ChatGPT action dolls: What are the concerns?

Liv McMahon & Imran Rahman-Jones

Technology reporters

Robert Timothy/BBC/ChatGPT On the left, a picture of Zoe. She is smiling. She has shoulder-length blonde hair, a blue jacket and a silver necklace. On the right, an image generated using ChatGPT of a doll-like version of her. The doll has the same clothes and necklace - but has morphed her dark eyes into a light green, and darkened her hair.Robert Timothy/BBC/ChatGPT

Left: BBC technology editor Zoe Kleinman. Right: Her AI-generated action figure

When scrolling through social media, you may have recently seen friends and family appearing in miniature.

It’s part of a new trend where people use generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPT and Copilot to re-package themselves – literally – as pocket-sized dolls and action figures.

It has taken off online, with brands and influencers dabbling in creating their mini-me.

But some are urging people to steer clear of the seemingly innocent trend, saying fear of missing out shouldn’t override concerns about AI’s energy and data use.

How does the AI doll generator work?

It may sound complicated, but the process is simple.

People upload a picture of themselves to a tool like ChatGPT, along with written prompts that explain how they want the final picture to look.

These instructions are really important.

They tell the AI tool everything it is meant to generate, from the items a person wants to appear with to the kind of packaging they should be in – which includes mimicking the box and font of popular toys like Barbie.

Allow Instagram content?

This article contains content provided by Instagram. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read  and  before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

Many online will then personalise it further with their name, job and clothing choices.

Though it does not always work, and many have also shared some of the amusing mistakes the tools made, where the action dolls look nothing like them.

Like other generative AI tools, image generators are also prone to making things up, and may make assumptions about how someone should look.

And it’s not just regular people using it – the trend has been seized upon by a wealth of brands online including beauty company Mario Badescu and even Royal Mail.

Allow Twitter content?

This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read  and  before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

What’s the appeal?

Trends come and go – but by their very nature can make people feel compelled to take part to avoid missing out.

“Generative AI makes it easier and quicker for people to create and jump on trends,” says Jasmine Enberg, principal social media analyst at eMarketer.

She said the technology had made it quicker and easier to make online content, which may have the unexpected effect of quickening the pace at which other social media users get annoyed by it.

But she believe AI-driven trends will become a more regular appearance on our feeds “as the tech becomes a more regular part of our digital lives”.

What are the big concerns?

But while its light-hearted nature may have drawn people to it, the trend has drawn criticism from some concerned about its environmental impact.

Professor Gina Neff of Queen Mary University London told the BBC ChatGPT is “burning through energy”, and the data centres used to power it consume more electricity in a year than 117 countries.

“We have a joke in my house that every time we create one of these AI memes, it kills a tree,” said Lance Ulanoff, US editor of TechRadar, in an article about the trend.

“That’s hyperbole, of course, but it’s safe to say that AI content generation is not without costs, and perhaps we should be thinking about it and using it differently.”

People have also highlighted concerns copyrighted data may have been used to create the technology which generates images without paying for it.

“ChatGPT Barbie represents a triple threat to our privacy, our culture and our planet,” said Ms Neff.

“While the personalisation might feel nice, these systems are putting brands and characters into a blender with no responsibility for the slop that emerges.”

And Jo Bromilow, director of social and influencer at PR and creative agency MSL UK, asks: “is a cute, funny result really worth it?”

“If we’re going to really use AI properly, we have to set guardrails around how we use it conscientiously,” she said.

Testing the AI doll trend

By Zoe Kleinman, BBC technology editor

I started by finding a suggested prompt online – a list of instructions to enter into the AI tool in order for it to generate the image.

You have to upload your own selfie with your prompt and you also have to be very specific about what you want, including a list of which accessories you’d like included and what colour you want the box to be.

ChatGPT An image generated using ChatGPT shows a doll-like version of Zoe Kleinman, wearing a navy skirt suit and white and blue check top. She is surrounded by accessories including a phone, microphone, camera and notebook. Text at the top of the packaging says "Zoe Kleinman" alongside her job title - "technology editor".ChatGPT

I found it took some time to perfect a pocket-sized and plastic-packaged version of myself

When it came to providing my job title, my first attempt was declined because I included BBC News and was told this violated content policy – I think because currently the BBC does not allow ChatGPT to use its output.

Once you do get an image you’re likely to want to tweak it further; my first attempt was too cartoon-like.

The following, more realistic version made me look considerably older than I am, then too child-like, and I gave up in the end trying to get it to use my actual eye-colour, which kept defaulting back to blue (mine are a blend of hazel and green).

It took a couple of minutes to generate each version and overall the process was slower than I would have liked, potentially because of its popularity.

It did start to feel like a lot of work for a passing trend, and it isn’t perfect – my doll is expanding out far beneath the supposed packaging.

But more importantly, somewhere in a data centre some hot computer servers were toiling away to make Action Figure Zoe.

They almost certainly could have been put to work on worthier causes.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Why Apple is stuck in tariff tussle

Why Apple is stuck in tariff tussle

Annabelle Liang Business reporter Getty Images To leave or not to leave? China, home to more than a billion consumers, is Apple’s second-largest market Every iPhone comes with a label which tells you it was designed in California. While the sleek rectangle that runs many of our lives is indeed designed in the United States,

Anxiety on US college campuses as foreign students deported

Anxiety on US college campuses as foreign students deported

Brandon Drenon and Robin Levinson-King BBC News, Washington DC and Boston BBC For the last few weeks, many foreign students living in the US have watched as a sequence of events has repeated itself on their social media feeds: plain-clothes agents appearing unannounced and hauling students off in unmarked cars to detention centres. Those taken

Hopes for Iran nuclear talks tempered by threats and mixed messages

Hopes for Iran nuclear talks tempered by threats and mixed messages

Parham Ghobadi BBC Persian EPA As Iran and the United States hold a second round of high-stakes nuclear talks in Rome, hopes for de-escalation are being tempered by mounting military threats and mixed messages. US President Donald Trump reminds Tehran nearly every day of its options: a deal or war. He has previously said Israel

Harvard–Trump row over antisemitism letter may have stemmed from a mistake: Report

Harvard–Trump row over antisemitism letter may have stemmed from a mistake: Report

A dramatic confrontation between Harvard University and the Trump administration over antisemitism policies may have stemmed from a mistaken letter, according to a New York Times report citing multiple sources familiar with the situation.Harvard received a letter on April 11 from the White House’s antisemitism task force, containing a series of demands about hiring, admissions,

Sen Van Hollen says deported man 'traumatised'

Sen Van Hollen says deported man ‘traumatised’

Kwasi Gyamfi Asiedu BBC News Watch: US senator Hollen says his ‘principle mission’ was to meet Ábrego García A Maryland man who the Trump administration mistakenly deported to El Salvador has been moved to a new prison, US Senator Chris Van Hollen has said. The Democratic senator was speaking after returning from El Salvador where

US Supreme Court halts deportation of Venezuelans under wartime law

US Supreme Court halts deportation of Venezuelans under wartime law

Reuters Venezuelans who the Trump administration says are gang members have been deported to the Terrorism Confinement Center in El Salvador The US Supreme Court has ordered the Trump administration to pause the deportation of accused Venezuelan gang members under an 18th-century wartime law. A civil liberties group is suing the administration over planned deportations

Trump ditched a 2015 nuclear pact between Iran and six powers during his first term in 2018 and reimposed crippling sanctions on Tehran.(File/AFP)

Iran, US to hold talks in Rome in bid to reach nuclear deal | World News

Iran and the United States will hold a new round of nuclear talks in Rome on Saturday to resolve their decades-long standoff over Tehran’s atomic aims, under the shadow of President Donald Trump‘s threat to unleash military action if diplomacy fails. Trump ditched a 2015 nuclear pact between Iran and six powers during his first

Demonstrators rally in a protest organized by the City of Cambridge calling on Harvard leadership to resist interference at the university by the federal government in Massachusetts, on April 12, 2025.(File/REUTERS)

Harvard vs Trump row was triggered by a ‘mistake’? What NYT report says | World News

Harvard, one of the US’ most prestigious higher education institutions, found itself in a dramatic standoff with the Trump administration after it received a letter last week detailing the latter’s demands on the changes it expects in the university. Demonstrators rally in a protest organized by the City of Cambridge calling on Harvard leadership to

US President Donald Trump during a swearing-in ceremony for Mehmet Oz, administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Friday, April 18, 2025. The Senate confirmed surgeon and TV star Mehmet Oz to lead the agency on April 3.(Bloomberg)

Trump’s Oval Office press briefing cut short after young girl faints | World News

A question-and-answer session with US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office was brought to an immediate halt on Friday (local time) after a young girl fainted, as per New York Post. US President Donald Trump during a swearing-in ceremony for Mehmet Oz, administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, in the Oval

Russia jails 19-year-old activist for quoting Ukrainian poet, criticizing war

Russia jails 19-year-old activist for quoting Ukrainian poet, criticizing war

A court in St. Petersburg sentenced 19-year-old Darya Kozyreva to two years and eight months in a penal colony on April 18 for allegedly “discrediting” the Russian army, including by sticking a quote from a Ukrainian poem onto a monument. Kozyreva was arrested on Feb. 24, 2024, after she affixed a verse from Taras Shevchenko’s

US has preliminary plan to monitor ceasefire in Ukraine, WSJ reports

US has preliminary plan to monitor ceasefire in Ukraine, WSJ reports

The U.S. shared a draft concept for monitoring a potential ceasefire in Ukraine with European and Ukrainian officials in Paris, the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported on April 18, citing an unnamed Western official. The draft concept was reportedly shared during meetings in Paris on April 17, where European, Ukrainian, and U.S. officials gathered to

Trump Zelensky Putin

Trump Admin Prepared to Recognize Crimea as Russian Territory: Report

The Trump administration is poised to recognize Crimea as Russian territory as part of a broader peace deal to bring an end to the Russia-Ukraine war, Bloomberg reported Friday, citing people familiar with the matter. Newsweek reached out to the White House and State Department for comment via email on Friday. Why It Matters Russia

Forgotten Indian explorer who uncovered an ancient civilisation

Forgotten Indian explorer who uncovered an ancient civilisation

Cherylann Mollan BBC News, Mumbai Alamy Rakhaldas Banerjee is credited with making one of the most important discoveries in world history An Indian archaeologist, whose career was marked by brilliance and controversy, made one of the world’s greatest historical discoveries. Yet he remains largely forgotten today. In the early 1900s, Rakhaldas Banerjee (also spelled Banerji)

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x