harmed Ukraine, including claims he ordered intelligence sharing to be halted. “The president is frustrated because, first of all, he doesn’t like to be blamed for things that

Blow to Reform UK motion refugee motion voted down

Blow to Reform UK motion refugee motion voted down

County Hall Chichester. Image: LDRS A call from Reform UK councillors in West Sussex for the county council to withdraw from all voluntary refugee resettlement schemes has been voted down. The motion was tabled by group leader Tim Charters (Southgate & Gossops Green) during a meeting on Friday (October 16), and seconded by Callum Johnson (Ref,

WOL.com Announces Global Launch of Its Real Time World News Platform

WOL.com Announces Global Launch of Its Real Time World News Platform

WOL.COM launches Online World News The platform delivers timely updates about World, Business, Technology, Politics, Lifestyle, and Culture, with a focus on accuracy and international reach ATLANTA, GA, UNITED STATES, October 19, 2026 /EINPresswire.com/ — WOL.com today announced the worldwide launch of its digital news platform providing real time global coverage through a modern, mobile

Trump Says Zelensky Should Get "Somebody Else" To Negotiate To End War

Donald Trump Says Volodymyr Zelensky Should Get Somebody Else To Negotiate To End War

Trump also told reporters that Russia has been “fine” with regards to Ukraine. US President Donald Trump on Monday said he thought someone other than Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy should negotiate on Kyiv’s behalf as it seeks to end the war with Russia. “Maybe it’s time for Zelenskiy to get somebody else to negotiate,” said

Pete Hegseth Makes Surprise Visit To Israel, Meets Netanyahu: Report

Pete Hegseth Meets Netanyahu In Unannounced Visit To Israel: Report

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth last met Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington in July. US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth met with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during an unannounced visit to Israel on Monday, Axios reported, citing two sources with knowledge. The Pentagon and Israel’s embassy in Washington did not immediately respond to requests

New York City police officers are on duty outside the Lotte Palace Hotel during a United Nations General Assembly leaders reception, late Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Saudi Arabia Executes 2 Bangladeshis Over ‘Indecent Acts,’ and Other Mideast News

Saudi Arabia says it has executed 2 Bangladeshi nationals over “indecent acts” inside a mosque in Mecca. Bangladesh said that it hadn’t been informed of the executions beforehand. Meanwhile, Israeli police have arrested 10 suspects in connection with a wave of settler violence, including against a U.S. journalist and European diplomats in the occupied West

FILE PHOTO: CoreWeave logo is seen in this illustration taken July 20, 2026. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo

The AI industry’s gigantic debts are making investors nervous

Credit markets are coming for CoreWeave. The price of a five-year bond issued by the “neocloud”, which rents out data-centre capacity for artificial-intelligence models, has fallen by 16% since July. The bond’s yield is now 15%—a level associated with companies in financial distress—up from 10% in July. The price of credit-default swaps offering insurance against

Pak army officer killed in IED blast

Pak army officer killed in IED blast

Islamabad, A Pakistan Army officer has been killed in an improvised explosive device blast during a security operation in the country’s Balochistan province, authorities said on Monday. Pak army officer killed in IED blast Security forces conducted a series of operations in the Shadi Kaur area in Gwadar and Jattakabad in Kalat district on Sunday

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x