Ukrainians in war-ravaged Donbas weigh prospects of peace deal

Jonathan BealeDefence correspondent, Kyiv

Watch: Escaping Ukraine’s war-ravaged Donbas region.

Trains no longer run to Ukraine’s eastern Donetsk region – part of the Donbas claimed in its entirety by Russia’s President Vladimir Putin. It’s another sign of the steady Russian advance.

Instead, the last station is now on the western side of the Donetsk border. This is where civilians and soldiers wait for a ride towards relative safety – their train to get out of Dodge.

Putin has been sounding more bullish since the leak of US proposals to end the war, widely seen as being in tune with his maximalist demands. Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky says territory remains the most difficult issue facing US-led peace talks.

At the last station on the line, soldier Andrii and his girlfriend Polina are parting after an all-too-brief time together. Andrii has to return to the front and they don’t know when they’ll see each other again.

He laughs when I mention peace talks, which have seen Donald Trump’s envoys speak to Ukrainian negotiators before heading to Moscow, and dismisses them as “chatter, just chatter”. He doesn’t think the war will be over soon.

BBC/Matthew Goddard Denys, sitting on a train, looks down away from the camera, lips downturned. He is wearing military fatigues. BBC/Matthew Goddard

Soldier Denys is adamant that the Donbas should not be given to Russia in a peace deal

There is scepticism, too, among other soldiers who board the train west for a brief respite from the fighting. They are taking some of their 20 days of leave. Most look exhausted.

Russian forces now control some 85% of the Donbas, made up of Luhansk and Donetsk. On Tuesday they claimed to have captured the key strategic town of Pokrovsk in Donetsk. Ukraine said fighting was continuing in the city.

Denys, who has been serving in the Ukrainian army for the past two years, tells me “everyone’s drained, everyone’s tired mentally and physically”.

Some of his comrades have already fallen asleep. His unit has been fighting in the besieged city of Kostyantynivka.

“It’s scary, really scary,” he says, describing drones flying around “like flies”. But he makes it clear they are not ready to give up after sacrificing so much.

“Nobody will give Putin the Donbas. No way, it’s our land,” he says.

Ceding territory where at least a quarter of a million Ukrainians live – the Donetsk “fortress belt” cities of Slovyansk, Kramatorsk and Druzhkivka – will not be acceptable to most Ukrainians.

Russia has spent well over a year trying to capture Pokrovsk and Ukraine is reluctant to hand over such important strategic hubs.

But US officials believe Ukraine is both outnumbered and outgunned.

There’s already been an exodus of civilians from the Donbas. It’s continuing as peace talks take place. We witness dozens, old and young, arriving at a reception centre just over the border in Lozova.

They had taken advantage of heavy fog to make their escape. Less chance of being targeted by drones. Around 200 people arrive at this one reception centre every single day. They’re given basic supplies and some money.

BBC/Matthew Goddard A train station in the mist. You can see a cluster of soldiers on the station platform. BBC/Matthew Goddard

Refugees fleeing the Donbas take advantage of foggy conditions as visibility is reduced for enemy drones

Yevheniy and his wife Maryna have just arrived from Kramatorsk, along with their two children. She tells me there are “more drones now”. “It’s getting harder and harder to even go outside. Everything is dangerous,” she says. “Even going to the shop, you might not come back.”

The family are planning to move to the capital, Kyiv. Yevheniy has little faith in the peace talks. He says “that side [Russia] won’t agree to our terms. We understand nothing good will come of it”.

But others appear more willing to contemplate giving up their home for good in return for peace.

Oleksandr says it is too dangerous to stay. His children have already gone to Germany. While he describes Russia’s maximalist demands as “probably unacceptable”, he appears willing to contemplate some of what was in the leaked peace plan – trading territory for peace. The original version of the US draft envisaged that areas of Donbas still under Ukrainian control be handed over to Russia de facto.

“Personally I would agree to those terms,” he says.

BBC/Matthew Goddard An out of focus image of a man facing away from the camera out of the window through a crack in the curtains.  BBC/Matthew Goddard

“Serhii” has been in hiding since he deserted his unit in May

Inna, escaping with her five children, also believes it’s time to make a deal. She could no longer hide her kids, aged between nine months and 12 years, from the dangers of living in Kramatorsk. She had tried telling them the explosions they heard while seeking shelter in their cellar were just fireworks.

“The main thing is that there will be peace,” Inna says. When I ask whether that means giving up her home for good, she replies, “in this situation, yes”. They’re already making plans to rebuild their lives elsewhere.

Some soldiers sent to the Donbas are also voting with their feet. There have been nearly 300,000 cases of desertion, or soldiers going absent without official leave, since the start of Russia’s full scale invasion – and numbers have risen dramatically over the past year.

One of them is Serhii – not his real name. We met him in hiding. His home has become his prison as he tries to evade arrest. Serhii volunteered to fight at the start of the year, whereas most of the men in his unit were forcibly mobilised – “taken off the street”.

He says his unit was already below strength when it was sent to the front, near Pokrovsk, and they weren’t properly trained or equipped. “I ended up in a battalion where everything was a mess,” he says, although he still believes this was the exception, not the norm.

Serhii deserted in May after two of his friends went awol.

“I wouldn’t have gone if we had proper leadership and someone experienced in charge,” he says. “I came to serve, not to run”.

Serhii is still thinking about his next move, and the possibility of returning to the army. But he echoes recent US warnings that the odds in this war are stacked against Ukraine.

Asked whether he believes Ukraine can win, he is doubtful. “If you think logically, no. A country of 140 million against us with 32 million – logically it doesn’t add up.”

Additional reporting by Mariana Matveichuk

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Pope prays at site of Beirut port blast at end of Lebanon visit

Pope prays at site of Beirut port blast at end of Lebanon visit

Reuters Pope Leo said he was “deeply moved” by his visit to the site of the Beirut port blast Pope Leo XIV led a silent prayer at the site of the Beirut port explosion and demanded justice for its victims, as he wrapped up his three-day visit to Lebanon. He also met some relatives of

GOP Civil War Brewing as Elise Stefanik Trashes Mike Johnson

GOP Civil War Brewing as Elise Stefanik Trashes Mike Johnson

(Rod Lamkey/AP photos) Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) blasted House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) in a social media tirade on Tuesday, accusing him of getting “rolled” by Democrats and turning against Republicans aligned with President Donald Trump. It all started on Monday when Stefanik posted a screed on X, saying Johnson was “getting rolled by House

Protestors gather at High Court over council decision to fly Palestine flag

Protestors gather at High Court over council decision to fly Palestine flag

Caoimhin McNulty/PA Protestors have gathered outside the High Court as a case is being heard over procedures used to decide to vote on flying the Palestinian flag over Belfast City Hall. A 20-year-old man was arrested on suspicion of disorderly behaviour and remains in custody. The proposal, from Sinn Féin, was passed by 32 to

Alibaba logo on a lawn.

Why This AI Cloud Stock Could Be the Market’s Biggest Sleeper

Alibaba has a better valuation than the big three AI cloud stocks. There are a few different ways to invest in artificial intelligence (AI) cloud stocks. Some of the biggest companies in the world — Amazon (AMZN +1.11%), Microsoft, and Alphabet — are the industry leaders in the cloud computing space, occupying the top three

Jury trials scrapped for crimes with sentences of less than three years

Jury trials scrapped for crimes with sentences of less than three years

Dominic Casciani,Home and legal correspondentand Tom McArthur EPA Jury trials in England and Wales for crimes that carry a likely sentence of less than three years will be scrapped, the justice secretary has announced. The reforms to the justice system include creating “swift courts” under the government’s plan to tackle unprecedented delays in the court

Jenny McCall

US growth forecast rises; Lutnick confirms South Korea’s 15% tariff rate

The US Supreme Court is poised in the weeks ahead to decide the legality of the majority of President Trump’s tariffs. The president invoked the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to levy blanket tariffs on goods from other countries. But Congress is the branch of the US government with oversight of taxation and spending

AI Radical to Accused Cult Leader

AI Radical to Accused Cult Leader

Z iz Lasota and Gwen Danielson had reached a stalemate. It was nighttime on the Caleb, the ancient steel-hulled tugboat where they had spent the last five months of 2017, anchored in the outer harbor of Pillar Point, 25 miles south of San Francisco. With their high cheekbones, dimpled chins, and penetrating gazes, the pair

Jenny McCall

Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq futures edge higher as Wall Street regains its footing

US stock futures edged higher on Tuesday, eyeing a cautious comeback after a fragile start to December trading that saw sharp losses on Wall Street and in crypto. S&P 500 (ES=F) futures rose 0.3%, while those on the tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 (NQ=F) added roughly 0.4%. Contracts on the Dow Jones Industrial Average (YM=F) hovered above

Elon Musk's cryptic statement about war has ignited discussions about geopolitical tensions, nuclear deterrence, and the future of international relations.(Bloomberg)

Elon Musk says war ‘inevitable’ within 5 to 10 years, but gives no other detail

Elon Musk’s latest comment on X has sent ripples across the platform, with the tech mogul declaring that a major global conflict is no longer a distant fear but an imminent reality. Known for his blunt takes, the billionaire didn’t hesitate to predict that war could break out within the next decade. Elon Musk’s cryptic

Tracking the war with Russia

Tracking the war with Russia

the Visual Journalism teamBBC News BBC Fighting has raged in Ukraine since Russia launched a full-scale invasion more than three years ago. Over the past year, Russian forces have slowly expanded the amount of territory they control, mostly in the east of Ukraine, and have continued their recent barrage of air strikes on Kyiv and

Jenny McCall

US and UK agree zero-rate pharma tariffs; Lutnick confirms S. Korea’s 15% tariff rate

The US Supreme Court is poised in the weeks ahead to decide the legality of the majority of President Trump’s tariffs. The president invoked the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to levy blanket tariffs on goods from other countries. But Congress is the branch of the US government with oversight of taxation and spending

US authorised second deadly Venezuela boat strike, White House says

US authorised second deadly Venezuela boat strike, White House says

Watch: White House defends Venezuela boat strikes, says Admiral Bradley acted legally A top US Navy admiral ordered a second round of strikes on an alleged Venezuelan drug boat, the White House has confirmed. The “double tap” strike on 2 September has drawn bipartisan scrutiny among US lawmakers. The Washington Post recently reported that two

'My electricity bill went to $8/month'

‘My electricity bill went to $8/month’

Solar installations are continuing their upward trend as temperatures also climb and electricity prices skyrocket. One Redditor, representing a clean energy company, wanted to know how people decided to make the switch. “For anyone who already went solar — what was the moment that convinced you it was actually worth it?” they asked. One person

US President Donald Trump.(AFP)

Trump’s Tweaks Will Help Endangered Species

The Endangered Species Act of 1973 is one of America’s most far-reaching environmental laws. It can stop projects, block land use, and impose sweeping restrictions to protect wildlife. Yet after more than half a century and billions of dollars, only 3% of species deemed threatened or endangered under the act have recovered and are no

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt at Monday’s press briefing. (WSJ)

New White House Website Takes Aim at Journalists and News Outlets

The White House published a website detailing what it calls “false and misleading” media coverage, the latest in a series of unorthodox steps by the Trump administration against media outlets. PREMIUM White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt at Monday’s press briefing. (WSJ) The official government site, which went live late last week, identifies news outlets

Venezuela's President Nicolás Maduro in Caracas, Sept. 15.

What Comes After Maduro Falls

Propagandists who support Venezuela’s Nicolás Maduro are trying to stoke fears that the fall of the narco-dictator could plunge the country into civil war. They use this argument to justify the survival of an increasingly isolated, authoritarian and unpopular regime. But it doesn’t reflect reality. Far from causing a power vacuum, a transition from Mr.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x