Opinion | Negative US narrative hurts Hong Kong relations and bewilders many
CSIS is a prominent Washington think tank focusing on US foreign policy and national security issues. It provides strategic insights and policy solutions to the US government, international institutions and the private sector.
Scott Kennedy, trustee chair in Chinese business and economics, and two of his colleagues visited Hong Kong in September 2023 to conduct their research. They met officials, former officials, business community members, investors, scholars, journalists and non-governmental organisations.
One can only assume that the trio felt utterly safe and comfortable conducting their research, notwithstanding their apparent grave concerns about the national security law introduced by the central government in 2020.
US consul general for Hong Kong and Macau Gregory May was the keynote speaker online. He endorsed the strength of people-to-people relationships between the US and Hong Kong, pointed out that the number of US firms in Hong Kong remains stable and highlighted that the US government was concerned about the political relationship and alleged erosion of freedoms.
In 2019, the proposed extradition bill prompted many critics to suggest that Hong Kong would use it to send people across the border to stand trial, claiming it would compromise Hong Kong’s judicial system and signal the demise of “one country, two systems”.
Barristers pose for a group photo after the senior counsel appointment ceremony at the Court of Final Appeal building in Hong Kong on May 11. Photo: Yik Yeung-man
However, even after the extradition bill was withdrawn, cases prosecuted since the implementation of the national security law, including that of Jimmy Lai Chee-ying, are being tried under Hong Kong’s legal system based on British common law principles.
The consul general also cited the release of Lai and the Hong Kong 47 as integral to the US re-establishing normal relations with our city. The 47 are the first to be accused of subversion under the national security law; 31 of them pleaded guilty before the trial commenced, and out of the remaining 16, 14 have been found guilty and two acquitted.
Meanwhile, Lai faces multiple charges and is going through due process of law in Hong Kong. His case is under intense scrutiny and regularly reported in the media. Just like in any other legal case, the defendant has the right to appeal to the Court of Appeal and, if that fails, to the Court of Final Appeal.
The US focus on the Lai trial could be seen as a bid to divert attention from the case of Julian Assange, who risks the death penalty if extradited to the United States from the United Kingdom for exposing alleged US war crimes in Afghanistan and Iraq. That the British High Court allowed Assange to appeal his extradition raises the question: will British judges be the next target of Washington’s sanctions?
Perhaps not. The US government seems more intent on threatening to sanction Hong Kong judges who participate in national security trials and, more recently, members of the International Criminal Court for following its chief prosecutor’s decision to seek arrest warrants for Israeli and Hamas leaders over alleged war crimes. The American willingness to arbitrarily attack other sovereign legal systems because it disagrees with their processes or rulings reflects its double standards.
US consul general Gregory May attends the opening ceremony of the Harvard Project for Asian and International Relations 2023 Asia Conference in Hong Kong on August 23. Photo: Jonathan Wong
In the case of Hong Kong, the US is using the threat of sanctions to intimidate our judges and undermine our legal independence, which is enshrined under one country, two systems.
Unfortunately, the US recently issued a heightened travel alert for Hong Kong, advising its citizens to exercise increased caution “due to the arbitrary enforcement of local laws”. Sadly, such unjust notices do little to encourage more significant interaction.
Thankfully, law-abiding American businesspeople and tourists understand they have no cause for concern when travelling to Hong Kong. They soon realise they are much safer in Hong Kong than in cities in their own country. If anything, they may find the alert confusing and misleading.
The ongoing negative narrative shows us that significant work remains ahead and that fostering direct people-to-people engagement will be crucial to achieving a favourable outcome for all stakeholders.
Bernard Chan is a Hong Kong businessmanandformer Executive Council convenor
The mother of murdered Hong Kong socialite Abby Choi Tin-fung has accused an ex-in-law of abusing her granddaughter, while insisting the former family member only agreed to look after two of the model’s children if she was offered money. Cheung Yin-fa continued to testify at District Court on Tuesday as part of the trial of
A 23-year-old woman has been arrested for allegedly disclosing the personal information of her former boyfriend after he dated someone else, Hong Kong’s privacy watchdog has said. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data apprehended the woman in the New Territories on Tuesday on suspicion of contravening the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance, following
Two international conferences will be held in Hong Kong for the first time this month, Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu has said, pledging that authorities will continue to attract more events to bring in high-end tourists and enhance the city’s global network. The city leader said on Tuesday that several global conferences had made their
An armed robber, who triggered a manhunt after he held a woman at knifepoint and stole HK$370,000 (US$47,180) from a Hang Seng Bank branch, is a Hongkonger and has fled across the border, the Post has learned. A source said on Tuesday that police’s elite tactical unit, the Flying Tiger, was searching for the local
What’s going on here? PwC’s Hong Kong operations are in turmoil as a wave of partner departures follows audit complications with China Evergrande and pivotal client losses. What does this mean? PwC is grappling with internal discord as audit-related issues with China Evergrande lead to a significant exodus of partners. In the last six months,
What’s going on here? On June 3, 2025, China and Hong Kong markets experienced gains, driven primarily by banking and automotive sectors, even as cautious investor sentiment lingered ahead of critical trade discussions. What does this mean? China’s main stock indices, including the blue-chip CSI300 and the Shanghai Composite, rose 0.5% by midday, rebounding from
Hong Kong’s leader has attributed his two meetings with Beijing’s newly appointed liaison office chief within three days to the need to maintain good communication and understanding with the central government, so he can reflect the city’s situation accurately and formulate good policies. Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu on Tuesday described Zhou Ji, the new
Hong Kong authorities will take action against anyone who threatens national security, the chief executive has warned, as the 36th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown approaches. Asked about the legality of commemorating June 4 by lighting candles or wearing clothing with related slogans in Causeway Bay, where annual vigils had been held for decades,
Principals in Hong Kong have criticised education authorities for failing to consult the sector regarding a new measure that permits popular schools to apply to operate an additional Form One class in the next academic year, raising concerns that the move will intensify competition among institutions. The Hong Kong Association of the Heads of Secondary
McDonald’s flagship store in Hong Kong is close to claiming the crown as the busiest in the fast-food chain’s global network of more than 40,000 outlets, a capstone in a half-century of operating in the city. The 9,000 sq ft (836 square metre) Admiralty Centre store, which reopened for business last month after a three-week
Hong Kong Airlines will launch flights to Urumqi in far western China in August and to Melbourne later, after making an ambitious comeback from a debt crisis three years ago and recording a 60 per cent year-on-year rise in passenger numbers in 2024. In an exclusive interview with the Post, airline president Jeff Sun Jianfeng
China is not a fan of cryptocurrencies. Over the past decade, the Chinese government has built up one of the world’s most hostile regulatory frameworks against cryptocurrency-related activities, including trading and mining. Beijing views digital assets like bitcoin as a threat to the country’s financial stability and capital account controls, and even a challenge to
By Reuters Published June 2, 2025 Hong Kong’s retail sales fell for a 14th straight month in April, government data showed on Monday, as local consumers remained cautious and visitors from mainland China spent less, although the decline was smaller than in March. Retail slump continues in Hong Kong: Fashion and jewelry sales decline. –
Sinographs June 2, 2025 • 1:20 pm ET Print this page Hong Kong highlights China’s policy of decoupling from US financial markets By Jeremy Mark As financial markets nervously adjust to President Donald Trump’s unpredictable tariff policy, an overlooked shift in US-China economic relations is taking place on the Hong Kong stock market. There, a
Five per cent of more than 90,000 critical infrastructure facilities in Hong Kong had “varying degrees of system vulnerabilities” last year, according to the cybercrime unit of the city’s police force. File photo: Sora Shimazaki, via Pexels. Credential leakage and compromise, hijackable subdomains, and exposed cloud storage were three critical and high-risk vulnerabilities identified in
Hong Kong law enforcement officers have arrested 43 women and two men on suspicion of being illegal sex workers and engaging in unlawful employment, with some found to be providing unlicensed massage services, condoms and lubricants. Police said on Monday that a cross-departmental operation, conducted from May 14 to 30 in Tsuen Wan, targeted illegal
Hong Kong police officers in tactical gear have been deployed at a major housing estate in a manhunt for a robber who held up a Hang Seng Bank branch with a knife and injured an employee before fleeing with HK$370,000 (US$47,180). Images seen by the Post show officers in tactical gear at block 50 of
The mother of slain Hong Kong socialite Abby Choi Tin-fung has claimed her former in-laws’ family “didn’t pay a penny” towards her two grandchildren’s living expenses, while alleging the model’s ex-mother-in-law took up to HK$80 million (US$10.2 million) from the deceased for investment. Testifying for the prosecution, Cheung Yin-fa on Monday recalled her encounters with
Hong Kong police have launched a manhunt for a robber who held up a Hang Seng Bank branch with a knife and injured a staff member before fleeing with HK$370,000 (US$47,180). Wearing a face mask and cap, the man entered the bank alone at Fortune City One shopping centre on Ngan Shing Street at about
