Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana faces political headache

Khanyisile Ngcobo

BBC News, Johannesburg

Getty Images South Africa's finance minister Enoch Godongwana is seen pointing a finger as he prepares to table the national budget. He's wearing a dark blue suit, lighter blue shirt and red tie and has his hat and glasses on.Getty Images

South Africa has entered uncharted waters following deep divisions in the coalition government over the national budget that has finally been tabled after a month-long delay.

This is the view of analysts after Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana’s budget drew a backlash from various quarters, including key partners in the coalition government rejecting his proposals for a second time.

The African National Congress (ANC) formed a government of national unity (GNU) with nine other parties after losing its parliamentary majority in elections last year.

And, without the support of its biggest coalition partner, the Democratic Alliance (DA), it will fail to pass the budget unless it rethinks its contentious policies or gets the backing of the biggest opposition parties.

Godongwana was forced to postpone his budget presentation last month after fierce resistance to his plan to raise value-added-tax (VAT), which would have seen the prices of goods go up at a time when South Africans are hard-hit by the cost-of-living crisis.

This delay sent shockwaves through South Africa at the time, as it was the first time this had happened since the end of white-minority rule in 1994.

Following a series of meetings between the parties in government, Godongwana returned on Wednesday to present what he called a “bold and pragmatic” budget.

In his revised budget, the minister tried to appease his GNU partners by announcing a reduced VAT increase, to be implemented over a two-year period.

Godongwana had initially proposed increasing VAT from15% to 17%, but has now suggested raising it to 16% in two stages.

The minister says that increasing taxes is necessary to tackle “persistent spending pressures in health, education, transport and security”.

“They [other parties] have to make a choice – do we close schools, hospitals or clinics? They have to make that choice. Do we fire people? That is the choice we have to make and that is not a good choice to make,” Godongwana said.

The minister added that he had opted to target VAT rather than personal and corporate taxes, as the latter two would generate less revenue while “potentially harming investment, job creation and economic growth”.

Getty Images A street vendor counts rand banknotes at a corn and peanut stall in Johannesburg, South Africa, on 26 October 2024Getty Images

Critics say the budget will make it more difficult for people to eke out a living

Godongwana’s revised budget has the support of his party, the ANC, but has failed to appease the DA, which said it would not “support any increase in taxes, unless those increases were temporary and the ANC agreed to a series of major reforms” that would grow the economy, reduce waste and create jobs within the next three years.

The impasse has tarnished President Cyril Ramaphosa’s much-vaunted reputation as a deal-maker, with only one of his coalition partners – the small Patriotic Alliance (PA) – supporting the budget.

The latest tussle highlights deepening divisions in the fragile coalition government, as the two biggest parties have locked horns over key issues since its formation.

This includes a controversial land law, which allows for private property to be seized by the government in certain cases, without any compensation offered to owners.

The DA is challenging the law in court, arguing that it is unconstitutional and threatens property rights in South Africa.

The two biggest opposition parties – former President Jacob Zuma’s Umkhonto weSizwe (MK) and Julius Malema’s Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) – have also rejected the budget, saying the proposed tax hikes would hit the poor the hardest.

This leaves the ANC in a difficult situation, at it needs the support of at least one of the three other biggest parties to pass the budget.

An analyst at South Africa’s Wits University, Thokozile Madonko, says the deadlock over the budget has left South Africa in “uncharted waters”.

She tells the BBC that the role of parliament will now be “absolutely critical” as it either accepted, changed or rejected the budget.

And while in the past the ANC could always push through its policies, this is no longer the case.

This will force it to strike a deal with other parties or risk seeing the budget being voted down – something that could result in the collapse of the coalition government.

Getty Images Waving to the crowd, Democratic Alliance (DA) leader John Steenhuisen arrives to speak during a rally held in Willowmoore Stadium, Benoni on 26 May  2024 in Johannesburg, South AfricaGetty Images

The Democratic Alliance (DA) is serving in South Africa’s government for the first time ever

Ms Madonko criticised Godongwana’s decision to take the “laziest option” by proposing an increase in VAT, which will affect the entire population, rather than targeting the richest section of the population by introducing a “wealth tax” on them.

Another expert, Adrian Saville, said the budget was a “folly” as the minister repeated many old promises to promote economic growth and create jobs in a country where unemployment is standing at more than 30%.

“Those are words. Give us the numbers [and] tell us what you intend to do so that when we meet again in a year’s time, we know whether you’ve been successful or if you’ve fallen short,” he tells the BBC.

Godongwana has long been seen as a steady pair of hands, commanding the respect of both the business sector and the trade union movement.

But his credibility has taken a knock following the crisis over the budget. He now faces the challenge of salvaging his reputation by steering the budget through parliament – or people would increasingly question his suitability for the post.

More BBC stories on South Africa:
Getty Images/BBC A woman looking at her mobile phone and the graphic BBC News AfricaGetty Images/BBC

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Syria gets temporary constitution for five-year transition

Syria gets temporary constitution for five-year transition

Reuters Interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa said he hoped the move would be the start of “a new history for Syria” Syria’s interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa has signed a constitutional declaration covering a five-year transitional period, three months after his Islamist group led the rebel offensive that overthrew Bashar al-Assad. The document says Islam is the

High stakes as Iran nuclear issue reaches crunch moment

High stakes as Iran nuclear issue reaches crunch moment

Caroline Hawley BBC diplomatic correspondent Reuters Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has rejected the idea of negotiations with the US over its nuclear programme Almost a decade since world powers sealed a historic deal to limit the Iranian nuclear programme, this is a crunch moment for Iran and the international community. The country is

Sean "Diddy" Combs

Cassie’s Lawyer Slams Diddy’s Claims That Her Assault Video Was Altered: ‘Disingenuous Argument’

A lawyer for Sean “Diddy” Combs‘ ex-girlfriend, Cassandra “Cassie” Ventura, has responded to the rapper’s claims that the 2016 assault video released by CNN was edited. The attorney, Douglas Wigdor, slammed the allegations, adding that the video “fairly and accurately” represents the assault incident. He also expects that, regardless of the claims, the footage would be

Juvenile hit by vehicle, suffers serious injuries

Juvenile hit by vehicle, suffers serious injuries

1-minute read What to do if you’re in a car accident Tips for New Jersey drivers on what to do when involved in a motor vehicle collision. Miguel Fernandez, NorthJersey.com A juvenile was struck by a vehicle while walking in Maywood on Thursday night and suffered serious injuries, authorities said. The Bergen County Fatal Accident

Video shows green flames following Texas Tech underground explosion

Video shows green flames following Texas Tech underground explosion

Texas Tech University closes early after manhole explosion An underground explosion at Texas Tech University that caused “widespread power outages” is under investigation, according to university officials. The Texas Tech University campus in Lubbock remains closed after a manhole explosion apparently sparked a series of fires around campus Wednesday night. Video shows green flames coming up through

PHOTO: In this April 29, 2024, file photo, demonstrators from the pro-Palestine encampment on Columbia's Campus show a banner as they barricade themselves inside Hamilton Hall, in New York.

Columbia students who occupied Hamilton Hall in pro-Palestinian protest expelled, suspended

Columbia University said students who occupied the campus’ Hamilton Hall during pro-Palestinian protests last spring have been expelled, suspended for several years or had their degrees temporarily revoked. The sanctions were issued by the Columbia University Judicial Board on Thursday, the school said. “The outcomes issued by the UJB are based on its evaluation of

Vladimir Putin sets out conditions for Ukraine ceasefire

Vladimir Putin sets out conditions for Ukraine ceasefire

James Landale Reporting fromKyiv, Ukraine Getty Images Russian President Vladimir Putin said he agreed with the idea of a ceasefire in Ukraine, but that “questions” remained about the nature of a truce as he set out a number of tough conditions. The Russian president was responding to a plan for a 30-day ceasefire, which Ukraine

A boy throws ice into the sea in Nuuk, Greenland, Tuesday, March 11, 2025. (AP Photo/Evgeniy Maloletka)

AP Week in Pictures: Global

March 7 – 13, 2025 This photo gallery, curated by photo editor Eloy Martin, highlights some of the most compelling images worldwide made or published by The Associated Press in the past week. A boy throws ice into the sea in Nuuk, Greenland, Tuesday, March 11, 2025. (AP Photo/Evgeniy Maloletka) A boy throws ice into

'Killed in front of our eyes': Survivors reveal how the 36-hour Pakistan train hijacking unfolded

‘Killed in front of our eyes’: Survivors reveal how the 36-hour Pakistan train hijacking unfolded

Militants hijacked a train in southwestern Pakistan on Tuesday, holding passengers hostage for nearly 36 hours. The Pakistani military later announced on Wednesday that a successful rescue operation had ended the standoff, freeing the hostages and eliminating over 30 militants.Earlier on Tuesday, Mehboob Hussain was travelling when an explosion damaged the tracks beneath the front

Pakistan hints at India role in deadly train hijacking

Pakistan hints at India role in deadly train hijacking

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has hinted at India being behind the train hijacking in Balochistan this week, saying the handlers of the attackers were based in Afghanistan and were allegedly sponsored by India.On Thursday, Pakistan foreign office spokesperson Shafqat Ali Khan said Islamabad had evidence that calls related to the hijacking originated in Afghanistan. Asked by reporters

Evening Headlines

Canadian entrepreneur Jasmine Eagle detained by ICE

The latest headlines from our reporters across the US sent straight to your inbox each weekday Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US A Canadian businesswoman who was arrested in the United States by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents over an

Donatella steps down as creative director, Dario Vitale to take over

Donatella steps down as creative director, Dario Vitale to take over

Annabel Rackham Culture reporter Getty Images Donatella Versace pictured last week at the Vanity Fair Oscars party Donatella Versace is to step down from her creative director role at fashion house Versace, after nearly 30 years. She has held the position since 1997 and took over after the murder of her brother Gianni. Versace has

Peace talks are in parallel universe, say Ukraine front-line troops

Peace talks are in parallel universe, say Ukraine front-line troops

Jonathan Beale Defence correspondent, BBC News Reporting fromEastern Ukraine BBC Ukrainian soldiers on the battlefield say they don’t expect to see the war end any time soon While Moscow considers a temporary ceasefire, its military machine continues to press its advantage on the front line. Diplomatic negotiations can be slow and difficult. But on the

Former Canadian Deputy prime minister

Former Canadian Deputy prime minister

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. New York Times writer warns ‘Democracy Dies in Dumbness’ 10:42 ‘I get stopped everywhere’: Actress Natasha Rothwell on the popularity of ‘White Lotus’ 05:02 Rep. Jeffries slams Trump and House GOP for ‘far-right, extreme bill’ that will hurt Americans 04:23

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x