The United Kingdom’s migration experiment with Rwanda did not go well and this is a warning for the EU

As explained by Prime Minister Boris Johnson on the day he presented the plan, the agreement with Kigali had “no limits”: Rwanda would, in principle, have “the capacity to relocate tens of thousands of people over the coming years.” Johnson added that, if the pilot program worked, women and children would be included. The reality, however, has been very different. After investing more than 700 million pounds in it and building ad hoc two centers to house the migrants, only four people were transferred to Rwanda. And not because they were deported there, but because they voluntarily accepted the transfer in exchange for 3,000 pounds each.

The failure of the British experience is not the only precedent that calls into question the European initiative, announced yesterday by five European Union countries – Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece, and the Netherlands – to create the first migrant deportation center outside community borders, in this case, also in Rwanda. In Italy, the courts initially blocked Giorgia Meloni’s plan to expel migrants to Albania.

The Italian case, however, has a second part. After the initial hurdles, Meloni reformulated the agreement with Tirana in March 2025 and converted the Gjader center into a repatriation facility. According to a report by Amnesty International published in August 2026, Italy has transferred more than 570 migrants there since the start of the program. The first 74, intercepted in the Mediterranean and sent to Albania between October 2024 and January 2025 to process their asylum claims there, had to return to Italy after a few days by court order.

However, since April 2025, Rome has been sending adult men there who were already interned in the country and who have a deportation order or a final asylum denial. More than 500 people have reached the Albanian facilities through this route, still far from the initial goal of processing up to 36,000 migrants a year.

An image of the Hope Hostel, in Kigali.

London’s main obstacle was the courts, although there was also criticism from the Anglican Church and, even, from the then Crown Prince Charles of England, who in private described the initiative as “appalling”. But moral considerations and legal barriers do not seem to have stopped the five European partners, who guarantee that the initiative is legal.

Challenges from human rights advocacy organizations and specialized lawyers led to the intervention of the European Court of Human Rights and various British judicial bodies. The first flight, initially planned with 37 people for June 2022, saw the list of deportees reduced successively to seven, four, and one, until it was finally suspended.

Shifting the responsibility

The guarantees of the asylum procedure also generated strong controversy. The plan stipulated that Rwanda would examine the migrants’ requests within a maximum period of three months: those who obtained refugee status could reside in the country, while the rest would be repatriated to their places of origin. Humanitarian organizations warned, however, that the system could facilitate indiscriminate expulsions and expose migrants to abuse in a country with a questioned track record regarding human rights.

In fact, the British government itself had expressed before the United Nations its concern regarding restrictions on civil and political liberties and freedom of the press in Rwanda. A report by a British parliamentary committee on the country went as far as to openly question the democratic nature of Paul Kagame’s regime, who has been in power since 2000.

The deterrent effectiveness of the initiative, one of Johnson’s central arguments at the time of announcing it, was also called into question. The government claimed that the deportations would dismantle the smuggling business and prevent migrants from using the asylum system to stay in the United Kingdom. But boat arrivals continued even on the day the aforementioned first flight to Kigali was scheduled to take place, when more than 300 people landed on British shores.

Furthermore, the program entailed a significant economic cost. London had agreed to an initial payment of 120 million pounds to Rwanda, in addition to the costs of reception and processing of the applications. A parliamentary committee warned that the cost would be equivalent to that of the British asylum system, which questioned the economic advantages of outsourcing its management. Rwanda has claimed more than 100 million pounds in compensation for the breach of the agreement, but the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled last June that the United Kingdom did not have to pay any compensation.

The British experience shows that outsourcing migration control does not curb irregular arrivals, but rather can increase dependence on human trafficking networks. This is what Ahlam Chemlali concludes, a migration researcher and co-director of the Centre for Coercion and Accountability at the University of Aalborg (Denmark). “These centers do not solve the migration problem, but rather shift responsibilities to third countries and make the migrants’ journeys longer, more expensive, and more dangerous,” she asserts in an article published this Tuesday on the academic website The Conversation.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Canada’s 10 best new restaurants worth planning a trip around

Breadcrumb Trail Links Travel Guide Travel Travel Canada Air Canada’s annual ranking puts St. Catharines, Calgary and Winnipeg on the culinary map Published Nov 17, 2026  •  2 minute read Attention to detail and thoughtful composition of flavours is what led Calgary’s Sushi Jun to take second place on Air Canada’s 10 Best New Restaurants list.

Britain’s Prince William and Princess Kate arrive in India for 3-day visit

Britain’s Prince William and Princess Kate arrived in India on Monday for a three-day visit, the first overseas trip together since Kate was diagnosed with cancer in 2024. The U.K. royal couple began their visit in Mumbai and will attend the Earthshot Prize awards ceremony on Tuesday. Founded by William, the annual environmental prize awards

Foo Fighters 2027 UK Stadium Tour: Dates, Presale and Ticket Prices

Few rock bands entertain stadiums quite like Foo Fighters. Dave Grohl and the band boast not just a catalogue of ginormous tunes but a formidable live rep – and the UK is part of their touring plans for 2027. Foo Fighters’ 2027 UK and European stadium tour, which is part of their wider Take Cover

US embassy issues warning to Americans in the UK: ‘Keep a low profile’

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in A security alert issued by the American embassy in London has told US citizens in the UK to “keep a low profile” and stay alert to the possibility of terror

Nine Guangdong yachts apply to visit Hong Kong in first month of southbound scheme

Nine Guangdong-registered yachts have applied to visit Hong Kong in the first month since the southbound yacht arrangement was launched, as industry representatives called for simpler mainland clearance procedures and better facilities in the city to encourage more owners to make the trip. The Marine Department said that as of mid-November, nine Guangdong yachts had

Security Alert: U.S. Embassy London, November 16, 2026

Security Alert: U.S. Embassy London, November 16, 2026 – U.S. Embassy and Consulates in the United Kingdom Skip to main content An official website of the United States government Here’s how you know  Official websites use .gov A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. Secure .gov websites use HTTPS A

Europe Terror Alert: Americans Urged to Stay Vigilant in Broad Warning

A Europe-wide security alert is in place for Americans traveling to the continent this holiday season, with the U.S. Embassy in Bulgaria warning that terrorist attacks could occur with little or no warning. The alert was issued on Monday. It follows a worldwide security alert issued by the U.S. Department of State in July warning

10 World-Famous Christmas Celebrations You Must Visit at Least Once in Your Lifetime – Anamika Mishra

There is something magical about travelling during Christmas. Streets come alive with sparkling lights, beautiful Christmas trees appear in city squares, traditional markets fill the air with festive aromas, and people from different parts of the world come together to celebrate the season. While Christmas is celebrated across the globe, some destinations take the festivities

Home Office tells blind Nigerian woman to go to India

The 67-year-old woman had lived in the UK for 26 years (Picture: In Pictures/Getty Images) A blind Nigerian woman who has lived in the UK for 26 years has been told by the Home Office to go to India for medical treatment, despite never having visited the country. The woman, 67, whose name has been

Eleven years after Chris Singleton lost his mother in the Charleston church shooting, a memorial backed by $25 million in fundraising has opened; he now has a place to visit when he wants to remember her

A permanent memorial honouring nine Black worshippers murdered in a racist attack at a historic church in Charleston, South Carolina, has opened more than 11 years after the shooting. Chris Singleton, whose mother was among those killed, said the new site gives him a place to visit whenever he wants to remember her. The Emanuel

10 Underrated UK Cities American Tourists Normally Miss

Chris Chambers Yorkshire/Shutterstock Beyond London, the United Kingdom consistently rewards adventurous travelers. Sure, you need to check those capital city boxes: Big Ben, Buckingham Palace, the Tower Bridge. But then what? For some American visitors, a few days ticking off London’s famous landmarks, riding a double-decker bus,

Kabaka Pyramid’s Rebel Music US Tour Heads to Bay Area With Venue Change

Kabaka Pyramid’s Bay Area date is still on, just not where fans may have first planned to be. The Jamaican artist told followers on Instagram that his Rebel Music US Tour stop is set for “next wed,” with a venue change but, in his words, “same vibes.” The post tags @longboardbarandvenue, which points to Longboard

US ground stop delays 2 Cathay flights, strands travelers

A rare nationwide ground stop in the United States has delayed two Cathay Pacific flights bound for Hong Kong, leaving passengers facing long waits, missed connections and an uncertain weekend of travel as airlines work to untangle widespread disruption across the trans-Pacific network. Get the latest news straight to your inbox! Two Hong Kong bound

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x