School cell phone bans may boost student well-being—but not test scores, new study suggests

School cell phone bans may boost student well-being—but not test scores, new study suggests

Banning cell phones in schools has been touted as a silver bullet for poor test scores and low student well-being and attendance, but new research suggests the results are more mixed

An over-the-shoulder view of a student using her phone while studying in a high school class.

Willie B. Thomas/Getty Images

Cell phone bans in schools are working—at least as far as keeping kids off their phones during school, according to a new working paper. But the bans, which have been touted by researchers, educators and policymakers as a way to boost children’s attendance and academic achievement and to combat mental health issues and online bullying, aren’t delivering on all those promises, the findings reveal.

In the years since cell phone bans went into effect in schools, students and teachers at those schools have reported higher levels of well-being, but average test scores and attendance records haven’t budged. Perceived levels of online bullying have also not improved, according to the paper.

The research was recently released by a nonprofit called the National Bureau of Economic Research. The study authors looked specifically at schools where kids have been required to keep their smartphones in magnetically sealed pouches that are not unlocked until the end of the school day. They then compared these schools with others that have not enforced pouches—more than 40,000 schools overall between 2019 and 2026. The researchers analyzed schools’ test data, attendance reports, discipline records, GPS data, and student and teacher surveys.


On supporting science journalism

If you’re enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.


As of 2026, about two thirds of U.S. states have passed laws to curb cell phone access in schools—and they are not entirely popular with kids. A recent Pew Research Center survey found that 41 percent of U.S. teens aged 13 to 17 supported banning middle and high school students from using their cell phones during class, while about half totally opposed it. Even fewer supported restricting cell phones for the entire school day—about one in five said phones should be banned all day, including during lunch and between classes, while 73 percent opposed such policies.

In the new paper, the researchers found that when schools first adopted the pouches, suspensions tended to rise, and students’ reported well-being fell—but that these trends didn’t last long and that, with time, discipline leveled out to baseline, and well-being rose.

The analysis has some limitations, the researchers wrote. Test scores and surveys don’t necessarily capture all the outcomes of the phone restrictions. And even in the schools that had been enforcing the pouch system for the longest amount of time, the researchers had no more than three years of postadoption data to consider. And some schools have used other forms of phone restriction that might have different effects than the pouches.

“Evaluating the longer-run impacts of phone restrictions and comparing alternative policy designs are important priorities as schools continue to experiment with approaches to managing digital access,” the researchers wrote.

It’s Time to Stand Up for Science

If you enjoyed this article, I’d like to ask for your support. Scientific American has served as an advocate for science and industry for 180 years, and right now may be the most critical moment in that two-century history.

I’ve been a Scientific American subscriber since I was 12 years old, and it helped shape the way I look at the world. SciAm always educates and delights me, and inspires a sense of awe for our vast, beautiful universe. I hope it does that for you, too.

If you subscribe to Scientific American, you help ensure that our coverage is centered on meaningful research and discovery; that we have the resources to report on the decisions that threaten labs across the U.S.; and that we support both budding and working scientists at a time when the value of science itself too often goes unrecognized.

In return, you get essential news, captivating podcasts, brilliant infographics, can’t-miss newsletters, must-watch videos, challenging games, and the science world’s best writing and reporting. You can even gift someone a subscription.

There has never been a more important time for us to stand up and show why science matters. I hope you’ll support us in that mission.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Daily Market Price Updates and Commentary 17th November 2026

  ICE Futures U.S. Sugar No.11 Contract Settlement (cUS$/lb) Open High Low Last Volume O/I Life High Life Low Mar27 18.17 0.07 ▲ 18.14 18.33 17.97 18.17 55,783 540,886 21.29 14.42 May27 17.60 0.01 ▲ 17.60 17.78 17.44 17.60 24,605 224,913 20.40 14.29 Jul27 17.24 -0.02 ▼ 17.26 17.40 17.11 17.23 15,295 146,817 19.81 14.27

CCTV footage shows a Russian An-12 military aircraft crashing near Yagunovo in Siberia, killing all 19 people on board. (Unsplash Representational image)

CCTV captures Russian military plane crash in Siberia that killed all 19 onboard

CCTV footage has captured the moment a Russian military transport aircraft crashed near the village of Yagunovo in the Kemerovo region of southwestern Siberia on November 17. All 19 people aboard the aircraft died, according to Russia’s Defence Ministry. CCTV footage shows a Russian An-12 military aircraft crashing near Yagunovo in Siberia, killing all 19

Consumer staples stocks benefiting from a powerful rotation as tech gets slammed

Investors continue to find comfort in boring consumer staples stocks as growth expectations for the tech giants driving the AI boom come under closer scrutiny. The S&P 500 (^GSPC) tech sector’s (XLK) forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is currently 17.2 times, its lowest level since 2020, according to data crunched by Duality Research. The S&P 500’s

A Strange Year in the Stock Market

For years now it felt like the only game in town was U.S. large cap growth stocks. That’s changed somewhat in the past few years. Growth stocks have still done fine, of course, what with the AI boom and all. But other areas of the market have come to life. Emerging markets have outperformed. International

The IIHF's website went offline on Tuesday following a reported cyberattack. (X @IIHFHockey)

Ice Hockey Federation website targeted in cyberattack after Russia barred from competing at World Juniors

The International Ice Hockey Federation’s website went offline on Tuesday following a reported cyberattack, which came amid controversy over its decision to exclude Russia from the world junior championship. The IIHF’s website went offline on Tuesday following a reported cyberattack. (X @IIHFHockey) According to the Canadian Press, an image featuring Russian players briefly appeared on

Not Nvidia. Not Alphabet. This Is the AI Stock I’d Buy With the Next Dollar I Invest.

It’s been a strange week in artificial intelligence (AI). With several AI stocks facing investor ire for various reasons. On Nov. 12, Nvidia (NVDA -0.48%) said CEO Jensen Huang had resigned, effective immediately, with CFO Colette Kress stepping in as interim CEO. A day later, Nvidia’s board said it hadn’t even picked a search firm

SPCX Stock In Focus: SpaceX To Reportedly Launch $4B Bond Sale This Week

According to Bloomberg, Goldman Sachs and Apollo Global Management are expected to underwrite the offering. Funds associated with BlackRock and KKR have also made financing commitments Microsoft, Meta and Oracle recently announced plans to raise funds for AI expansion. SpaceX (SPCX) could begin selling bonds worth around $4 billion this week as part of its

Is Avalanche’s New Deal With the New York Stock Exchange a Threat to Hyperliquid?

On Nov. 9, Ava Labs, the developer of Avalanche (AVAX -0.82%), said that its blockchain will be the technology backend for the New York Stock Exchange’s (NYSE) planned new venue for trading tokenized stocks. The new venue will be owned by Intercontinental Exchange (ICE -2.34%), which also owns the NYSE. This new development is both

LVMH: Share transactions disclosure | MarketScreener

Paris, November 17th, 2026 The disclosure of share transactions carried out from November 9th to November 13th, 2026, was sent to the AMF on November 17th, 2026. As required by current law, this document is publically available and can be consulted on the Company’s website (www.lvmh.com) under the section «regulated information». LVMH LVMH Moët Hennessy

Britain’s Prince William and Princess Kate arrive in India for 3-day visit

Britain’s Prince William and Princess Kate arrived in India on Monday for a three-day visit, the first overseas trip together since Kate was diagnosed with cancer in 2024. The U.K. royal couple began their visit in Mumbai and will attend the Earthshot Prize awards ceremony on Tuesday. Founded by William, the annual environmental prize awards

Ipsos: Disclosure of trading in own shares under a share buyback programme (9 to 13 november 2026)

17 November 2026 Disclosure of trading in own shares under a share buyback program Period: From 9 to 13 November 2026 Issuer’s registered name: Ipsos Issuer’s Identification code: 9695002OY2X35E9X8W87 Financial instrument reference: Ordinary shares – ISIN code FR0000073298 Reporting of transactions in aggregated form (per day and per trading venue) Issuer name Issuer Code Transaction

A military An-12 transport aircraft crashed in Russia's Kemerovo region in southwestern Siberia on Tuesday, killing all 17 people on board, Russian media outlet Izvestia reported. (Representative)

17 killed as Russian military plane crashes in Siberia

A military An-12 transport aircraft crashed in Russia’s Kemerovo region in southwestern Siberia on Tuesday, killing all 17 people on board, Russian media outlet Izvestia reported. A military An-12 transport aircraft crashed in Russia’s Kemerovo region in southwestern Siberia on Tuesday, killing all 17 people on board, Russian media outlet Izvestia reported. (Representative) The circumstances

Foo Fighters 2027 UK Stadium Tour: Dates, Presale and Ticket Prices

Few rock bands entertain stadiums quite like Foo Fighters. Dave Grohl and the band boast not just a catalogue of ginormous tunes but a formidable live rep – and the UK is part of their touring plans for 2027. Foo Fighters’ 2027 UK and European stadium tour, which is part of their wider Take Cover

A Serbian military jet crashed on Tuesday northwest of Belgrade, killing the pilot, the defense ministry said.

Serbian military jet crashes, killing pilot: report

A Serbian military jet crashed on Tuesday northwest of Belgrade, killing the pilot, the defense ministry said. The ministry did not immediately give a reason for the crash. The MIG-29 jet crashed around 8:45 a.m. into a field near the town of Stara Pazova, some 30 miles from the Serbian capital, a statement said. A

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x