Donald Trump Is Crashing the Economy, but Wall Street Is Afraid to Speak Out

Everyone knows Trump is messing up, but fear and greed prevent resistance.

President-elect Donald Trump rings the opening bell on the trading floor of the New York Stock Exchange on December 12, 2024, in New York City.(Spencer Platt / Getty Images)

Normally, it’s a mistake to blame the fluctuations of the stock market on the actions of just one person—even if they are president of the United States. But there is nothing normal about the Trump era. The stock market is in a tizzy, and the fault is not hard to find: Donald Trump. The S&P 500 is down 10.1 percent from its peak a month ago, which means technically we’re in a “correction.” If this slide continues on its current trajectory, it won’t be long before the correction turns into an outright crash, bringing in its wake a recession.

In 1929, at the start of the stock market crash that inaugurated the Great Depression, Variety ran the famous headline: “WALL STREET LAYS AN EGG.” It’s possible now to imagine the sequel: “DONALD TRUMP LAYS AN EGG.”

This economic turmoil is due to two factors: Trump’s erratic policy shifts and Wall Street’s initial misjudgment about Trump. When Trump won his second presidential term in November, Wall Street enjoyed a strong rally because it expected Trump to govern as he did in his first term. In 2017, Trump came into office talking like a radical economic populist—but his actual performance was as a standard big-business Republican, more interested in tax cuts and deregulation than industrial policy or empowering workers. True, Trump did initiate a new trade war with China (a policy Joe Biden continued) and renegotiated NAFTA (now rebranded the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement or USMCA).

But both changes were less revolutionary than they seemed. The move toward seeing China as an economic threat had already started under Barack Obama; and USMCA is basically a cosmetic change of NAFTA. In other words, both policies were part of a longer continuity. Beyond that, Trump often relied on standard Republican businessmen like Federal Reserve chairman Jerome Powell and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, both avatars of the stability of well-entrenched capitalism. On foreign policy, Trump’s reliance on military men like John Kelly and Mark Milley made sure he didn’t stray too far from the national security consensus either. True, Trump’s White House was a hothouse of intrigue and infighting, but in terms of policies it was much more like a conventional Republican administration than anyone had expected.

Anticipating Trump 2.0 to be a repeat of Trump 1.0, Wall Street looked forward to another round of tax cuts and deregulation, with the threat of a new trade war viewed as largely rhetorical. Unfortunately, Trump and his circle had been radicalized by being out of office. Trump seems to have decided that for his second term as president, he really was going to live up to the MAGA agenda of protectionism and foreign policy unilateralism.

Instead of Steven Mnuchin, Trump’s main economic adviser now is Elon Musk—a product not of blue-chip Wall Street but of swashbuckling Silicon Valley. Musk, now tasked with gutting the administrative state, came from a world where disrupting entrenched practices and government/business synergy are seen as the keys to wealth. Suddenly, acne-infested Sanford students—some of them literal teenagers—were in charge of slashing government agencies.

Current Issue


Cover of April 2025 Issue

Trump’s Secretary of Commerce, Howard Lutnick, shares his boss’s passion for kicking-and-biting tariff fights. The United States suddenly found itself in a series of tussles with Canada, Mexico, China, and the European Union. These trading partners also expected a return to the transactional Trump of the first term and were startled to discover that this time he’s really committed, although erratically so, to trade wars. The pattern over the past few weeks is for Trump to raise tariffs—and then start lowering them when met with retaliation and when the stock market sinks.

As The New York Times reports, European officials were shocked when Trump turned out not to be “transactional” but simply irrational:

As a tit-for-tat trade war kicks into gear, Europe is facing a difficult reality. It is not clear to many European officials what exactly Mr. Trump wants. Tariffs are sometimes explained by administration officials as an effort to level the playing field, but they are also cited as a tool for raising money for U.S. coffers to pay for tax cuts, or floated as a way to punish the E.U. for its regulation of technology companies.

Trump’s incoherent policy, which shifts wildly from day to day, is spooking Wall Street. Another New York Times article reports that the current stock market slide is motivated by “investors’ growing pessimism about the whipsawing policy pronouncements coming from Washington over the past few weeks. On-again, off-again tariffs and mass layoffs of federal workers have fomented unease on Wall Street.”

Wall Street might be uneasy, but it is also, so far, remaining quiet. A major feature of Trump’s second term is not only a much more radical set of policies but also a pervasive fear in many institutions of offending the president, who has shown every inclination to use both his bully pulpit and the instruments of state power to punish perceived enemies.

On Wednesday, The Wall Street Journal reported, “How business leaders talk about the Trump administration in private has been markedly different than what they are game to say in public.”

The newspaper cited a recent meeting of a Yale CEO Caucus attended by such high rollers as JPMorgan Chase’s Jamie Dimon, billionaire Michael Dell, and Pfizer’s Albert Bourla. According to Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, a professor at the Yale School of Management who participated in the private meeting, “There was universal revulsion against the Trump economic policies. They’re also especially horrified about Canada.”

Despite these private worries, these CEOs are apparently not willing to voice public rebukes of Trump. According to The Wall Street Journal, “asked how much the stock market would need to decline for them to speak out collectively, 44% said it would have to fall 20%. Another 22% said stocks would have to fall 30% before they would take a stand.”

This silence is partly due to political agreement with the rest of Trump’s economic agenda—particularly tax cuts and deregulation. It’s also due to cowardice, as “they worry public criticism will make them a target of the president’s bully pulpit.”

The self-censorship of Wall Street is of a piece with the larger failure of the American elite in the Trump era. Institution after institution—both political parties, the media, the academy—continue to surrender to Trump despite expressing private concerns about the dangers of his policy.

The only hope for resistance to Trump comes not from the elite but from the people. Voters are just as worried about Trump’s mishandling of the economy as Wall Street is. There seems to be a sea change in public opinion. Because of robust job growth in his first term, Trump has usually been rated highly as an economic manager. This is no longer the case. On Wednesday, Politico reported, “When asked about how Trump is handling the economy, 56 percent of adults said they disapprove and 44 said they approved, according to a CNN/SSRS poll released Wednesday morning.”

The public anger at Trump’s economic policy can be seen in town halls, where voters berate Republican lawmakers for complicity and Democratic lawmakers for cowardice. It can also be seen in the large crowds Senator Bernie Sanders is drawing in rallies against Trump. The open question is how long it will take for the Democratic Party as a whole to start following Sanders’s lead.

Wall Street will never be at the forefront of resisting Trump, which means the job falls to the people themselves—and any politician brave enough to take up the fight.


Donald Trump’s cruel and chaotic second term is just getting started. In his first month back in office, Trump and his lackey Elon Musk (or is it the other way around?) have proven that nothing is safe from sacrifice at the altar of unchecked power and riches.

Only robust independent journalism can cut through the noise and offer clear-eyed reporting and analysis based on principle and conscience. That’s what The Nation has done for 160 years and that’s what we’re doing now.

Our independent journalism doesn’t allow injustice to go unnoticed or unchallenged—nor will we abandon hope for a better world. Our writers, editors, and fact-checkers are working relentlessly to keep you informed and empowered when so much of the media fails to do so out of credulity, fear, or fealty.

The Nation has seen unprecedented times before. We draw strength and guidance from our history of principled progressive journalism in times of crisis, and we are committed to continuing this legacy today.

We’re aiming to raise $25,000 during our Spring Fundraising Campaign to ensure that we have the resources to expose the oligarchs and profiteers attempting to loot our republic. Stand for bold independent journalism and donate to support The Nation today.

Onward,

Katrina vanden Heuvel

Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Jeet Heer



Jeet Heer is a national affairs correspondent for The Nation and host of the weekly Nation podcast, The Time of Monsters. He also pens the monthly column “Morbid Symptoms.” The author of In Love with Art: Francoise Mouly’s Adventures in Comics with Art Spiegelman (2013) and Sweet Lechery: Reviews, Essays and Profiles (2014), Heer has written for numerous publications, including The New Yorker, The Paris Review, Virginia Quarterly Review, The American Prospect, The GuardianThe New Republic, and The Boston Globe.

More from
Jeet Heer Jeet Heer Illustration


How Covid Sickened the National Psyche

While the US was a troubled nation long before the coronavirus, our failure to treat the pandemic as an enduring emergency helped birth this nasty moment.

Jeet Heer


Elon Musk at the first Trump cabinet meeting.

The president’s narcissistic management style is at the root of cabinet infighting.

Jeet Heer


Democrats protest with signs (“Medicaid,” “Musk”) as President Donald Trump addresses a joint session of Congress in the Capitol building’s House chamber in Washington, DC, on March 4, 2025.

The flailing and unpopular party elite needs to be replaced with fighting economic populists.

Jeet Heer


President Donald Trump addresses a joint session of Congress at the US Capitol on March 4, 2025, in Washington, DC. Vice President JD Vance and Speaker of the House Mike Johnson applaud behind him.

The president understands that politics never stops. Democrats should do the same.

Jeet Heer


Art Spiegelman, “Self-Portrait With Maus Mask,” 1989.

The creator of Maus has learned that the past is always present.

Jeet Heer


Tech billionaire Elon Musk speaks live via a video transmission during the election campaign launch rally of the far-right Alternative for Germany party on January 25, 2025, in Halle, Germany.

Trump’s most important adviser is promoting racist parties all over the world.

Jeet Heer




Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

What’s the matter with Tesla?

Flagging global sales and Elon Musk’s increasingly outspoken political activities are combining to rock the value of Tesla. Shares in the once-trillion-dollar company saw their worst day in five years this week. Year to date, Tesla’s stock has plunged 36% — though it is still up by some 54% over the past 12 months. For

US economic slowdown fears escalate as trade war and debt woes weigh on markets

The US economy is facing increasing fears of a slowdown, with stock markets spiralling downward amid growing concerns over President Donald Trump’s escalating trade war. The Nasdaq Composite has entered correction territory, falling more than 10% from recent highs, while the S&P 500 teeters on the edge of the same level. The Dow Jones Industrial

Tariffs got you down? How to substitute European wines for American imitators

New York CNN  —  Scotch and Irish whiskey aren’t the only alcohols that will feel the pain of a 200% tariff on European-made products — so will your favorite bottles of Bordeaux and Chianti. Wine, which already dealt with an 8% drop in US sales last year, was hit with another blow this week when

Stock Correction: What Could Go Right After Tariff-Fueled Wipeout

The stock market has been hammered by tariff worries but a handful of catalysts could spark a turnaround. The stock market has been badly hurt by President Donald Trump’s trade war so far, but one Wall Street research firm says there are potential catalysts on the horizon that could help turn the situation around for

Trump’s ‘America First’ policies are boosting stock markets overseas

The STOXX Europe 600 index, which tracks hundreds of companies across 17 European countries, is up 7.7% so far this year. Germany’s DAX index has risen more than 15%, and the CAC 40 in Paris is up around 9%. Across the English Channel, London’s FTSE 100 is up 5.6%. The U.S.-based S&P 500, by contrast,

5 takeaways from what happened in Trump’s Washington this week : NPR

President Trump speaks to the press as he meets with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, on Thursday. Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images hide caption toggle caption Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images We’ll be recapping what you need to know every Friday morning for the

U.S. stock market loses $5 trillion in value amid Trump tariffs

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Democrats need to focus on fighting ‘real danger’ which is Trump-Musk axis: Sen. Whitehouse 06:13 Dr. Oz refuses to rule out cuts to Medicaid in confirmation hearing 02:34 ‘Anti-immigrant’: Ex-lawmaker slams Trump’s Guantanamo Bay migrant plan 09:36 ‘Every Democrat agrees’

The S&P 500 Just Hit Correction Territory. History Says the Stock Market Will Do This Next (Hint: It May Surprise You)

U.S. stocks have fallen sharply in recent weeks as the Trump administration began imposing tariffs on foreign trading partners. Investors unnerved by the potential consequences of the burgeoning trade war have rotated away from domestic equities, particularly those in the consumer discretionary and technology sectors. As of March 13, the benchmark S&P 500 (^GSPC 2.13%)

Why it might get worse for US stocks

Unlock the White House Watch newsletter for free Your guide to what the 2024 US election means for Washington and the world One of the many notable things about the beating under way in US stock markets is that US government bonds are not really picking up the slack. This is not a good sign.

The Chaos Economy – The Atlantic

Produced by ElevenLabs and News Over Audio (Noa) using AI narration. Listen to more stories on the Noa app. Americans hold all sorts of views on tariffs. Some are opposed on free-market grounds. Others are in favor for reasons of national security or to bring back American manufacturing. Those debates are part of a normal

Wall Street rallies but ends with fourth straight losing week

By STAN CHOE AP Business Writer Wall Street rallies to its best day in months, but that’s not enough to salvage its losing week Updated: 4:17 PM EDT Mar 14, 2025 OTHER POLICIES MADE BY PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP HAVE CAUSED SOME UNCERTAINTY AND FEAR FOR THE STOCK MARKET. SO HERE TO TALK ABOUT IT IS

Trump’s Breaking Point Could Come Soon, Analyst Tells BI

Good morning. Have you ever had a paintball gun let loose on your vehicle? No? You must not own a Cybertruck then. BI spoke with 10 Cybertruck owners about what it’s like driving the most controversial vehicle in the world. In today’s big story, we’re looking at when the stock market sell-off could force President

US stocks rebound as government shutdown fears recede

Stay informed with free updates Simply sign up to the US equities myFT Digest — delivered directly to your inbox. Wall Street stocks rallied on Friday at the end of a volatile week of trading as hopes grew that the US government will avoid a costly shutdown. The blue-chip S&P 500, which on Thursday fell

Trump’s 200% tariffs could have an unlikely winner — beer brewers

A twelve pack of Budweiser sits on a shelf for sale at a convenience store in New York City. Drew Angerer | Getty Images U.S. President Donald Trump’s threat to impose 200% tariffs on alcohol from Europe would serve a major blow to drinks makers on the continent, but it could have one unlikely beneficiary

The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq fell into a ‘correction.’ What’s that?

A tour bus passes the Wall Street bull in the financial district January 22, 2007 in New York City. – Image: Spencer Platt / Staff (Getty Images) Stock markets took another hit on Thursday, with several key benchmarks slipping into correction territory — a sign that Wall Street may be losing momentum in the early

恒指收市升497點 科指升2.3% 成交增 北水流入減 長和跌6.3% (16:36) – 20250314 – 即時財經新聞

大市成交增24%,升至2906億元,北水交易成交額(包括買入及賣出交易)亦較上日增29.07%,創近一周高,不過淨流入金額則減少20%。北水交易成交額佔香港市場成交額比率增至23.24%,創2月27日後高。 港股創一周最大升幅,國指創一周高,指曾升穿24000點。全周計,三大指數均下跌。 長和(0001)曾跌最多6.78%,是2022年9月26日後最大跌幅,當日跌幅為7.42%。低見46.05元,是3月5日44.4元後最低。收市跌6.3%,報46.25元,是3月4日後收市新低,當日報38.65元。連續第3日陰燭,對上一次連續第3日陰燭是1月6日。成交金額增513.45%,至28.32億元,是3月6日後最多,當日達45.23億元。 恒指今早高開190點,高位升650點,低位跌8點,高低波幅659點。上升股份比例為45.79%,下跌為24.25%,無升跌為29.95%。 恒指收市升497點或2.12%,報23959點,大市成交金額2906億元,較上日增加24.28%,是3月11日3070.34億元成交後最多;國指升237點或2.75%,報8877點。恒生科技指數收報5880點,升2.31%。 藍籌股成交金額1456.89億元,佔大市成交50.13%;科指成份股成交金額855.07億元,佔大市成交29.42%;國指成份股成交金額1264.52億元,佔大市成交43.51%。 24隻雙櫃台股,總成交1.24億元人民幣,相當於約1.33億港元,佔大市成交的0.05%。 窩輪及牛熊證成交金額增加15.52%,至204.64億元,佔大市成交7.04%。牛熊證成交金額108.12億元,增加25.49%;窩輪成交金額96.51億元,增加6.08%。 藍籌65隻升,18隻下跌,0隻無升跌。藥明生物(2269)升14.38%,收報26.65元,是升幅最大的藍籌,長和(0001)跌6.38%,收報46.25元,是跌幅最大的藍籌, 恒生科技指數成份股26隻升,3隻下跌,1隻無升跌。升幅最大的是海爾智家(6690)收報26.45元,升6.01%;跌幅最大的是蔚來(9866)收報36.75元,跌6.13%。 恒指曾跌穿10天線(23673.18點),下試20天線(23407.36點)。科指曾跌穿10天線(5826.23點)、20天線(5766.17點)。 北水南下合計淨流入43.46億元,較上日減少20.48%,連續第3日流入,累計流入360.24億元,對上一次連續3日淨流入是3月7日。北水本月累計流入971.63億元,按月減少36.4%,金額是2024年12月後新低,連續第21個月流入。北水交易成交額(包括買入及賣出交易)1351.13億元,較上日增29.07%,佔香港市場成交額由上日的22.38%增至23.24%。 三大指數表現 恒指曾升最多2.77%,是3月6日後最大升幅,當日升幅為3.46%。高見24113.53點,是3月10日24292.8點後最高。收市報23959.98點,是3月7日後收市新高,當日報24231.3點。 科指曾升最多3%,是3月6日後最大升幅,當日升幅為5.77%。高見5920.03點,是3月12日6075.31點後最高。今日收市報5880.78點,是3月11日後收市新高,當日報5967.23點。 國指曾升最多3.43%,是3月6日後最大升幅,當日升幅為3.78%。高見8937.06點,是3月7日9083.51點後最高。今日收市報8877.99點,是3月7日後收市新高,當日報8914.03點。 一周表現 恒指本周累跌1.12%或271點,跌幅是2月28日後最大,當時收市跌幅為2.29%;本周表現最佳的是藥明生物(2269),累升12.21%,其次為比亞迪(1211)及紫金礦業(2899),分別升8.61%及6.88%。而表現最差的是聯想(0992),累跌8.08%,其次為九龍倉置業(1997)及中芯國際(0981),分別跌7.67%及7.51%。 國指本周累跌0.4%或36點,跌幅是2月28日後最大,當時收市跌幅為2.88%;本周表現最佳的是比亞迪(1211),累升8.61%,其次為紫金(2899)及農行(1288),分別升6.88%及4.86%。而表現最差的是聯想(0992),累跌8.08%,其次為中芯國際(0981)及申洲國際(2313),分別跌7.51%及7.46%。 科指本周累跌2.59%或156點,跌幅是2月28日後最大,當時收市跌幅為4.97%;本周表現最佳的是蔚來(9866),累升9.21%,其次為海爾智家(6690)及小鵬(9868),分別升2.92%及2.33%。而表現最差的是地平線機器人-W(9660),累跌16.7%,其次為金山軟件(3888)及金蝶(0268),分別跌9.56%及8.68%。 午後消息股表現 艾德韋宣(9919):AI設計團隊有效縮短提案周期40%。收報0.91元,升1.11%。 今早及隔晚消息股表現 花旗:呼和浩特育兒補貼政策超預期。中國飛鶴(6186)創52周高,見6.99元,收報6.86元,升15.68%。 蒙牛乳業(2319)收報19.8元,升9.03%。 其他 錦欣生殖(1951)收報3.57元,升41.67%。 好孩子國際(1086)創52周高,見1.38元,收報1.33元,升25.47%。 澳優(1717)收報2.44元,升12.96%。 小米(1810)擬今年在日本開設5至10家「小米之家」。收報53.85元,升1.89%。 俄鋁(0486)全年多賺1.8倍 曾升逾5%。收報5.11元,跌0.39%。 中國飛機租賃(1848)出售6架連租約飛機 曾升逾4%。收報3.73元,升2.47%。 友邦(1299)全年新業務價值增18% 遜預期 跌逾4% 近5個月最大跌幅。收報61.25元,跌2.47%。 長和(0001)售港口,港澳辦轉載質疑文章,據報交易未知會中央,賣港口存暗湧。收報46.25元,跌6.38%。 多間公司最快今日布業績,績前表現如下,理想(2015)收報113.2元,升2.35%。 宏橋(1378)收報15.06元,升1.89%。 中信資源(1205)收報0.35元,升1.45%。 法拉帝(9638)收報22.45元,跌2.81%。 華潤建材科技(1313)收報1.74元,升3.57%。 金利來集團(0533)收報1.46元,無升跌。 和記電訊香港(0215)收報0.98元,跌1.01%。 華大酒店(0201)收報0.075元,跌1.32%。 彩星集團(0635)收報0.52元,無升跌。 中石化煉化工程(2386)收報6.05元,升0.33%。 港華智慧能源(1083)收報3.28元,跌0.3%。 東方海外(0316)去年多賺近九成達25.77億美元,每股末期息大增8倍至1.32美元。收報112.4元,跌0.35%。 九倉(0004)香港碼頭吞吐量跌6%,吳天海:國際船運重組,香港成輸家。九倉吳天海:目前間接投資內地住宅為主,寫字樓供應仍然過剩。收報18.74元,跌3.4%。 微博(9898)去年第四季盈利倒退近九成。收報83.55元,跌0.65%。 太地(1972):料香港寫字樓市況明後年才改善 ,零售商場市道已回穩。收報17.14元,升5.02%。 世茂(0813)境外債重組計劃獲高院批准。收報1.06元,升3.92%。

U.S. stock market loses $5 trillion in value in three weeks

A trader reacts while working on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on Feb. 25, 2025. Brendan Mcdermid | Reuters The S&P 500‘s rapid 10% decline from a record high into correction territory has wiped out trillions of dollars in market value. The market value of the S&P 500 at its Feb. 19

US stock futures rise Friday after a volatile week

Chipotle CEO says it will absorb tariff costs President Trump’s proposed tariffs on major trading partners are affecting the U.S. economy, but Chipotle plans to keep prices stable for their customers. Cheddar U.S. stocks are headed for a higher open, with futures up in pre-market activity. At 6:40 a.m. ET, futures tied to the broad

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x