Quarantine in China: why so long and does science back it up?

For example, people entering Beijing must spend 14 days in a hotel, then seven days at home or a hotel, then another seven of “health monitoring”.

In Shenzhen, Hongkongers need to spend 14 days in quarantine then seven more being monitored for symptoms. Arrivals can ask to spend the second half of their quarantine period at home.

Some provinces have longer periods. Travellers to Shenyang, for instance, have to go through 28 days of quarantine in a hotel and then stay at home for another 28 days of health monitoring.

01:51

China steps up zero-tolerance approach to Covid-19 as Delta fears grow ahead of Beijing Olympics

China steps up zero-tolerance approach to Covid-19 as Delta fears grow ahead of Beijing Olympics

What does science say about how long quarantine should be?

The length of quarantine is based on the coronavirus’s incubation period, the time between a person contracting the virus and starting to develop symptoms.

The original Covid-19 strain has an incubation period of around six days, while the Alpha variant has a median period of about three days. The more contagious Delta variant has a four-day median incubation period, according to a study of the outbreak in Guangdong from May to June published in the EClinicalMedicine journal.

According to the Hong Kong Department of Health, most people with Covid-19 develop symptoms within 14 days of contracting the virus, with five days being the most common. 

Critics of the 21-day isolation such as epidemiologist Ben Cowling and virologist Jin Dong-Yan of the University of Hong Kong say there is no evidence to support this arrangement. Cowling has repeatedly said an exit test after 10 days of quarantine is sufficient and 14 days of quarantine is “more than enough”.

Jin said the length of quarantine could be shorter for fully vaccinated individuals.

“Vaccination can shorten the window of virus shedding,” he said, referring to the phenomenon when the virus leaves the infected person through secretions in the nose and mouth. “The vaccinated people, because they have antibodies, they are actually fighting the virus.”

Experts also say the 21-day quarantine at a hotel could raise hygiene concerns, or increase the risk of a person catching the virus at the hotel. Earlier this month, Hong Kong health authorities stepped up measures to curb the transmission of the virus in quarantine hotels after health experts said a man likely caught the more transmissible Delta Plus variant from his neighbour, when both of them opened doors to their room to collect food.
Though rarer, some studies have suggested a small proportion of cases could have incubation periods longer than 14 days. In October, a woman tested positive for Covid-19 on the 26th day after arriving in Hong Kong from the United States, with authorities classifying it as an imported case.

How long is quarantine in other places?

In countries that have chosen to live with Covid-19, there is either no quarantine or the period is short.

In Britain, for example, people who are not fully vaccinated are only required to isolate for 10 days, while those who have had the shots can skip quarantine entirely.

Quarantine measures vary by state and cities in the US. Travellers to New York state and California, for example, have no restrictions, but local authorities encourage travellers to self-quarantine for seven days if they are not fully vaccinated.

Singapore allows fully vaccinated travellers to enter the country without quarantine if they are from certain countries such as Australia, South Korea and the US. Travellers from mainland China, Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan can also enter unvaccinated and only need to self-isolate while waiting for their Covid-19 test result on arrival.

Other countries have stricter measures. Travel to New Zealand without quarantine is only available to those from some Pacific island nations. Other travellers entering the country with a “critical purpose” must be isolated for seven days at a hotel and then at home until they receive their day 9 test results.

Travellers to Taiwan need to spend 14 days in quarantine in a hotel or a group quarantine facility.

02:07

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

How likely is China to shorten its quarantine period soon?

Local governments in China have not announced plans to shorten their quarantine periods. Some, such as Guangzhou, have made isolation measures stricter because of an outbreak that started in October.

The Chinese government has also not said when it will relax border restrictions. But respiratory diseases specialist Zhong Nanshan has said China could reopen if the Covid-19 case fatality rate – the proportion of those infected who die from the disease – is controlled at 0.1 per cent and an infected person infects only an average of 1 to 1.5 people.

The global case fatality rate fell to around 2 per cent in November, according to data from Johns Hopkins University, while countries with high vaccination rates have a much lower case fatality rate.

The case fatality rate of Delta variants for vaccinated people in Britain, for example, is between 0.14 to 0.18 per cent, according to Jin.
Some travellers from Hong Kong, however, are expected to be able to enter mainland China quarantine-free from December, although there will be a limited quota of a few hundred people per day to start with.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Philippe Jordan & Simon Trpčeski

所有集數 您喜歡這個節目嗎? Orchestra dell’Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia:Brahms Double ConcertoSayaka Shoji (violin) | Ettore Pagano (cello)Orchestra dell’Accademia Nazionale di Santa CeciliaThomas Guggeis (conductor)BRAHMSDouble Concerto for Violin and Cello in A minor, Op. 102 (34’)LISZTSymphonic Poem No. 3, S. 97, ‘Les Préludes’ (16’)Richard STRAUSSTod und Verklärung, Op. 24 (25’)Recorded at Auditorium, Parco della Musica, Rome on

Non-local security guard training at Richland Gardens, a residential estate in Kowloon Bay, in April 2026. Photo: Richland Gardens, via Threads.

HK housing estate draws controversy over hiring of non-local security guards

Hong Kong residential estate Richland Gardens has sparked controversy after announcing the hiring of non-local workers as security guards. The owners’ corporation of Richland Gardens – a government-subsidised housing estate in Kowloon Bay – announced on Threads on Monday that its management company was training a group of “non-local security guards,” who started working on

Ballroom or Bunker? Exploring President Trump’s goals with the expansion

WASHINGTON (TNND) — President Donald Trump’s proposed White House ballroom is drawing renewed attention after last weekend’s shooting near the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, with the administration arguing that the project is far more than a venue for state dinners; it is part of a much larger presidential security expansion. WASHINGTON, DC – APRIL 16:

OpenAI reportedly missed revenue targets. Shares of Oracle and these chip stocks are falling

Shares of companies tied to artificial intelligence infrastructure fell Tuesday after a report that OpenAI has fallen short of internal growth expectations, raising fresh questions about whether the pace of spending across the sector is sustainable. Oracle, which has a $300 billion, five-year partnership to supply computing power to OpenAI for AI operations, dropped 4%.

Pixar Takes Over Hong Kong Disneyland This Summer

Pixar Takes Over Hong Kong Disneyland This Summer

Starting this summer and continuing into next year, Hong Kong Disneyland is betting big on Pixar – with a special event this summer and a brand-new experience opening in 2027. What’s Happening: Pixar Summer Fest will be taking over Hong Kong Disneyland beginning June 12, where guests are invited to meet and play with beloved

Chart showing number of notable AI models by geography

China tech startups feel chilling effect after Beijing blocks Manus sale

Beijing’s blocking of Meta’s plan to buy Chinese AI startup Manus is already forcing a rethink among tech entrepreneurs who have ties to both China and the US. The move highlights the intensifying battle between the superpowers for AI dominance, and could factor into a planned summit between the countries’ leaders next month. It deals

Nigel Farage

Reform UK makes local debut while Tories fight off rivals in crunch ballot box test

Reform UK is gearing up to make its debut while Tories fight off rivals in an upcoming ballot box test this Thursday. Voters in Worcestershire will cast their ballot to vote for a new councillor for the Tenbury ward on Malvern Hills District Council after Conservative Andrew Willmott resigned. Last time locals headed to the

Brewery appears to joke about Trump assassination attempt

(TNND) — A Wisconsin brewery with a history of provocative political messaging is facing backlash after appearing to joke about a recent assassination attempt on President Donald Trump. The Minocqua Brewing Company, which is owned by former state Assembly candidate Kirk Bangstad — who is a Democrat — posted on social media that “we almost

Xu Zewei

Kash Patel says Italy trip set up arrest of Chinese national COVID hacker

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! FBI Director Kash Patel says a trip to Italy that raised questions earlier in 2026 helped set the stage for the arrest of a Chinese national accused of hacking U.S. COVID-19 research.  Xu Zewei is now in U.S. custody after what Patel described as a coordinated operation

ASPI’s China Defence Universities Tracker: China–Iran research ties

ASPI’s China Defence Universities Tracker: China–Iran research ties

China and Iran have gradually deepened research ties in dual-use and emerging technologies over the past 15 years, the latest update to ASPI’s China Defence Universities Tracker (CDUT) shows. The scale of this collaboration is limited, but the direct involvement of Iranian government agencies in facilitating joint research with China indicates the strategic nature of

The Best Blue Chip Stock to Buy After This Year’s Market Pullback

Investors who have been in the market for years or decades know to take market pullbacks in stride. But new investors could find market volatility panic-inducing. It’s a great opportunity for beginner investors who might be all-in on artificial intelligence (AI) and hot tech stocks to take a step back and make sure they have

EUR/USD: Cautiously bullish above 1.1700 ahead of FOMC and ECB

EUR/USD: Cautiously bullish above 1.1700 ahead of FOMC and ECB

Overall Bias: The EUR/USD narrative has shifted from bearish to cautiously bullish Key Support: The bullish bias remains firm as long as the price sustains a hold above the critical 1.1700–1.1710 support zone. Tactical Scenarios: Bulls need to defend the 1.1700 area, with targets at 1.1769 and 1.1800; a break below 1.1700 triggers the bearish

Barcelona identify Chelsea star as striker backup plan

The transfer team at La Liga giants Barcelona have earmarked a member of the attacking ranks at Chelsea as a potential summer signing. This comes amid the understanding that the Blaugrana have set their sights on João Pedro. Advertisement Barcelona are of course widely expected to bring in reinforcements at centre-forward with a view to

Lin Daye Conducts Guangzhou Symphony Orchestra

所有集數 您喜歡這個節目嗎? Orchestra dell’Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia:Brahms Double ConcertoSayaka Shoji (violin) | Ettore Pagano (cello)Orchestra dell’Accademia Nazionale di Santa CeciliaThomas Guggeis (conductor)BRAHMSDouble Concerto for Violin and Cello in A minor, Op. 102 (34’)LISZTSymphonic Poem No. 3, S. 97, ‘Les Préludes’ (16’)Richard STRAUSSTod und Verklärung, Op. 24 (25’)Recorded at Auditorium, Parco della Musica, Rome on

Hong Kong’s ‘Special Project’ Targets 7,000 Protesters With Mainland Reeducation Trips

Hong Kong’s government has confirmed it is running a so-called “rehabilitation program” that sends people who were arrested during the 2019 anti-extradition protests, but never charged, on organized trips into mainland China. Roughly 7,000 people are eligible. Hong Kong’s secretary for security Chris Tang calls it the “Special Project.” The program is being rejected by

Elon Musk and Sam Altman Head to Court

Musk alleges that Altman, OpenAI’s CEO, betrayed the founding mission of OpenAI, which the two men co-founded in 2015 as a non-profit organization devoted to developing AI for the benefit of humanity as a whole. On the docket — OpenAI has since restructured into a for-profit company, a move that Musk alleges is a breach

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x