German court rejects Peruvian farmer’s landmark climate case

Vanessa Buschschlüter

BBC News

Reuters Peruvian farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya poses for a photo in front of Lake Palcacocha. He is wearing a baseball cap and behind him the clear waters of the lake can be seen. Reuters

Saúl Luciano Lliuya says water in Lake Palcacocha has increased, putting his hometown at risk

A court in Germany has rejected a lawsuit brought by a Peruvian farmer against German energy giant RWE in a long-awaited decision.

Saúl Luciano Lliuya had argued that the firm’s global emissions contributed to the melting of glaciers in Peru – threatening his hometown of Huaraz with flooding.

He was seeking €17,000 (£14,250) in compensation – money he said he would use to pay for a flood defence project to protect the city.

However, the higher regional court in the German city of Hamm on Wednesday blocked the case from proceeding further and ruled out any appeals, putting an end to Mr Lliuya’s 10-year legal battle.

RWE said it was not active in Peru and questioned why it was singled out.

It also pointed to its plans to phase out its coal-fired power plants and become carbon neutral by 2040.

In their ruling on Wednesday, judges deemed that the flood risk to the property of Mr Lliuya was not high enough for the case to proceed.

However, in what climate change groups have hailed as a win, they did say that energy companies could be held responsible for the costs caused by their carbon emissions.

While the sum demanded by Mr Lliuya was very low, the case has become a cause celebre for climate change activists, who hope that it will set a precedent for holding powerful firms to account.

The 44-year-old mountain guide and farmer said he had brought the case because he had seen first-hand how rising temperatures were causing glaciers near Huaraz to melt.

He said that as a result, Lake Palcacocha – which is located above the city – now has four times as much water than in 2003 and that residents like him were at risk of flooding, especially if blocks of ice were to break off from Palcacocha glacier and fall into the lake, causing it to overflow.

He alleged that emissions caused by RWE were contributing to the increase in temperature in Peru’s mountain region and demanded that the German firm pay towards building a flood defence.

Mr Lliuya also said that he chose the company because a 2013 database tracking historic emissions from major fossil fuel producers listed the German energy giant as one of the biggest polluters in Europe.

Reuters Mr Lliuya is seen walking in front of Palcacocha Lake, in the Peruvian Andes. Snow-capped glaciers can be seen in the background. Reuters

Mr Lliuya says that as a mountain guide he has seen the effects of climate change at first hand

Mr Lliuya’s original case was rejected by a lower court in Germany in 2015, with judges arguing that a single firm could not be held responsible for climate change.

But in a surprise twist, Mr Lliuya in 2017 won his appeal with judges at the higher regional court, which accepted there was merit to his case and allowed it to proceed.

His lawyers previously argued that RWE was responsible for 0.5% of global CO2 emissions and demanded that the energy firm pay damages amounting to a proportional share of the cost of building a $3.5m-flood defence for Huaraz.

Reuters Mr Lliuya's lawyer, Roda Verheyen, can be seen smiling and embracing a woman outside the court in Hamm.Reuters

Mr Lliuya’s lawyer, Roda Verheyen, celebrated the court’s decision

Germanwatch, an environmental NGO which backed Mr Lliuya’s case, celebrated the court’s ruling saying it had “made legal history”.

“Although the court dismissed the specific claim – finding flood risk to Luciano Lliuya’s home was not sufficiently high – it confirmed for the first time that major emitters can be held liable under German civil law for risks resulting from climate change,” it said in a statement.

The group said it was hopeful that the decision could positively influence similar cases in other countries.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Rugby Premier League: World’s best on board, new league could be gamechanger

‘Crash! Bam! Wallop!’ For the next two weeks, the evening air around the Andheri Sports Complex in Mumbai will be filled with the noise of some of the most athletic sportspeople on the planet crashing into (or ripping past) each other as India witnesses a new addition to its burgeoning basket of franchise leagues: the

Opinion | No way should Hong Kong bail out taxi licence holders

Opinion | No way should Hong Kong bail out taxi licence holders

What do you get when you mix outdated regulation, asset bubbles and an on-demand economy? In Hong Kong’s case, a taxi system on life support – clinging to the hope of million-dollar medallions (taxi licences) while app-based ride-hailing services quietly reshape the market. The government has finally committed to regulating these ride-hailing platforms, promising a

The 12 Premier League players who need a transfer this summer

There is a long list of Premier League players who will make moves this summer. Plenty already have — from Trent Alexander-Arnold’s move to Real Madrid to Liam Delap’s switch to Chelsea. But who are the players crying out for a new club? Who is out of favour? Who needs a fresh start? Here, The

Grand relaunch of Hong Kong club marred by police raid, money laundering arrest

Grand relaunch of Hong Kong club marred by police raid, money laundering arrest

The grand relaunch of a famous Hong Kong nightclub on Saturday night was marred by a police raid that saw at least one person arrested on suspicion of money laundering. Police and Food and Environmental Hygiene Department officers raided Big Boss Generation (BBG) in Tsim Sha Tsui at around 10pm that night, just hours after

New Images Released as More Characters Announced

New images from Zootopia 2 have been released. The first Zootopia movie was released in March 2016. The film was a massive hit for Walt Disney Animation Studios, as it made over a billion dollars at the global box office. That led to a television spin-off show, Zootopia+, that was released in 2022, while a

Hong Kong’s John Lee marks Father’s Day by sharing picture of grandson

Hong Kong’s John Lee marks Father’s Day by sharing picture of grandson

Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu marked Father’s Day this year by sharing a photo on social media of himself with his grandson. Lee’s photo shows the city leader wearing a cap and a polo shirt as he warmly greets his grandson and has the caption: “From father to father’s father, paying tribute to

Big Boss Generation reopening night marred by police raid and money laundering arrest

Big Boss Generation reopening night marred by police raid and money laundering arrest

15th June 2025 – (Hong Kong) On its reopening night, Big Boss Generation (BBG), a transformed multi-functional entertainment venue at the site of the former Big Boss nightclub in Tsim Sha Tsui, became the focus of a coordinated police operation. Law enforcement officers, alongside Food and Environmental Hygiene Department officials, conducted

Hong Kong wants an ecotourism boom, but can its parks handle more visitors?

Hong Kong wants an ecotourism boom, but can its parks handle more visitors?

Amy Zhang is dressed in full sportswear, with sunglasses and a lightweight hiking backpack. She is one of many visiting Hong Kong’s Dragon’s Back following the social media craze in mainland China over “in-depth travels” in the city. “The beautiful merging horizon and skyline make good photos for my friend circle on WeChat and RedNote,”

Dwayne Johnson A24 Movie Breakthrough Eyes Oscar Nominated Director

A24 may have found a director for its upcoming film Breakthrough starring Dwayne Johnson, according to a new report from Deadline. Who is in talks to direct Breakthrough? According to Deadline’s report, Darren Aronofsky is in early conversations to direct the upcoming movie. While a deal is not closed as of yet, it would reunite

Wetland Seasons Bay|保留交樓標準 設計配搭有妙法

平日我們看設計單位都有很多不同風格,好像酒店風、輕奢風、奶油風或簡約風,今集特別些看「示範單位風」。新盤開放的示範單位通常分為三個款式。第一款是發展商必須設置,按交樓標準搭建的「清水房」。裡面規定必須展示與樓書描述一致的單位間隔、樓底高度、用料,以至配備的裝置、家具或家電等,都要與大廈落成後的單位一模一樣。若有出入須清楚列明,所以這款示範單位只有最基本的裝修。有時候發展商為了賣樓推銷,會同時搭建連布置或裝修設計的示範單位。 最簡單直接的是以「清水房」為基礎,單純擺放家具進去,再加入一些基本的裝飾及布置,旨在讓準買家感受內籠添置家具後會怎樣;有些則整個單位重新裝修,甚至改動間隔。例如拆走間隔牆或以其他物料取代牆身,也有機會更換原有配件,好像換掉整個洗臉盆,務求令單位看上去更美觀,又有空間感。雖然每一個樓盤都會有自己的主題及設計概念,但普遍都是想營造既舒適,又華麗及優雅的氛圍,所以不難發現雲石、岩板、玫瑰金鋼、玻璃、壁燈或軟墊等物料,總會在這款示範單位的設計中出現。儘管漂亮,但有些示範單位的設計為求美觀,或會犧牲實際家居的實用性及溫度,尤其是小型單位,設計師也需要平衡。 參觀的設計單位位於天水圍Wetland Seasons Bay,是一個原則兩房開廁加儲物房的平台單位,實用面積428平方呎。業主鍾情示範單位的設計及細節,但又保留廚廁、玄關櫃、木門、地磚及地板等原裝設計。變相今次的裝修要在單位的既有框架下,設計出帶有屋主個人特色,又有裝修示範單位感覺的優雅及華麗。 設計師其中一個辦法,就是運用多款物料來設計客廳兩邊牆身。通常電視牆會被視為客飯廳的焦點,所以著墨都會較多。這裡有前後兩層,再配搭光面岩板及仿木紋板等材質及顏色,令整體很豐富及有層次。另一邊的沙發背牆,很多時候因為呎數的限制,不想客廳感覺很狹窄,都會簡單處理,好像髹油或加上花線。這裡反而在中間很大面積地用上仿石板,左右兩邊配搭仿皮紋膠板,再於上面以金鋼及壁燈點綴,來營造示範單位高雅的氛圍。全屋的裝修費約38萬元,由於沒有太多改動,所以主要花費都是在家具項目上,佔了約28萬元。 延伸閱讀: * Wetland Seasons Bay * 更多樓市影片 * 28Hse App Source link

Tropical Storm Wutip: Hong Kong’s T3 signal to stay in place for early afternoon

Tropical Storm Wutip: Hong Kong’s T3 signal to stay in place for early afternoon

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. New users who download our updated app get a seven-day free trial. A No 3 typhoon warning will remain in force in Hong Kong throughout the early afternoon on Sunday, with local winds expected

Daddy cool: how Hong Kong fathers are building ‘unforgettable’ bonds with kids

Daddy cool: how Hong Kong fathers are building ‘unforgettable’ bonds with kids

Younger generations of Hong Kong dads are increasingly eager to engage more with their children, but often face challenges due to limited time and parenting skills, an NGO has said ahead of Father’s Day on Sunday. Allen Ha Wing-on, co-founder of the DADs Network, said that traditional expectations and busy schedules posed obstacles for local

Matthew McConaughey Reunites With True Detective Creator for Mike Hammer Movie

Matthew McConaughey and True Detective creator Nic Pizzolatto are reuniting for a new Mike Hammer movie. McConaughey played Detective Rustin “Rust” Cohle alongside Woody Harrelson as Detective Martin “Marty” Hart in the first season of HBO’s True Detective show, which premiered in January 2014. The show earned by McConaughey and Harrelson Emmy nominations for Outstanding

Group tour prices from Hong Kong drop 10% as tourists opt for alternatives to Japan

Group tour prices from Hong Kong drop 10% as tourists opt for alternatives to Japan

Hong Kong travel agencies have launched cheaper outbound group tours this summer, driven by increased flight capacity amid a shift in tourists’ preference away from Japan due to increased earthquake concerns. Several tour operators have reported that prices for their summer group tours are either lower or have remained stable, adding that popular destinations include

Italy to appoint Gennaro Gattuso as Luciano Spalletti replacement, says Gianluigi Buffon

Italy will appoint former midfielder Gennaro Gattuso as their new head coach, according to Gianluigi Buffon. Former shot stopper Buffon, who is now the head of a delegation of the Italian football federation, said Gattuso was set to be appointed as Luciano Spalletti’s replacement.  Spalletti was sacked earlier this week, after winning just 12 and

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x