Ukraine got the go-ahead to hit Russia with F-16s, but doing so could be a waste of a good jet

  • Denmark says Ukraine can use the F-16s it plans to give to hit military targets in Russia.

  • Experts say that may not the best use for the jets.

  • Ukraine hasn’t been promised many, making each one a valuable prize for Russia.

NATO member Denmark has given Ukraine permission to use the F-16s it receives to hit military targets within Russia.

It is unclear if Ukraine has any intention of using its F-16s in this way, or if doing so would mean the jets themselves enter Russia or just their munitions, but military experts told Business Insider it may not be the best use for them regardless, at least right now.

Denmark’s decision is part of a wider and influential shift in NATO oversight of the weapons sent to Ukraine, a loosening of the restrictions on how Ukraine is allowed to fight the war.

Since Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022, partner nations have prevented Ukraine from hitting military targets within Russia, giving Moscow a safe space to stage attacks and putting Ukraine at a huge disadvantage. Over the course of the war, many attacks have been launched from inside Russian territory. Analysts have described this situation as Ukraine fighting a war with one hand tied behind its back.

But some of Ukraine’s international partners have been changing their approach over the past few weeks. And now Denmark is the first country to give the go-ahead for the coming F-16s. Just because it can, though, doesn’t mean it should.

A big danger

Ukraine is expected to get its first F-16s this summer. George Barros, a Russian military expert at the US-based Institute for the Study of War think tank, said “it doesn’t make a lot of military sense” to use the American-made fighter jets to “strike into Russia at this time.”

“Because the deeper you go into Russia and the closer you get to the border, the more dangerous it is for you to fly,” and it’s more likely that you lose high-end equipment and trained pilots not easily replaced, he said.

An Israeli F-16 fighter jet fires a 'Rampage' air-to-ground rocket in an undated photograph.An Israeli F-16 fighter jet fires a 'Rampage' air-to-ground rocket in an undated photograph.

Illustrative: An Israeli F-16 fighter jet.Israeli Military Industries Systems and Israel Aerospace Industries

Barros said that in the future, particularly with more jets, that would be a great use for them, “but that’s not where we are now.”

Ukraine’s ability to use other weapons to hit Russia is a big boost for Ukraine, but it’s not necessarily the best thing for a fairly small fleet of F-16s.

Mark Cancian, a retired Marine Corps colonel and a defense strategy expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said that he suspects “that the F-16s will stay back from the front lines to avoid the Russian air defense envelope.”

F-16s, when armed with anti-radiation missiles like the AGM-88 HARM missiles provided by the US, can be used to target air defenses in suppression and destruction missions, but those can be challenging, high-risk operations.

F-16s are big targets

Tim Robinson, a military aviation specialist at the UK’s Royal Aeronautical Society, said the F-16s could be useful for hitting targets that are in Russia but out of range for other weapons. The aircraft has that capability, but striking into Russia is a risky mission, particularly for a fourth-generation aircraft that first flew in 1974.

He suspects that Ukraine, having “finally got them,” will want to ensure “they don’t lose them straight away.”

Ukraine has been fighting hard to get F-16s since the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion, but the US prohibited other countries operating the jet from sending them to Ukraine until it changed its mind in May 2023.

Peter Layton, a fellow at the Griffith Asia Institute and a former Royal Australian Air Force officer, said that Ukraine will want to keep its aircraft “safe.”

Ukraine will have to be more cautious with its F-16s, as it is not getting a lot, experts say.

The exact number of F-16s Ukraine will get to begin with is unclear, but it’s not expected to be many. Ukraine has been promised a total of an estimated 85 jets by Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway and Belgium. And France is sending an unspecified number of its Mirage 2000-5 fighters. This is a boost, but Ukraine can’t afford to suffer tremendous losses.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy sits in front of and  looks back at Denmark's Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen as they sit in a F-16 fighter jetUkrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy sits in front of and  looks back at Denmark's Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen as they sit in a F-16 fighter jet

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy and Denmark’s Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen sit in a F-16 fighter jet at Skrydstrup Airbase in Vojens, Denmark, in August 2023.Ritzau Scanpix/Mads Claus Rasmussen via REUTERS

A problem is that Ukraine is expected to receive more F-16s than it has trained pilots. A lack of available training spots in Arizona, Denmark, and Romania means that only around 20 Ukrainian F-16 pilots will be trained this year, Politico reported, thus limiting the number of jets Ukraine can fly into battle.

The number of warplanes aside, there’s also a political aspect to Ukraine needing to keep its jets in the air.

Professor Michael Clark, a Russia and Ukraine expert and a British national security advisor, said Ukraine has been managing expectations over how effective the aircraft will be. Ukraine has suggested that the aircraft will be extremely useful against Russia, but there is a risk of backlash over losses or failure to secure a major breakthrough.

He said that while analysts “know that warfare is full of setbacks and things that don’t go right first time and so on,” a “manifest failure of an F-16 offensive would be politically very damaging for the Ukrainians,” especially among some US Republicans and groups that are reluctant to back Ukraine.

As a result, Clark said, the Ukrainians are likely thinking that for its F-16s, “it’d be better to hold them back until they can be more confident rather than throw them in quickly, hoping that they’ll be okay, because the chances are they won’t.”

Cancian said losing F-16s, particularly with so few promised to Ukraine, would be seen as “a big deal.”

He said some expectations put on Ukraine’s F-16s are unfair. US air strength, for instance, can come from the employment of “hundreds of aircraft with extensive support systems on the ground,” the air fleet and ground infrastructure that Ukraine’s embattled air forces lack.

Avoiding Russia

The experts said that the jets likely won’t go into Russia because of the dangers there. If they do, it would like be rare. Even flying over Russian-occupied territory is dangerous.

Cancian said there may be “one or two deep raids maybe over Crimea just for the symbolic and psychological effect, but as a routine use, no, it’s just too dangerous.”

Notably, though, Ukraine has been increasingly targeting air defense systems on the occupied peninsula and elsewhere.

ISW suspects “Ukrainian forces may be conducting an organized effort to degrade Russian air defenses, which could enable Ukraine to more effectively leverage manned fixed-wing airpower (namely using F-16 fighter jets) in the long term.”

And Ukraine has demonstrated a willingness to make bold plays.

Layton acknowledged Ukraine might attempt something daring, noting that they have conducted some other risky moves that have given them big wins, like taking down Russian aircraft.

“Tactically, they are very smart,” he said. “So while I think they wouldn’t do it, if they did it, it would be very carefully organized and fairly quick.” But in general, he said, going into Russia “makes them far too vulnerable.”

“I personally think that the Ukrainians will be foolish to put their aircraft in quite small numbers across the border because I think that the Russians will outnumber them,” he said.

Robinson noted Russia has a “massive air defense network” that would target the jets, which lack stealth characteristics like fifth-gen jets. Ukraine has a network like this too, and it’s why Russian jets have barely entered Ukrainian-held airspace. But in Russia, Ukrainian aircraft can also expect to battle the Russian Air Force in addition to enemy air defenses.

A rocket launches from a S-400 missile system against a dark blue skyA rocket launches from a S-400 missile system against a dark blue sky

A rocket launches from a Russian S-400 air defense system.DIMITAR DILKOFF/AFP via Getty Images

“The problem is that there’s not going to be very many F-16s, and they will be very vulnerable as they fly over Russian territory,” Mark Cancian said.

F-16s may hang back

Instead, Cancian said, he expects them to be used mostly defensively — used away from the front, protecting cities and infrastructure from Russia’s drones and missiles. The F-16 can play defense well and has been prominent in the post-9/11 Noble Eagle mission defending US and Canadian airspace.

He said F-16s “aren’t going to be flying over the front lines, but they don’t really need that,” as other weapons can hit into Russia and defend the front lines.

Layton agreed the best use for Ukraine’s first F-16s would be defensive, staying in Ukrainian territory in an air-defense role to shoot down Russia’s drones and cruise missiles.

a gray fighter aircraft turned on its side while flyinga gray fighter aircraft turned on its side while flying

An F-16 Fighting Falcon banks left.US Air Force photo by Senior Airman Chanceler Nardone

But he was more bullish on Ukraine hitting targets in Russia, saying that it could do it without flying the aircraft into Russia, as he suspects that Ukraine will likely get the right intelligence to do such a hit without taking too much risk.

A key aspect of what kind of missions the F-16 can fly is what kind of missiles and bombs the jet is carrying. Ukraine does not currently have the full range of capabilities.

Ukraine’s pilots could, however, be able to master defensive action the fastest, and it would likely be the most effective thing Ukraine could do without a greater number of aircraft, the experts said. It would also bolster a capability that has been heavily strained by relentless Russian attacks, and that’s air defense.

Experts said they don’t expect the F-16s to make a massive difference in the war by themselves, particularly without more of them. But they said these fighter jets will be useful for Ukraine by replenishing lost aircraft, deterring Russian jets, and acting as defenses.

“Whenever they arrive,” Cancian said, “that’s a good time for Ukraine because they will add to Ukraine’s military capability.”

Robinson said the F-16s will “make Russian pilots there a little bit more kind of wary, a little bit more careful about what they’re going up against.”

Read the original article on Business Insider

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Ecuador election ends in a 'tie' prompting run-off in April

Ecuador election ends in a ‘tie’ prompting run-off in April

Ione Wells South America correspondent Reuters The campaign was dominated by the incumbent, Daniel Noboa’s hard-line approach to Ecuador’s violent drug gangs Ecuador’s presidential election will go to a second round after a closely contested first-round result failed to produce an outright winner. The electoral authorities called it a “technical tie” after the incumbent centre-right

Donald Trump to announce raft of new trade tariffs including on steel

Donald Trump to announce raft of new trade tariffs including on steel

João da Silva Business reporter Reuters President Donald Trump has said he will announce a 25% import tax on all steel and aluminium entering the US, a move that will have the biggest impact in Canada. Trump also said that there would be an announcement later in the week about reciprocal tariffs on all countries

Taylor Swift speaks to musician and actress, Alana Haim in the stands. Pic: Reuters

Super Bowl 2025: Donald Trump makes history – as Taylor Swift booed | US News

Celebrities including Taylor Swift, Jay-Z, Sir Paul McCartney and Bradley Cooper were out in force for arguably America’s biggest sporting event of the year – the Super Bowl – as the Philadelphia Eagles beat the Kansas City Chiefs 40-22. But it wasn’t just the stars of music and acting who were among the crowds to

Taylor Swift, Jay-Z and Donald Trump among stars in New Orleans

Taylor Swift, Jay-Z and Donald Trump among stars in New Orleans

50 minutes ago Thomas Mackintosh BBC News, London Reuters Taylor Swift – pictured in between two of the Haim sisters – watching boyfriend Travis Kelce’s Chiefs at her second Super Bowl appearance One of the biggest sporting events in the world is under way in New Orleans as the Kansas City Chiefs take on the

US President Donald Trump stands as US singer-songwriter Jon Baptiste performs the National Anthem ahead of Super Bowl LIX between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Philadelphia Eagles at Caesars Superdome in New Orleans, Louisiana, February 9, 2025. (Photo by TIMOTHY A. CLARY / AFP) (Photo by TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images)

Who Was Missing From Donald Trump’s Super Bowl Entourage

President Donald Trump’s posse at Sunday’s Super Bowl game in New Orleans included Eric Trump, Lara Trump, Ivanka Trump and her son. But as the other members of the first family watched the Kansas City Chiefs and the Philadelphia Eagles vie for the championship, first lady Melania Trump was nowhere to be found. Melania Trump

US News Live: Super Bowl and close referee calls: Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles get controversial flags

US News Live Today February 10, 2025: Super Bowl and close referee calls: Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles get controversial flags

US News Live: Get real-time breaking news updates on the biggest event unfolding in the United States, including election, politics, economics, crime, viral and more. US News Live: Super Bowl and close referee calls: Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles get controversial flags US News Live: Get the latest updates and breaking news from the

Frogmore Cottage

Duke of York ‘strikes deal to make money off Pitch@Palace contacts’

The Duke of York has reportedly struck a deal to earn money by sharing contacts he made through his Pitch@Palace initiative. Prince Andrew could earn millions under the deal with Startupbootcamp (SBC), based in the Netherlands, from the project which aimed to connect entrepreneurs with investors. Pitch@Palace has faced scrutiny since Yang Tengbo, an alleged

Palestinians cross back to their homes after the Israeli army withdrew from the Netzarim corridor, as part of the ceasefire agreement with Hamas. The corridor was created to separate the Gaza strip into northern and southern areas. Abed Rahim Khatib/dpa

Israel pulls out of key Gaza corridor as Cairo to host crisis talks

Following the latest hostage-for-prisoner exchange under the current ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas, the Israeli military withdrew from the strategic Netzarim Corridor in the Gaza Strip on Sunday. The corridor divides the coastal strip into northern and southern halves. The army’s departure means internally displaced people can return from the south of the Gaza

CFPB

White House Orders Consumer Protection Agency Shutdown

The Trump administration has ordered an effective shutdown of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), directing the agency to stop investigations, suspend rule implementations, and cease supervision activities. Russell Vought, the newly appointed director of the Office of Management and Budget, issued the order in a Saturday night email. Newsweek reached out to the White

Palestinians making their way past the rubble after Israeli forces withdrew from the Netzarim Corridor on Sunday.

Israel completes withdrawal from key road dividing Gaza as part of ceasefire deal

CNN  —  Israel completed its withdrawal from the Netzarim Corridor on Sunday, a key road that splits Gaza in half, as part of its commitments under a ceasefire agreement with Hamas. Palestinians have been filing through the area by foot, car and in some cases, by donkeys video footage showed, although those traveling must navigate

Boy, 17, charged with attempted murder in Northampton

Boy, 17, charged with attempted murder in Northampton

Mark Bulstrode/BBC A man was stabbed on Wednesday in Northampton and was said to now be in a stable condition A 17-year-old boy has been charged with attempted murder after a man was stabbed. Police were called after a 29-year-old man was attacked on Monarch Road in Northampton on Wednesday between 18:30 and 18:45 GMT.

Sir Richard Branson and crew after landing from Virgin Galactic's test flight July 11, 2021.

Will Virgin Galactic Abandon the Space Tourism Business?

Virgin Galactic may have found a better way to make money in space. In June 2024, space tourism pioneer Virgin Galactic (SPCE -4.67%) launched its Unity spaceplane with a planeload of space tourists for the last time. In the months since, the company has continued working on its new spaceplane, dubbed the Delta class. Expected

Reform UK press conference

Delays to local elections not a ‘stitch-up’ – Angela Rayner

Angela Rayner has denied that delays to local elections are a “stitch-up” after votes in nine council areas due to be held in May were postponed. The Deputy Prime Minister, was asked about the perception that Labour could be delaying elections due to a fear of Reform UK making gains, after Nigel Farage accused the

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x